University of the Aegean
Μια ουδέτερη γλώσσα επικοινωνίας για την διαβούλευση ανομοιογενών συλλογικών σωμάτων στο πεδίο της περιβαλλοντικής πολιτικής και της διαχείρισης φυσικών πόρων
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe main tendency that is observed today in the field of Environmental Policy, is the “opening up” of decision-making processes, in a bigger number of interests, a fact that results mainly, either from the need for effectiveness of decisions, or from the need to incorporate social values and preferences in each policy. In theory, this question is recognized as a bipolar opposition between effectiveness and democracy. However, what constitutes an essential element in a participatory decision-making process is to what degree it is simultaneously democratic and effective. That means, to what degree it corresponds in the real equality of citizens and to what degree the cognitive ability of those who participate in it is extended and enriched; so that they can participate effectively, according to the criterion of democratic governance, but also to contribute in the objective result with the biggest knowledge and critical thought. In the centre of this question lies also the effective communication that should not lead neither to the nullification of equivalence between deliberators nor to what we name the ‘illusion of hierarchical authority’. Our research proves to us, that one of the main ‘practical’ factors of the danger of this illusion is the communication mean that is used in the deliberations and particularly that of the natural language. Thus we support the thesis that the communication mean that the participants will use for deliberating, could possibly democratise and increase the effectiveness of participatory decision-making processes, between individuals and stakeholders with different social characteristics. So an exceptionally interesting question is maintained open, which in our research we named as ‘the issue of language in participatory deliberations’. Consequently the main goals of our research were the following: the first goal was: the ascertainment of, a) the necessity of participatory decision making processes in Environmental Policy, and b) the communication problems that participatory deliberations cause, due to the use of natural language, considering that the deliberators are non-homogeneous regarding their composition in their social, educational and other characteristics of their identity. The second goal was: the ascertainment of: a) the linguistic ambiguities of the natural language and b) the proposal for the use of an artificial language for the better confrontation of these linguistic ambiguities. The 3rd goal was the planning of suitable experimental participatory deliberations for the practical investigation of our basic work hypothesis. And finally the 4th goal was the analysis of the results from the experimental participatory deliberations and the rebuttal/verification of our work hypothesis. The final conclusion of our research was that indeed the democratic and procedural effectiveness were improved in the 2nd experimental deliberation, which used as a medium of communication, an artificial language, in comparison with the 1st experimental deliberation which used as a mean of communication the natural language.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2009
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Αποστολίδου, Βασιλική
Subjects
dc:subject × 22- Περιβαλλοντική πολιτική
- Δημοκρατικές διαβουλεύσεις
- Συμμετοχικές διαδικασίες λήψης απόφασης
- Δημόσια συμμετοχή
- Τεχνητές γλώσσες προσομοίωσης
- Δημοκρατική αποτελεσματικότητα
- Διαδικαστική αποτελεσματικότητα
- Ανομοιογενή συλλογικά σώματα
- Environmental policy
- Denocratic deliberations
- Participatory decision making processes
- Public participation
- Visual programming languages
- Democratic effectiveness
- Procedural effectiveness
- Collective and non-homogenous decision-making bodies
- Γεωπονία, Δασολογία και Αλιεία
- Γεωπονικές Επιστήμες και Κτηνιατρική
- Δασολογία
- Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
- Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences
- Forestry
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/44746