University of Thessaly (UTH)
Πανελλήνια επιδημιολογική μελέτη γνώσεων, στάσεων και συνηθειών (ΚΑΡ) ιατρών που ασκούν πρωτοβάθμια περίθαλψη σε θέματα προσυμπτωματικού ελέγχου διαλογής screening
Abstract
dc:descriptionEvidence-based public health (EBPH) developed as a practice model which aims at whole communities and is based on evidence based medicine (EBM) approach.Increased emphasis on EBPH has several benefits, which converge to the concept of health promotion and disease prevention.EBPH can be defined as the process of integrating science-based interventions with community preferences to improve the health of populations.Screening as a key component in the setting of evidence-based public health (EBPH) should involve incorporate evidence based practices into a population-centered model of preventive health care in order to improve and maintain population health.Despite the major progress made in the field of public health in the last years, there is evidence of non-compliance with the recommendations offered by national advisory groups such as the United StatesWe aimed to assess the knowledge, attitudes and practices of doctors toward U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPTF) screening guidelines. The second purpose of the study was to identify the risk factors a contributing to poor adherence to USPSTF screening guidelines.The survey was conducted within a six month period in a stratified random sample of 370 internal medicine specialists (IMS), 382 GPs, 371 practicing Cardiologists and 371 pediatricians. Participants were queried about sociodemographic characteristics, their knowledge, attitudes, and self-reported practice patterns regarding screening in primary care setting. Socio-demographic characteristics associated with inappropriate screening were identified using multivariable logistic regression models.To achieve health goals for improved population health, more widespread and uniform implementation of evidence-based strategies has been recommendedSpecifically, the role of the primary care physicians in health care supply is particularly relevant as they are in a unique position to promote screening. Since the screening recommendations and profile of medical doctors in Greece is more or less unknown, our survey aimed to evaluate knowledge, attitude and practices (KAP) doctors in regard to screening and to current recommendations in primary care setting.Following review of previous literature, and pre-testing, three separate questionnaires were prepared to assess the knowledge, attitude and practices of internal medicine specialists, general practitioners, cardiologists and pediatricians.Medical doctors were selected by using geographically stratified random sampling methodology. It was estimated that the inclusion of approximately 10% of Greek doctors for each of the 4 specialty categories it would be satisfactory. In total 382 GPs, 371 pediatricians, 371 practicing Cardiologists and 370 internal medicine specialists (IMS) were randomly selected to participate in our study. Nevertheless, the questionnaires were finally analyzed in 297 physicians, 299 general practitioners, 297 cardiologists and 294 pediatricians. Data collection through telephone interviews was the method of choice, since it reduces the response time increases the response rate and offers anonymity and confidentiality. All interviews were contacted by one particular expert (medical doctor) in order to minimize bias and ensure objectivity. The final percentage of doctors' participation in the survey stood at 79.1%.Data collection through telephone interviews was the method of choice, since it reduces the response time increases the response rate and offers anonymity and confidentiality. All interviews were contacted by one particular expert (medical doctor) in order to minimize bias and ensure objectivity.Nearly all IMS (99, 7 %) agreed on the important role of population based screening in improving patient care. Moreover, despite variation in the implementation of guidelines among IMS, 61 % of the respondents reported that their screening recommendations are based on major international guidelines. Furthermore the majority of IMS (65, 4%) claimed that not only explicit screening guidelines are available but also that guidelines are widely disseminated among health professionals practicing in primary care setting. Finally 85, 6% of IMS claims that their performance and consequently the quality of patient care would be improved with the implementation of computer based decision support systems in clinical practice.However, IMS screening recommendations appeared to be in contrast with USPSTF guidelines in many clinical entities. Τhe most common error made by participants involved incorrectly repeating screening for cervical cancer in a woman 22 years old who tested negative on annual basis (98.9%). Failure to screen for AAA in a man 67 years old with smoking history was the least common mistake observed in our study (54.7%). According to the results of our study, ΙΜS younger than 50 years of age and those with less than 15 years of practice were more likely to declare that there are clear and widespread guidelines.In latent class analysis we found that IMS younger than 50 of age as well as doctors with postgraduate studies are more likely to report that their performance would be facilitated by the use of computer based decision support systems.All GPs agreed on the important role of population based screening in improving patient care and 88% of GPs reported that their performance would be improved with the implementation of computer based support systems in clinical practice. Despite that, GPs’ screening recommendations are in stark contrast with USPSTF guidelines in many clinical entities. The most common error made by participants was to incorrectly recommending screening for type 2 diabetes in a woman 45 years old in the absence of risk factors (98%). Failure to screen for depression in a woman 25 years old in the presence of family history suggestive of depression was the least common mistake observed in our study. GPs older than 50 years of age, those who practicing for more than 15 years, private practitioners and GPs reviewing more than 100 patients per week were less likely to be compliant with USPTF guidelines. In latent class analysis we found that male practitioners, government practitioners and those who claimed that do not consult screening guidelines for their decisions are more likely to adhere to USPTF recommendations than their counterparts.The vast majority of Cardiologists (99%) agreed on the important role of population based screening in improving patient care and 69.4% of Cardiologists reported that their performance would be facilitated by the use of computer based decision support systems. Our survey revealed that more than half of the cardiologists (53.7%) failed to screen for abdominal aortic aneurysm (ΑΑΑ) in a man 67 years with smoking history. The vast majority of the Cardiologists were also found to incorrectly offer screening for dyslipidemia in a man23 years (80%), in a woman 36 years (83.45%) as well as in a woman 46 years (93.58%). Most of cardiologists would inappropriately screen for coronary heart disease (CHD) in a man 47 years (83.6%) as well as in a woman 57 years old (82.09%). Furthermore, contrary to USPSTF recommendation, the majority of cardiologists would screen for carotid artery stenosis (CAS) (84, 12%) in an obese hypertensive man 53 years old. Ιn addition more than half of the participants would erroneously consider prescribing aspirin in a woman 60 years old with smoking history (53.4%). Being over age 50 was the most important predictor of non-compliance as well as of poor attitude regarding screening guidelines revealed by latent class analysis.The vast majority of the pediatricians (99%) agreed on the important role of population based screening in promoting public health and most of the responders (78.8%) stated that the use of an on line software would facilitate their decision making process. Moreover, 61.1% of the respondents reported that their screening recommendations are based on major international guidelines. In addition, more than half of the Pediatricians (51.4%) are not convinced that screening guidelines are clear and widespread. Our study revealed the insufficient implementation of international guidelines for screening of pediatric obesity (87.71%). Despite the lack of evidence supporting screening for hip dysplasia, most Pediatricians (86.39%) were found to hold favourable attitude towards screening in a boy 2 months old with family history of hip dysplasia. Furthermore most Pediatricians (80.27%) would inappropriately screen for scoliosis in a boy 13 years old. Our study revealed also that the majority of Pediatricians erroneously tend to screen for lipid disorders in a boy 7years old (54%) as well as in an obese boy 10 years old (94%) Finally, the majority of the participants (60, 8%) failed to screen for depression in an asymptomatic girl 14 years old with family history of depression. Female practitioners, younger than 50 years of age, working in the private sector and those who declared that they use specific screening guidelines for their decisions were found to have a poor knowledge towards these screening guidelines. The results of our survey suggest the need for educational intervention in order to promote the routine adoption of national evidence based screening recommendation in clinical practice.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Dresios, Christos
- Δρέσιος, Χρήστος
Subjects
dc:subject × 6Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/44649