National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Kinetic modeling of reductive biodegradation of chloroethenes in croumdwater
Abstract
dc:descriptionChloroethenes, and particularly the most chlorinated perchloroethene (PCE) and trichloroethene (TCE), are among the most prevalent groundwater contaminants. In contaminated subsurface environments, PCE and TCE are often accompanied by dichloroethenes (DCEs) and the monochlorinated vinyl chloride (VC), which are produced by the microbially-mediated degradation of PCE and TCE.Anaerobic reductive dechlorination (referred to simply as dechlorination in the context of the thesis) has emerged as the most efficient biodegradation pathway of chloroethenes. Dechlorination is a stepwise microbial respiratory process, during which chloroethenes serve as electron acceptors and H2 serves as the electron donor. Ultimately, the environmentally benign ethene (ETH) is produced.Dechlorination depends upon, besides H2 availability, the presence of specific microbes (namely dechlorinators), often naturally-occurring, that mediate each step of the reaction and gain energy to support their maintenance and growth. In field settings, when H2 is insufficient for the complete or timely detoxification of chloroethenes, H2 precursors are supplied, an approach referred to as biostimulation (or enhanced, as opposed to intrinsic, biodegradation). Typically, H2 is not readily available to dechlorinators, hence, the presence of bacteria that can mediate the production of H2 is also a prerequisite for successful biostimulation. But, H2 will not stimulate onlydechlorinators; H2 under strictly anaerobic conditions is an electron donor for competitor H2 scavengers, such as sulfate-reducers and methanogens. Consequently, dechlorination is part of a complex food web involving populations that help (syntrophs) or hinder (competitors) dechlorinators.The composition of mixed dechlorinating communities varies considerably both in field and laboratory conditions. Differences in the make-up of chloroethene-degrading communities (i.e. different dechlorinating and nondechlorinating microorganisms) have resulted in mixed cultures with diverse dechlorinating abilities. Consequently, dechlorination rates reported in the literature vary significantly, almost by two orders of magnitude. Considering the metabolic properties of dechlorinators, when the goal is their preferential stimulation, a reasonable remedialapproach appears to be the addition of slowly fermentable substrates that provide H2 (and acetate) steadily at low concentrations. Yet, several biostimulation efforts in the literature deviated from this reasoning (mainly in the laboratory) and managed to successfully effect complete dechlorination to ethene.The study of dechlorination in mixed communities becomes especially challenging when multiple underlying microbial processes are involved in the explanation of the observed outcomes. In the laboratory, it is hard to separate dechlorination from its side reactions and systematically observe the interspecies flow of H2. Kinetic models, however, can aid experimental approaches and provide insight into the relevance of dechlorinating and non-dechlorinating processes.In this research, a comprehensive kinetic model was developed and calibrated, and suitable applications were devised, with the aim to shed light on the non-dechlorinating part of dechlorinating communities. A model that integrates the key microbial processes that are typically anticipated under strictly anaerobic conditions can offer plausible explanations for the distinctive behaviors of dechlorinating cultures in laboratory settings and naturalenvironments. The model can be used to perform numerical experiments and evaluate the outcome of targeted what-if scenarios that corroborate laboratory investigations, in search of supporting evidence for selecting strategies to optimize chloroethene detoxification.To this end, the kinetic model presented herein accounted for dechlorination in conjunction with cooperative (i.e.fermentation of H2 precursors) and competing processes (methane formation and sulfate reduction). A heuristic multistart global optimization approach was developed in order to calibrate the model with experimental observations from research previously performed at NTUA. The multistart optimization technique was also tested with two models and mixed chloroethene-degrading cultures reported in the literature: in one of them, it was found to offer greater insight into the type of dechlorinators. Confidence in model structure and the multistart strategywas gained by testing them under distinctive conditions, ranging from non-limiting conditions (e.g. ample donor supply in the absence of sulfate reducers) to competitive conditions for dechlorinators (e.g. when sulfate reduction and methane formation compete with dechlorination for limited quantities of H2). Finally, a series of numerical tests was performed to simulate the performance of alternate mixed communities under distinct scenarios of enhanced dechlorination, with emphasis given on the activity and the make-up of non-dechlorinators.The findings of this thesis offer a framework through which to interpret the observations of dechlorination under methanogenic conditions reported in the literature. The results delineated a group of mixed dechlorinating cultures, containing mostly acetate-consuming methanogens, for which the addition of H2 in significant quantities will not put dechlorinators in disadvantage, thereby explaining why this is so on the basis of the composition of the nondechlorinatingportion of the microbial community. This is important, because most of the well-studieddechlorinating cultures, including several commercially available ones, exhibit the opposite trend: as a result, perceptions of good practice for efficient dechlorination have often stemmed from over-generalizations that did not apply to the universe of the mixed cultures capable of fully dechlorinating PCE and TCE.This work investigated systematically the activities of non-dechlorinators for the first time, thus highlighting the need to examine the performance of chloroethene-degrading cultures by considering the interplay of the main microbial groups. Specifically, it showed that moderate differences in the metabolic properties of nondechlorinators (methanogens and H2-producing fermenters), even if they are minority populations, influenced significantly the performance of dechlorinators following biostimulation.Overall, the type of inquiry presented herein frames the use of slowly fermentable substrates to communities where efficient H2-utilizing methanogens thrive and compete with dechlorinators. In addition, this is the first time that the competition for fermentation daughter-products besides H2 (i.e. acetate) is assessed. Model results indicated that acetate can dictate the extent of dechlorination, especially under limiting H2 conditions, i.e. conditions typically encountered during the natural attenuation of chloroethenes.Simulations performed under sulfate-reducing conditions revealed the role of sulfate-reducing pathways that involve electron donors other than H2; competition for H2 precursors (fermentable substrates and acetate) can jeopardize the success of dechlorination, apart from direct competition for H2. Specifically, the results quantified differences in dechlorination extent depending on the type of the pathway followed for sulfate reduction. Finally, model results provide evidence supporting the hypothesis that the long-term exposure of dechlorinators to sulfides(the end-product of sulfate reduction) preferentially inhibit the most efficient dechlorinating species, giving room to slow-growing dechlorinators to dominate. The preferential inhibition of dechlorinators by sulfides provides a suitable explanatory framework for the inconsistent findings regarding dechlorination under-sulfate reducing conditions.Perhaps more importantly, this work showed that kinetic modeling of the fate of priority groundwater pollutants can become more than a fitting exercise and be trusted not only in a predictive mode but also to evaluate alternate hypotheses of the composition of mixed microbial communities and their remediation potential.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kandris, Kyriakos
- Κανδρής, Κυριάκος
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Χλωροαιθυλένια
- Υπόγειο νερό
- Βιοαποκατάσταση
- Κινητική προσομοίωση
- Αναερόβια αναγωγική αποχλωρίωση
- Groundwater
- Chloroethenes
- Bioremediation
- Kinetic modeling
- Anaerobic reductive dechlorination
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Περιβαλλοντική Μηχανική
- Περιβαλλοντική Βιοτεχνολογία
- Engineering and Technology
- Environmental Engineering
- Environmental Biotechnology
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY_ND
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/44465