Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Τα όρια των περιορισμών του δικαιώματος έφεσης στη διοικητική δίκη
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe requirement for secondary judicial protection may be rational when assessed on the basis of the functional dimension of judicial protection. The holding position that refuses to secure an appeal under Article 20 (1) of the Constitution is based on the literal interpretation, while not making proper use of other interpretative methods and principles. The reasoning behind the position reveals a restrictive interpretative starting point, which can be explained by the limited jurisdictional resources but cannot be justified in terms of substantive justice. Τhe judicial protection commenced when the case is brought to the first instance of jurisdiction may, in some cases, not be completed within that degree, due to an error in the judgment. When the judicial protection is not completed can and should be decided by the appellate judge after making a total and substantive assessment of the case. Only in the context of a judicial review can the actual limits of the restriction of appeal be disclosed. In the annulment proceedings, since Article 95 (3) of the Constitution expressly permits, on the basis of the minor importance of the case, to bring a dispute as irrevocable, it is then implied that it imposes, by reason of the major importance of the case, the exercise of appeal. In accordance with article 2 (1) of Protocol No.7 ECHR, if a dispute is declared by the judge to be an administrative criminal law dispute, the compatibility of the provision limiting the appeal with the provision of article 2 (1) must be checked. In substantive administrative litigation, the financial conditions of an appeal increase the final cost of litigation to such an extent that the social dimension of the right to judicial review is invalidated. The proportionate fee of the appeal is constitutional, as a legislative provision, but must also be constitutional when it is implemented. The money limits of the irrevocable are proposed to be adjusted - by reducing them - to the data of the current socio-economic context. In the field of the annulment proceedings, the regulation of article 12 par. 2 of Law 3900/2010 removes the judicial review from the infringement of the substantive right. To the extent that it excludes an appeal on real issues, it seeks to alter the nature of the appeal. Appeals in the annulment proceedings have lost their status as a regular remedy and are allowed only in exceptional cases and for legal reasons only. It is proposed that the appeals system be amended by a law that will allow appeals upon judicial authorization granted by the formation of the Council of State. Judicial authorization is proposed to be granted for all the decisions issued by the regular administrative courts on the basis of the consequences for the applicant or the importance of the legal issue raised in the particular case.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Koukoutsis, George
- Κουκούτσης, Γεώργιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 10Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/46319