National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Συσχέτιση κατανομής διαταραχών προσωπικότητας και είδους διαπραχθέντων εγκλημάτων σε πληθυσμούς αρρένων κρατουμένων
Abstract
dc:descriptionIntroduction The perception of the self and the behavior of people, has always been an area of interest for initially philosophers and later scientific researchers. Without a doubt, the Greek Philosophers’ approach to mankind, especially in the light of the fullness of Aristotle's thought, has marked the modern, semantic approach of human temperament. The diagnostic approach now used in DSM-5, represents the view that Personality Disorders are qualitatively distinct clinical syndromes. Alternative approach is that Personality Disorders are malpractice variations in personality traits, which are subtly merged into normality. Personality Disorders can also be considered dimensions, representing spectra, where the dysfunction of the personality is in a continuous with other mental disorders. In DSM Personality Disorders represents a permanent pattern of internalized experience and behaviors that deviate significantly from the anticipated cultural context of the individual and manifests itself in two or more of the following areas: cognitive, emotional, interpersonal, and impulse control. This particular pattern is rigid and present in a wide range of personal and social situations. The patterns lead the individual into dysfunctional practices, at the mental, emotional and behavioral levels. Cluster B disorders are associated with the whole range of crimes, cluster A disorders mainly with sex crime, and cross-crime, while cluster C disorders are mainly associated with sexual crime. Although recent years have shown, a further exploration of the relationship between personality traits, life-demographic events, and types of Personality Disorders, in relation to the types of offenses, shows a variety of outcomes. Especially for populations of prisoners in Greek prisons the research literature is limited in this area. Material and Methods This study is an attempt to record demographic and psychosocial data, delinquent history, personality traits, and evaluation the personality disorders of detainees. This is a cross-sectional study that was conducted in two Greek detention centers. In particular, in two sections (E 'and C') of Korydallos Prison and the Domokos Prison, the period from January 2012 to August 2013. The aim of this research is to investigate the distribution of Personality Disorders based on the PDQ-4 Questionnaire (Personality Disorders Questionnaire) on populations of male prisoners. Furthermore, the association of the Personality Disorders with the crime history of prisoners (violent and non-violent) as well as the offense of homicide too. A further objective is to evaluate the following temperament parameters: 1. Hostility (Hostility and Direction Hostility Questionnaire, HDHQ), 2. Aggression (Aggression Questionnaire) and 3. Impulsivity (Barratt Impulsiveness Scale, BIS-11). Also the collection of family, economic, psychological and social parameters, correlated with the type of crime (violent- not violent) and the homicide offense too.ResultsThe 42.5% of participants had Antisocial personality disorder, 15.9% had Borderline, and 10.7% of them they didn’t have Personality Disorder. Furthermore the 66.9% of them had a Personality Disorder that belonged to cluster B and 16.2% to cluster A. Participants with Schizoid and Schizotypal personality disorder had committed violent crime at a significantly higher rate than those who did not have Personality Disorder. Also, participants with Personality Disorder from cluster A had committed violent crime at a significantly higher rate than those who did not have Personality Disorder. While participants with Antisocial personality disorder, they had committed a violent crime at a significantly lower rate than those with Schizoid, Schizotypal or Paranoid disorder. More generally, the rate of committing violent crimes was significantly higher in cluster A compared to both cluster B and cluster C (p = 0.005 and p = 0.003 respectively).At a total of 308 participants, 46 (14.9%) had committed homicide or attempted homicide. Specifically, 38 (12.3%) had committed for homicide, 6 (1.9%) had commited for attempted homicide, and 2 (0.6%) had committed for intended fatal injury. Participants with Schizoid and Schizotypal personality disorders had committed homicide at a significantly higher rate than those who did not have any Personality Disorder. Similarly, participants with Personality Disorder of cluster A had committed homicide at a significantly higher rate than those who did not have any Personality Disorder. On the other hand, participants with Antisocial personality disorder had committed homicide at a significantly lower rate than those with Schizoid, Schizotypal, Paranoid or Borderline personality disorder. In addition, among the A, B and C clusters, there were significant differences in homicide rates (p <0.001). In particular, the homicide rate was significantly higher in the cluster A, compared both cluster B and cluster C.Conclusions We have seen a number of adversities in the juvenile detention. The prisoners watch and reproduce violence from an early age. Early drug use, controversial delinquency with schoolmates, school leaving, low professional and socio-economic levels, impulsive and antisocial behavior, interpersonal difficulties, and personal instability were facts on the criminal population. Moreover, they data are elements that potentially contribute to their early involvement with the criminal justice system. In our sample, the predominance of Personality Disorders of cluster B was obvious. Overall, Personality Disorders were diagnosed in the overwhelming majority (about 9 out of 10) of the sample of prisoners. Among these, the most common Personality Disorder was Antisocial (4 out of 10). Followed by the Borderline personality disorder, Narcissistic personality disorder, Paranoid personality disorder and Schizoid personality disorder, then followed by the Obsessive Compulsive personality disorder and the Schizotypal disorder with little differences. Finally, very low percentages were found in Historionic, Depentent and Avoidance personality disorders. Whereas only a tenth of the sample population did not diagnosed with Personality Disorder. There was a positive trend for violent offending, at a higher average age, than non-violent offending. This fact also describe a tendency for prisoners who have committed violent crimes, to live alone or with a non-stable partner, highlighting unstable interpersonal relationships. Also a statistically significant correlation with non-violent crime, has emerged for those who have been exempted from their military obligations. In particular, prisoners discharged from their military duties were 49% less likely to have committed violent crime than those who have been fulfilled their military obligations. The use of cannabis was statistically associated with non-violent crime as well. In particular, cannabis users were less likely to have committed a violent crime than non-cannabis users or drug users (p = 0.003). Following this finding, there is also a positive correlation of drug use with non-violent crime. It turned out that drug users are 65% less likely to commit non-violent crime and 57% less likely to commit homicide (p = 0.024) than non-users. Then, with regard to the temperament characteristics, aggression and hostility, there was no statistically significant correlation with any type of crime or homicide . On the contrary, individual characteristics of the Impulsivity Scale, in particular mobility, self-assessment and lack of design, showed a positive correlation with non-violent crime. Non-violent criminals they seem to have less self-control and increased mobility. Positive correlation with non-violent crime resulted in the mean overall impulse score (p = 0.039), where non-violent criminals are significantly more impulsive than violent criminals. Also, statistically significant correlation was also revealed for the homicide offense, where non- homicide offenders appear to be significantly more impulsive (p = 0.034), relative to the homicide offenders. Finally, with regard to Personality Disorders, a statistically significant correlation with violent crime, arose for the Personality Disorders of cluster A (p = 0.011) overall, and in particular for Schizotypal and Schizoid personality disorder. Prisoners with cluster A disorders were 3.66 times more likely to commit violent crime than those they didn’t have Personality Disorder. While prisoners with Schizoid and Schizotypal personality disorders had 3.49 times (p = 0.043) and 10.5 times (p = 0.017) respectively, they were more likely to have committed violent crime compared to participants without Personality Disorders. Furthermore, for the offense of homicide - attempted homicide, a statistically significant correlation, emerged here also for the disorders of cluster A and in particular for Schizotypal and Schizoid personality disorder. In particular, prisoners with cluster A disorders were 4.25 times more likely to commit murder than the prisoners without Personality Disorders. Prisoners with Schizoid disorder were 5.26 times (p = 0.020) more likely to have committed homicide compared to participants without Personality Disorders. An even greater correlation has emerged for prisoners with Schizotypal personality disorder who were 8.80 times (p = 0.030) more likely to have committed homicide compared to participants without Personality Disorders. These results contradict the prevailing view in literature that, in particular, cluster B disorders and, especially in men’s population, the Antisocial personality disorder, were related to violent crimes and offences against life. In the present study, it was attempted to emphasize that violence is the product of a chain of life events in which the risks accumulate, potentially mutually reinforce and interweave with temperament features. It is a fact the effect of both common and non-common environments. Also should be noted that there are usually no purely criminal histories or fixed patterns of delinquency. However, it describes criminal activity that starts from an early age and involves a combination of non-violent and violent recurrent acts, with drug use and possibly psychiatric co-morbidity that leads to early imprisonment. On the other hand, there is criminal activity that does not necessarily involve repeatability, but it sometimes involves with serious offenses. In all this, it appears that the personality factor plays a key role. Finally, the "contribution" of cluster A disorders to violent crime and homicide is highlighted, which needs further investigation into both a larger sample of prison population and a population of criminals suffering from specific Personality Disorders.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Apostolopoulos, Athanasios
- Αποστολόπουλος, Αθανάσιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/44558