Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Ανάπτυξη και εφαρμογή συστήματος αξιολόγησης για διδάσκοντες φυσικών επιστημών βασισμένο στην Παιδαγωγική Γνώση Περιεχομένου
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe present doctoral dissertation aims at designing an evaluation system for science teachers in secondary education. Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK) was selected as the theoretical basis for describing teachers’ knowledge and practices. The evaluation criteria and the aspects of teachers’ practices that are included in each criterion were then formulated based on PCK. Within the context of this evaluation system, what is required from the evaluator is to collect data from these aspects of teachers’ practices and draw conclusions. The literature indicates the need for formulating a commonly accepted framework which mainly addresses the criteria by which teachers are evaluated. PCK is considered as the most contemporary and widely accepted concept among researchers in terms of describing teacher’s knowledge as well as the ways in which this knowledge is reflected in teacher’s practice. Therefore, it can be used as a common basis between researchers and teachers for developing criteria for an evaluation system. Furthermore, what has emerged from the literature review is that many researchers argue about taking into account students’ perceptions concerning their teachers’ practices as it can be useful and important. The rationale for including students’ perceptions within evaluation systems is that they can provide a more holistic view of the teachers’ practices. According to these researchers, students constitute a reliable source of data. Still, students’ perceptions are rarely used within evaluation systems – and if they are – they are not used in a systematic way. Considering the above, an evaluation system was designed for Science teachers in secondary education. The thesis presents this system which involves the data sources, evaluation criteria, tools, as well as the methodology for collecting, analyzing and exploiting the results. Regarding teachers, the evaluation system collects data from observations of their practice using an evaluation rubric. Regarding students’ perceptions the evaluation system collects data using a questionnaire. The evaluation criteria that were based on PCK are divided in four categories: Subject Matter Knowledge; Instructional Representations and Strategies; Instructional Objectives and Context; Knowledge of Students’ Understanding. The present doctoral dissertation includes two parts: (a) testing the reliability of the tools (b) implementing the evaluation system in order to draw conclusions concerning strengths and weaknesses of science teachers’ practices in Greece. The reliability test indicated that the evaluators were led to similar results by using the observation sheet and the rubric, utilising a common scoring strategy when completing the rubric. In addition, high degree of reliability emerged with regards to the questionnaires for students’ perceptions, even in small samples, which appears to favour their use in the context of individual teacher evaluation. The full implementation of the evaluation system was carried out in schools located at Northern Greece’s municipalities, with common features to the Greek educational context. Τhe sample was representative. 32 secondary school science teachers (Physicists, Chemists and Biologists) participated in the study and 1154 students completed the questionnaires. The analysis of the results indicated the strengths and weaknesses of their teaching practice which can be identified in almost all the categories of the evaluation criteria. Τhe most positive aspects are related to criteria included in the category ‘Subject Matter Knowledge’, though positive aspects can also be identified in the other categories. The weakest aspects are related to criteria included in the categories ‘Instructional Representations and Strategies’ and ‘Knowledge of Students’ understandings’ as well as within the category ‘Instructional Objectives and Context’ in a lower degree. Similarities were identified regarding the strengths and weaknesses of teachers’ practice. The strengths of their teaching practice seem to be related to a high degree of Subject Matter Knowledge as well as with the development of empirical knowledge. The weaknesses of their teaching practice appear to be related with lack of General Pedagogical Knowledge, lack of knowledge regarding their students as well as lack of knowledge of evaluation. In essence, using PCK as a conceptual basis for developing criteria covered a wide range of aspects related to teachers’ practice, while valorising students’ perceptions provided a holistic view of teachers’ practices.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Sofianidis, Angelos
- Σοφιανίδης, Άγγελος
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Αξιολόγηση εκπαιδευτικών
- Πρακτικές διδασκαλίας στις φυσικές επιστήμες
- Αντιλήψεις μαθητών
- Παιδαγωγική γνώση περιεχομένου (ΠΓΠ)
- Σύστημα αξιολόγησης εκπαιδευτικών
- Teachers’ evaluation
- Teachers’ practices in science education
- Students’ perceptions
- Pedagogical content knowledge
- Teachers' evaluation system
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση
- Social Sciences
- Education
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/45661