Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Συστημικό υπολογιστικό πλαίσιο για την αποτίμηση αειφορίας και την υποστήριξη αποφάσεων σε αρχικά στάδια ανάπτυξης και σχεδιασμού βιοδιυλιστηρίων

Abstract

dc:description

Purpose The concept of sustainable development has gained significant ground in process design. The basis of decision making along the process development stages has been enlarged from the traditional economic criteria to incorporate also other important considerations such as environmental and social aspects. Production processes from renewable sources (e.g. biomass feedstocks) appear as competitive options to the conventional fossil-based equivalents, making the assessment of their sustainability performance a necessary tool for their establishment as technologically mature choices. On top of that, the innovative character of bio-based production, and therefore, of data availability and access on detailed process modelling, is a challenging point for decision makers to move towards this direction.The scope of this PhD thesis is to support decisions in early stages of the development and design of biorefineries, on the basis of sustainability criteria with regard to their production processes over a range of impacts. Representative examples of impacts considered in this research work are the use of resources (such as water and energy), the environmental degradation of ecosystems (eutrophication, acidification, etc.) and the impacts on human health.Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is generally considered as a suitable methodology for the evaluation of the LCA metrics of processes. However, it requires large amount and often inaccessible process data at the early design stages. The present study provides an approach to streamline LCA for a broad set of biomass process chains. The proposed method breaks away from conventional LCA work in that its purpose is to support decision at early stages, assuming minimal use of data available and pointing to the most dominant LCA impacts, thus providing useful feedback to process design.The study aims at the development of a framework for estimation of LCA metrics of bio-based chemicals and fuels using information which can be accessed in early design stages. Thus, assessments can be conducted “ahead of (detailed) design” without detailed process inventories, (i.e. mass and energy balances and emissions) and without models as process simulators and LCA software tools.The innovative element of the present computational framework is that it supports decision making that can direct design choices in early stages, using methods such as decision trees that give approximate estimates, in the range of a class label, through a sequence of rules and/or neural networks when a numerical estimation is necessary, avoiding the analytical and time-consuming steps to assess the possible design options which are the current practice. Instead, conventional methods start by simulating the individual production processes using simulation tools (e.g. Aspen Plus), analyze flows, compile inventory tables and use LCA softwares (e.g. SimaPro, Umberto ).Materials and Methods The proposed computational framework employs decision trees and neural networks as modeling techniques, which are able to analyze data and identify patterns and parameters, which formulate the environmental profile of biorefinery systems. Decision trees are used which form “if-then rules”, using a set of critical parameters of the process chain with respect to various environmental impacts. The models classify products into three classes, namely having low, medium and high environmental impact. Neural Networks were also employed as a commonly used method for mapping relations among input and output data and creating prediction models.The primary information for training the models refer to the thirty-three products produced from various synthesis paths which represent the most important groups found in literature. Products are derived from 52 unit processes which form 92 study systems developed from the appropriate combination of these unit processes producing products of interest. Twenty-three LCA metrics were selected as target attributes (one for each model), according to the ReCiPe and the Cumulative Energy Demand (CED) methods which provide a wide range of metrics for various environmental issues such as climate change, eutrophication, acidification, etc., and the non renewable fossil energy demand. Target attributes for the corresponding products were estimated using the LCA method according to the ISO 14040 for each study system. The functional unit, the reference flow on the basis of which the assessment and the overall analysis is referred, is 1kg of product. Values of LCA metrics of each observation of the dataset are also provided for three allocation approaches (mass, market price, substitution).Descriptor variables refer to the molecular structure of the product of interest and process-chain related variables corresponding to chemistry, complexity and generic process conditions (e.g. process chain temperature ranges, efficiency factors etc., number of processing steps for the synthesis of the final product). Descriptor variables are arranged into two sets of 24 and 30 input variables depending on the level of access on early design stages, i.e. lab scale and conceptual design level respectively. In total, 138 datasets are compiled (23 LCA metrics x 3 allocation approaches x 2 sets of full/reduced input attributes) for the modelling task.Results and discussion The obtained results demonstrate that the average classification error for the decision trees ranges between 13.4% and 43.8% for the various LCA metrics and allocation approaches. Allocation approaches present a better classification performance (up to 25% error) compared to the substitution approach for many LCA metrics such as Climate Change, CED, and Human Health. For the majority of models low and high output classes are characterized by better predictive performance compared to the medium class. The interpretability of selected decision trees is analysed in terms of pruning levels and “irrational” branches. The results of the application of the decision trees for recently published case studies show that nine out of thirteen cases and seven out of sixteen were correctly classified for CED and CC metrics, respectively. Additionally, cases where models overestimated and underestimated class labels were also quantified providing their suitability to support decision making in early stages of design.Neural network models are able to estimate LCA metrics and their estimation capability is expressed as the average R2CV values (coefficient of determination) as a result of 500 iterations in a cross validation procedure. Values for R2CV range between close to 0 (e.g. for various environmental issues such as freshwater eutrophication (FE), freshwater ecotoxicity (FET), water depletion, etc. for all allocation scenarios) to 0.8 (for instance for energy and climate change related metrics).Conclusions and recommendations The proposed approach provides a first generation of models in the form of computationally inexpensive and easily interpretable decision trees, that can be used as pre-screening tools for the environmental assessment of bio-based production ahead of detailed design and conventional LCA approaches. The transparent structure of the decision trees as well as the neural network modelling capabilities facilitate the identification of critical decision variables, thus providing insights for improvement in terms of process parameters, biomass feedstock or even targeted product.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2018

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Karka, Paraskevi
  • Κάρκα, Παρασκευή

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/43905

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Karka, Paraskevi; Κάρκα, Παρασκευή. Συστημικό υπολογιστικό πλαίσιο για την αποτίμηση αειφορίας και την υποστήριξη αποφάσεων σε αρχικά στάδια ανάπτυξης και σχεδιασμού βιοδιυλιστηρίων. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2018. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/43905