University of the Aegean
Αντιμετωπίζοντας την παράτυπη μετανάστευση: ανάλυση και αποτίμηση της διεθνούς επιρροής και «επίδοσης» της Ευρωπαϊκής Ένωσης
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe EU is becoming an increasingly important player on the world stage, while its common external action is constantly expanding in new areas. Irregular migration and the management of the modern form of the migratory phenomenon are one of them. After the end of the cold war, EU gradually was confronted with the crucial question of the successful management of the migratory challenge. In 2015, EU was called upon to face the greatest post-war migratory challenge, as the massive mixed flows of irregular migrants and refugees, which were unprecedented in size, put the whole system in crisis. In the light of the EU's view as an international act, this PhD thesis focuses on the external actions of the European migration policy, of which the handling of irregular migration is a constituent element. The purpose is twofold. On the one hand, to record its influence on immigration issues, whether and to what extent it is capable of effectively influencing its external environment. On the other hand, to detect its international performance which includes the notion of influence, but also other characteristics that define the dynamics of its international role. Both international influence and the international performance of the EU, which is perceived as a dependent variable of its intra-organisational characteristics, its actions and their effectiveness, will be considered in two cases. The first concerns the migration crisis of 2015. The second concerns EU participation in the UN negotiations on the creation of a new international regime on migration issues and its contribution to the formulation of both the global agenda of the new regulatory framework and the regulatory framework itself. Part I presents the two working cases that direct research and analysis on the issue of assessing the EU's international influence and performance. Both working cases focus on the external interactions of the EU by associating them with the international environment. It follows the methodological tool through which the empirical material was organized and processed. This is the Analytical Framework of the EU International performance of Spyros Blavoukos and Dimitrios Bourantonis. The aforementioned framework will be used as an analytical basis to direct research to the aim of evaluating the international performance of the EU, on the one hand in managing the migration – refugee crisis of 2015 and on the other, the Negotiations in the UN framework for the creation of a new international regime on migration issues. According to the analytical framework, international performance will be examined in three levels of analysis, the first of the policy output, the second of the policy outcome and the third of the impact that this policy can have on the international environment. Also, a brief record of the modern debate on EU as a subject of the international system, its external identity and international action, and the review of the international Bibliography on the EU as a subject of action and the theoretical assumptions are presented. Part II seeks to assess the EU's international action to manage the migration crisis. Part III examines the EU's performance in the negotiations for the adoption of the two UN global Compacts for refugees and migrants. Part IV presents the conclusions of the analysis, which was guided by the assumptions, used the empirical data and elaborated with the implementation of the analytical framework for the valuation of the international performance of EU. According to the conclusions, in the first case, assessing the international influence of the EU in managing the crisis of 2015, it was found that EU achieved its main objective of halting migratory flows and returning to the pre-crisis levels. So it was effective. However, as far as its overall performance is concerned, it was found that from the outset the internal policy production process for crisis management, which took place under high pressure, was problematic. It was characterised by confrontations not only between the Member States, but also between the institutions, while setting a series of lofty objectives with regard to the internal aspects of the crisis, which did not reflected the will of all Member States. This resulted in an ' implementation gap ' between the decisions and the compliance of the Member States. Throughout the crisis, not only did the dissenting Member States comply with the decisions, but were taken unilaterally and contrary to the Community logic of solidarity and joint responsibility. However, despite the institutional failure to direct crisis management and the dramatic division of Member States, EU managed, shifting the centre of gravity of Management to the external aspects of crises, to bring about the desired result of containment flows at its external borders. In the latter case, assessing the EU's international influence in the negotiations on the adoption of the two UN Global Compacts for migration and refugees, it was found that EU influenced the results of the negotiation and achieved the objectives in both cases. The Global Compact for migration clearly reflects the European approach. In the case of the Global Compact for Refugees, its main negotiating positions were fully integrated into the text of the Compact. In this case, however, its international performance has been overshadowed by issues of cohesion and heterogeneity among its member States. During the negotiations, EU came up against crucial challenges arising from its insufficiently entrenched cohesion and the partial homogeneity of the Member States. In both cases, the EU arose as an international leadership of during the migration crisis. EU in all cases in its cooperation with third countries has exercised its influence to guide their behaviour towards the desired direction. In the negotiations for the adoption of the two UN Global Compacts, the EU played a leading role with institutional confidence. Despite the issues of internal cohesion and controversy that it faced, it created the concept of an international act that can represent and bring together third countries with which it has developed a nexus of cooperative relations. A common point of the two case analyses used, is the finding that EU as an international actor can effectively influence the international environment.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Chatziantoniou, Aikaterini
- Χατζηαντωνίου, Αικατερίνη
Subjects
dc:subject × 14Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/45670