National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Κλινική και εμβιομηχανική μελέτη των ανάστροφα λοξών καταγμάτων του ισχίου
Abstract
dc:descriptionAimThe clinical study and evaluation of the patients suffered by reverseobliquity pertrochanteric fracture who were treated with intramedullarynailing (short or long nail). Our purpose is to clarify if there is any differencebetween the two treatment methods, the advantages and disadvantages ofeach method. Furthermore, to note if there is any difference between thosetwo methods of treatment with respect of the postoperative physical activityof the patients.Material and methods1st part: We studied 80 patients with reverse obliquity pertrochantericfracture after a low energy injury. Patients with neuromuscular diseases,contralateral operated hip and pathological fracture as well as youngerpatients with similar fracture pattern after high energy injury were excluded.We divided the patients into two groups, group A (40 patients with mean age81 yo) and group B (40 patients with mean age 79 yo) according to theirtreatment. The patients of group A were operated with intramedullary nailingwith short nail in contrast with the patients of group B who were operatedwith long intramedullary nail. The mean postoperative follow up was 2 yearsand the patients gave written permission in order to participate to the study.The study was also approved by the scientific council of the “ATTIKON”general university hospital. All patients underwent the necessary preoperativeworkup and also were setup for any medical comorbidities. In group A, theAffixus intramedullary nailing system was used (Affixus Hip Fracture NailSystem® (Zimmer BIOMET, Warsaw, IN, USA) in contrast with group B, wherethe Orthofix Veronail system was used [Orthofix VeroNail Trochanteric Nail®(Orthofix, Verona, Italy)]. Factors as the patient’s ability for painless walking80with a single crutch or a cane, possible leg length discrepancy andTrendelenburg gait as indication of abductor muscles insufficiency wereclinically evaluated. The radiologic evaluation was about fracture healing, thepossible loss of reduction in varus/valgus on AP views and additionally forgroup A, the measurement of the distance between the distal fracture lineand the distal locking screw of the nail. The clinical and radiological data wascompared between the two groups via Student’s t test.2nd part: We studied 60 patients separated in two groups in relation tothe treatment they underwent (short vs long intramedullary nail). Detailedmedical history, BMI, socioeconomic level, possible mental disabilities as wellas the level of the postoperative homecare were registered. Two monthspostoperatively, a step counter was hanged on each patient for 48 hours andthe physical activity was also registered.Results1st part: The mean operative time in group A was 41 min and in groupB was 54 min. The difference is statistically significant. The functional healingevaluation highlighted similar results for both groups (p=0.910). The meantime of painless weight bearing with the use of a single crutch or a cane was7.85 weeks for group A and 7.31 weeks for group B. The gait evaluation in 3and 12 months postoperatively registered abductor muscles insufficiency in12 and 6 patients respectively in group A and in group B 10 patients sufferedby Trendelenburg gait in 3 months and 5 patients in 12 monthspostoperatively. 5 patients of group A and 3 patients of group B presented leglength discrepancy less than 1 cm postoperatively. Full healing achieved in allpatients of both groups with similar healing time (11 weeks, p=0.44). Loss ofreduction in varus or valgus was not reported in any patient of both groups.The distance between the distal fracture line and the distal locking screw ofthe nail was measured only in group A and the average was 7.2cm. Withrespect of complications, no statistical significant difference was registered81between the two groups. Only one patient of group A with a periprostheticfracture and one case of group B with z-effect were registered.2nd part: Similar comorbidity rates were reported for both groups. Themean BMI was 21,.62 in group A and 26.06 in group B. The mean familyincome per person, the education level and the postoperative home care leveldidn’t have statistically significant difference between the patients of the twogroups. The mean duration of hospitalization was 9 days for group A and 10days for group B (p=0.24). This difference is not statistically significant. Thecomplications which were reported were the DVT and non-usualpostoperative bleeding without difference between the two groups (p=0.74).The Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE) scores were similar between thetwo groups. In group A the score was 24.1/30 and in group B was 24.3/30. Inthe two months follow up, patients of group A were performing average 97.5steps per day and patients of group B average 115.11 steps per day. Thecomparison of the two groups highlighted statistically non-significantdifference with p value =0.82 (>0.05).ConclusionThe treatment of the reverse obliquity pertrochanteric hip fractureswith short intramedullary nail has similar results with the treatment with longintramedullary nail but significantly shorter operative time. In addition, thepostoperative physical activity of these patients seems not to bedifferentiated in relation to the treatment method followed.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Galanopoulos, Ioannis
- Γαλανόπουλος, Ιωάννης
Subjects
dc:subject × 7Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/45481