Back to search

University of Patras

An integrated design process for durable concrete structures at the minimum environmental cost: application with the incorporation of rice husk ash

Abstract

dc:description

The construction industry is the largest consumer of materials in our society. Approximately 40% of all materials used are related to this section of the industry. Equivalent is the impact of the sector’s activities to the environment in terms of non-renewable energy sources (grey energy), gas emissions (mainly CO₂), solid waste, etc. With concrete being the most widely used construction material (second only to water in total volumes consumed annually by society) and cement being the essential “glue” in concrete, emphasis should be placed on investigating and enforcing ways, methodologies and policies, to make cement manufacturing and the construction industry in general a more environmental friendly sector. At the same time, by considering, at one hand the significant amount of research and breakthroughs achieved on structural materials and design, as well as the level of sophistication of the modern European Standards and structural codes, and on the other hand, the increasing cases of premature deterioration of concrete structures, particular emphasis should also be placed on safeguarding the service life of reinforced concrete structures (in addition to tackling their environmental burden). That is why it is very important to introduce the sustainable way of thinking and the concept of industrial ecology on the preliminary design stages of a structure, on the material selection process and on the service life estimation stage, in achieving a robust durable reinforced concrete (RC) structure (for a given service life) with the minimum environmental burden. ► Thus, the main objective of the present Thesis is to focus on identifying and quantifying a structured framework of the appropriate methodologies in formulating an Integrated Design Process (IDP) for the design of durable and sustainable structures at the minimum environmental and economical cost (without compromising issues of structural safety) and also in identifying and demonstrating ways of industrial ecology for the sustainable development ofthe cement and construction industry. A significant step forward for a thorough durability design process of reinforced concrete structures is the development of software packages, based on predictive models, for the estimation of concrete strength and service life. Such an attempt, in full compliance with the European Standards for cement and concrete, is presented in Chapter 2. Upon defining the concrete mix design, the software calculates the main chemical and volumetric characteristics, as well as the compressive strength, of concrete. By taking into account the environmental conditions where the structure will be exposed, concrete service life is predicted, using fundamental mathematical models (based on reaction engineering principles) that simulate the reinforced concrete deterioration mechanisms leading to corrosion of the embedded reinforcement (caused by either carbonation or chloride ingress). A validation process of the yielded results is also presented, and the effectiveness of the simulation tool in designing for durability is illustrated. The goal of this study is to promote wider acceptance in achieving feasible and durable solutions to structural concrete design problems. Considering the well-known environmental issues of cement manufacturing (direct and indirect levels of CO₂ emissions), clinker replacement by supplementary cementing materials (SCM) can be a very promising first step in reducing considerably the associated emissions. However, such a reduction is possible up to a particular level of SCM utilization, influenced by the rate of its pozzolanic reaction. In Chapter 3, a (4-step) structured methodology is proposed in order to be able to further adjust the concrete mix design of a particular SCM, in achieving additional reduction of the associated levels of CO₂ emissions and being at the same time accepted from a derived concrete strength and service life point of view. On this note, the aim of this study is twofold. To evaluate the environmental contribution of each concrete component and to provide the best possible mix design configuration, balanced between the principles of sustainability (low environmental cost) and durability (accepted concrete strength and service life). It was proved that such a balance can be achieved by utilising SCM by-products in the concrete mix, reducing in this way the fixed environmental emissions without compromising the long-term safety and durability of the structure. Utilization of biomass ash from agro-industrial by-products (containing large amounts of silica in amorphous form) in cement manufacturing and/or concrete production can be an alternative solution to the incorporation of the traditionally used supplementary cementing materials (SCM). An evaluation of biomass ashes, identified in the literature, with varying SiO₂ contents in terms of concrete strength and performance in chloride exposure is the focus of Chapter 4. Results indicate that these materials are effective on concrete strength development and extremely efficient in reducing the concrete permeability. The dependency of this behavior on the level of SiO₂ of the ash content was examined in depth and was concluded that it is affected by the composition of other components of the biomass ash. Main objective of Chapter 5 is to identify the detailed economical outcome for rice hush ash (RHA) valorization technique as a pozzolanic material and main biomass ash. A techno-economical analysis of producing advanced and high-added value material from RHA is presented. The study was elaborated in the framework of pilot production in a Greek rice industry. The importance of the issues examined is further enhanced by the emphasis given nowadays on adaptation of energy and emissions reducing solutions by the construction industry. Utilization of supplementary cementing materials (SCM) in concrete design, such as RHA, should be a very promising first step in reducing considerably the associated materials environmental footprint. In contrast to common approach – that often involves extensive pre-grinding - the utilization potential of RHA as an SCM, in its untreated form was further examined. This is to meet industry’s increasing awareness for lower embodied energy cement and concrete. Given the availability of current raw materials in cement manufacturing, what is needed is to be able to achieve an optimum approach, between sustainability and durability when designing concrete structures. Under this frame, as produced RHAs (D50 of approx. 70 microns) were examined with respect to their inherent characteristics and their impact on the performance of cement-based mortars. Strength, hydration and durability properties were considered. Untreated RHA exhibits moderate pozzolanicity and a low efficiency factor of approximately 0.5-0.6. Its very high chemical reactivity (active silica ratio of approx. 90%) cannot be exploited since the lack of adequate specific surface slows down its engagement in hydration reactions. Taking into consideration their untreated nature, it can be supported that they exhibit an acceptable strength potential after 28 days, complying - even marginally - with the strength class (42.5) of the used cement. Durability results revealed that there is no need to pre-treat RHA in order to achieve equal or even better performance than mortar with plain cement in terms of sorptivity (50% increase for 15% RHA usage) and resistivity. Untreated RHA however fails - as most SCMs do - to improve carbonation resistance since for a 15% cement replacement, carbonation depth was almost doubled. Overall, results indicate that usage of untreated RHA in cement-based systems is an alternative to decrease their carbon profile, as long as cement replacement is kept relatively low (below 15%). The internationally acclaimed efforts to reduce man-made CO₂ emissions require a more rigorous approach to be adopted by the construction industry. Given the need to provide a durable solution that guarantees a minimum service life, on a common reinforced concrete structure, the issue of sustainable durability design is of paramount importance. Bearing in mind that the major source of emission of gasses in concrete manufacturing arise from the clinker production process, during cement manufacturing several means of reducing the environmental footprint have been suggested, as incorporation of cement replacement materials. The present Thesis contributes to the evaluation of the environmental cost of each component of concrete and to provide the best possible mix design configuration (by means of a holistic analytical software tool) in terms of low environmental cost, as well as, to assess this proposed configuration in terms of strength and durability requirements. Overall, it has to be emphasized that through the present Thesis a new indicator is proposed for design purposes: the environmental cost, which can be added to the existing strength, durability and economic cost indicators towards an integrated design optimization of concrete structures. Finally, the incorporation of new SCM, as biomass ashes and especially RHA, offers new perspectives for decreasing the environmental cost of constructions.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Patras
Year dc:date
2014

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Tapali, Tzoulia
  • Τάπαλη, Τζούλια

Subjects

dc:subject × 26

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/44011

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Tapali, Tzoulia; Τάπαλη, Τζούλια. An integrated design process for durable concrete structures at the minimum environmental cost: application with the incorporation of rice husk ash. University of Patras, 2014. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/44011