National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Μονομερής και αμφιμερής πλάνη ως προς τις ιδιότητες προσώπου ή πράγματος
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe present Doctoral Thesis entitled "Unilateral and bilateral error as to the properties of a person or thing" consists of the Introductory Part and eight (8) separate Chapters (Chapter One - Chapter Eight) with bibliographical and jurisprudential documentation.The starting point of the examination is the historical research of the matter with reference to the passages of the Law of the Pandecten, D.18.1.9, 18.1.11, 18.1.14 (Ulpianus). From the study of the Sources, significant findings are concluded on the approach of the error in the properties of classical Roman jurists. The point of departure of the theory of error, and as to the error with item properties of the person or thing, for the continental laws based on the Byzantine Roman tradition, as is the case for the Greek Civil Code, is the Roman law. In this context, the issue of inserts (Interpolationes) and the problem of insertion in relation to the relevant passages is raised. The historical examination illuminates the evolution of the theory of error and the formation of the notion of properties in time, while at the same time it is a source of interpretation of Article 142 of the Greek Civil Code (Αστικός Κώδικας – Α.Κ.) "error referring to the properties of the person or thing".Chapter One investigates the error in the properties of a person or thing as a material error in productive causes and as an exception to Article 143 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.). In the configuration of the error in properties historically as type exceptionally significant error in productive causes have contributed the theories of Savigny and Zitelmann. In the answer to the key question, what is the criterion for recognising the essential nature of the error is an extensive analysis.The legal characterization of the error in properties is also connected with the determination of the thing. In Chapter Two, the error as to the properties of a thing is examined in relation to the law of defects, and issues arising from the simultaneous parallel application of Article 142 and Articles 534 et seq of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.) are resolved.In Chapter Three, the elements of the Rule of Article 142 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.) are analysed. As regards the important character of the property in accordance with the agreement of the parties or on the basis of good faith and fairness and commercial practices, the supported views in Greece and Germany, where the corresponding to Article 142 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.) § 119 II BGB applies, legislative model for the regulation of Article 142 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.), are mentioned and analysed. There are listed and analysed cases of properties of the person and of the thing important for the contract. Particularly is examined the importance of good faith in Article 142, and also in Article 144 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.) and its purpose in Articles 142, 388 and 200, 288 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.). The question of the unilateral or bilateral nature of the error and its importance for the applicable provisions is emphasized. It is examined in the same Chapter the avoidance of a real estate contract which is transcribed, due to an error in the properties of the thing.In Chapter Four is examined and analysed the error as to the foundation of the contract (subjective contractual foundation). This error is determined by the fact of misconfiguration of the will of the parties for the existence of a crucial element (of the foundation) of the contract, and is therefore closely related to the error and eventual fulfillment of its conditions leads to the avoidance of the contract. The hesitation, whether the error of the foundation of the contract acts as a means of circumventing the rule of non-essential character of error in productive causes of will, is not right, mainly because of the safeguards of the objective criteria of good faith and fair trade practices, which are extensively defined in the dissertation. As legal basis of the error of the foundation of the contract, it is correct to invoke Article 388, in conjunction with Article 288 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.). Justifiable basis of intervention of the judge is the requirements of good faith and the commercial usage. For the issue of the risk imputation of error are made practical questions regarding the sharing of the risk of the existence or non-existence of the determining element for both parties. There is also a comparison of the elements of the error on the contractual foundation with the elements of the error in properties.In Chapter Five, Flume's theory as to the error in properties is presented and criticized.Chapter Six examines specific provisions of Family and Inheritance Law for the error in properties and on the basis of the contract.Chapter’s seventh object is the exclusion of the avoidance of the act under Article 144 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.) in a systematic examination to Article 181 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.) and to the partial avoidance of the act, with application and to error as to the properties as well. A comparison is made between what applies to partial nullity and partial avoidance of the contract. The function of good faith in Article 181 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.) especially on partial avoidance of the contract is approached.The theoretical approach of the subject is combined with its practical application through the cited and commented cases of court decisions, but also by the presentation of practical examples in the entire Thesis. Athens July 2019 A. Chatzisevastou
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Chatzisevastou, Anthoula
- Χατζησεβαστού, Ανθούλα
Subjects
dc:subject × 8- Μονομερής και αμφιμερής πλάνη στις ιδιότητες προσώπου ή πράγματος ουσιώδης κατ' άρθρο 142 Α.Κ.
- Πλάνη ως προς το θεμέλιο της δικαιοπραξίας (υποκειμενικό δικαιοπρακτικό θεμέλιο)
- Unilateral and bilateral error as to the properties of a person or thing substantial in Article 142 of the Greek Civil Code (Α.Κ.)
- Error as to the foundation of the contract (subjective contractual foundation)
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Social Sciences
- Law
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/45992