Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Καθόλου και υποστασιακός επιμερισμός: η οντολογία της εξατομίκευσης στον σχολαστικισμό
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe problem of individuation and universals, constitutes the most classic and fundamental debate in the history of philosophy. The contradistinction between realism versus nominalism. A conflict whose object is the absolute principle in the ontological and cognitive level. On that conflict the classic realism is being accepted per se the universals through them was provided the existence of the common element and the reality itself. The problem in the scholastic period was, the conditions would allow disconnection from essence. Essence represents the common element which is together unified with the singular, so in order to resulted the individuation has to be separated from essence. This procedure was expressed from Scotus, where the principle of individuation was the private cause. The stake for Scotus was the disconnection from the common element, without that to lead us in the nominalism. This procedure is unable to be achieved in the extent that universals exist, because the transition from general to unity is being hurtled with the concept of causality. From the other side in the nominalistic model the individuation is more powerful than ever, because of the rejection of universals and in this case the only issue it could be the proof of universals. In the extent that nominalism secure singularity sacrificing the universals, in essence not only rejects the individuation as a procedure, but the mental reality is being collapsed together with the transcendental parameter. While the universals prevents the integration of individuation in the ultimate implementation, at the same time the individuation without the universals is a process out of meaning. Consciousness cannot be held without the universals. Nominalism may glorify singularity in a world that the subject cannot prove itself, and that world would be interpreted only subjectively. Scotus interferes between those two models, and he is using an analogy among the conceptual singularity of common nature and numerical unity. He displays a system where ‘thisness’ set up individuation as powerful as the individuation would be in nominalism, but at the same time the concept of ‘thisness’ is being related with the common element (essence) which is conceptual singular. This procedure is called ‘formal distinction’ and is taking place inside of every being either is conceptual either existential. This distinction presupposes the existence of universals, since universality represents the common element which is being compressed with the equivalent ‘thisness’. In case of essence – species we may say that ‘thisness’ of humanity is reason and when we have a specific creature like Socrates, that ‘thisness’ is socrataeity. ‘Thisness’ is being counted as the specific or individual difference that makes something the what it is. In case of species reasoness remains a general cause, instead with the individual Socrates where socrateity may not be divided further. That is because individual difference has been differentiated with respect to itself. By this process Scotus imparts a positive principle in individuation, unlike with other systems of his age. The other systems prefer subtractive functions like the principle of severability. Similarly that principle may be quantity, form, matter or existence. The common disadvantage of them is their applicability to all the cases (a common cause for each individuation), therefore is being reduced their individuating power by producing only differentiation and not individuation. As a final conclusion, this dissertation presents the relation between the multiple and unity not as opposed concepts, but through their connection in the ontological level will be highlighted the correlation between the intelligible and the real. It is about for a self-determination of the subject, and the resulting self-consciousness (in the extent that will not constitute just an interpretation), will lead us to proof of universals.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Laparidis, Konstantinos
- Λαπαρίδης, Κωνσταντίνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Αυτότητα
- Καθόλου
- Εξατομίκευση
- Ουσία
- Σκώτος, Ντουνς (1266 - 1308)
- Όκαμ, Γουίλιαμ (1287 - 1347)
- Νομιναλισμός
- Σχολαστικισμός
- Thisness
- Universals
- Individuation
- Essence
- Scotus, Duns (1266 - 1308)
- Ockham, William (1287 - 1347)
- Nominalism
- Scholasticism
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/44450