University of the Aegean
Analysing information security behaviour: technological-organisational-individual framework and practical guidelines to enhance ISP compliance
Abstract
dc:descriptionWith the advancement of technology leading to new security threats and vulnerabilities and the enforcement of the General Protection Regulation (GDPR) according to which organisations must be compliant with its regulatory requirements and implement security and privacy by design (Karyda & Mitrou, 2016; Mitrou, 2017a), effective employee security behaviour is needed more than ever. Moreover, organisations invest heavily in security countermeasures, designing information security policies (ISPs) to protect their information assets and to safeguard against financial loss or other damage to their organisation, and yet security incidents continue to occur, often as a result of employees’ failure to comply with information security policies (Bulgurcu et al., 2010). In short, there is a clear gap in organisations addressing the “human aspect” of security and understanding of how to achieve the appropriate security behaviour from their employees. In order to address this gap, this Thesis aims to answer two main research questions: a) which factors influence employee security behaviour; and b) how knowledge of these factors can be exploited to help security managers enhance security management practices and thus encourage employee security behaviour to be in line with the organisation’s security objectives. With the first research objective in mind, a critical analysis and review of relevant literature was carried out to identify all factors influencing ISP compliance and security behaviour. After analysing relevant literature, it was identified that there is a plethora of different factors, which, while useful, are not comprehensible or useful to security managers for a variety of reasons: they often present unclear or conflicting results, such as the effect of sanctions ; different terms are used to describe similar concepts adding confusion to the field, as in the case of punishment severity (or deterrent severity) and in the case of resource availability and facilitating conditions; also, specialised terminology used is often confusing as it is drawn from theories that security managers are unlikely to be familiar with, such as self-efficacy, perceived value congruence etc. Furthermore, an important finding of the analysis of related literature was that the role of technology and its characteristics affect security behavior however their role is not adequately studied and addressed in relevant literature. To further explore the technological factors that influence users to use security and privacy tools a survey was conducted among 150 ICT Students to investigate the usability of security and privacy tools. A combination of different research instruments was employed in this survey including scenarios, questionnaires and interviews. Findings show that users value usability security characteristics such as accessibility, language, intuitiveness, efficiency, feedback and errors, error prevention, undo actions, availability of information, design and consistency, characteristics relevant to installation, privacy characteristics and automation. Based on the findings from the literature review and the survey, a framework of factors influencing security behaviour was created. The framework which consists of these factors grouped into three categories along with the analysis of their implications facilitate security management address the multi-faceted issue of security behaviour. This framework presents a comprehensive analysis of all factors that influence security behaviour, classified under three main categories addressing individual, organisational and technological aspects. The aim of this framework is to act as a roadmap of the different factors that security managers need to consider when designing and implementing ISPs. Subsequently, the practical value of this framework was further investigated by analysing current security management practices provisioned in the ISO/IEC 27000 series, namely ISO 27001, 27002, 27003 and 27005. Through a gap analysis several factors influencing security behaviour were identified, which are not addressed in the ISO Standards, including top management participation, cultural context, cost of compliance, habits, individual characteristics and values. Furthermore, practical guidance is provided on how to integrate current security management with practices that support security behavior. To validate the applicability of the framework a case study was performed in a large organisation. The case study aimed to analyse the current security management practices of the organisation and to identify aspects of the framework that were implemented. Through this case study it was possible to identify the security management practices that are currently applied and gain insights into the practices followed in the day-to-day running of the organisation. An important finding is that this organisation supports teleworking and has recognised the importance of informing users about the threats and risks that might take place during teleworking by designing new ISPs for this purpose. This highlights the need for organisations to be aware of the constant evolution of technology, its impact on the workplace and the resulting need to update their practices accordingly. Furthermore, the case study offers additional insights into how an organisation may motivate employees to adopt the appropriate security behaviour: firstly, through the use of practical methods such as cards or posters; secondly by promoting an organisational information security culture of communication, common values and openness. Finally, the case study reveals how this organisation’s individual stance on sanctions (no sanctions are applied for ISP non-compliance despite ISO recommendations) may be the most appropriate policy for this organisation. Besides providing suggestions for further enhancement of security management practices, the case study also concludes that in terms of employee security behaviour there is a need for more customised security management practices to suit the information security needs of particular organisations rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. Finally, drawing from research findings, the usability study, the ISO Standards gap analysis and the case study, this Thesis meets the second research objective by providing practical guidelines, to enable security managers to better understand security behaviour and enhance their current security management practices. This set of guidelines focuses principally on those areas which findings from the present study have identified as both significant factors influencing employee security behaviour and factors which are insufficiently addressed either in current literature and/or the widely adopted ISO standards. This Thesis contributes to the field of security behaviour and ISP compliance by: a) identifying and analysing conflicting results and confusing terminology in related literature, b) justifying the role of technology for shaping security behaviour and analysing relevant factors that influence the use of security and privacy controls. It also identifies the need for developers to consider the usability characteristics identified in order to design usable security tools. c) providing guidelines to enhance security management and addressing the gaps in current security management approaches following ISO 27001, 27002, 27003 and 27005 Standards with regard to top management participation, the cultural context, cost of compliance, habits, individual characteristics, perceptions about threats and capabilities, values, different types of security awareness and social influence. Overall, this Thesis bridges the gap between theory and practice by providing security management a roadmap, in the form of a three categories framework and a set of applicable, as shown through the case study, guidelines to enhance security behaviour and ISP compliance. Overall, this Thesis provides a roadmap to address the individual, organisational and technological aspects of security behaviour that can lead to improved ISP compliance. Finally, as the field of information security is highly complex and undergoing rapid changes as a result of new technologies and changing work styles, we conclude that there is a standing need for further research into the role of the human aspects of information security and the role of technology for shaping security behaviour.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Topa, Ioanna-Aikaterini
- Τόπα, Ιωάννα-Αικατερίνη
Subjects
dc:subject × 9Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/46411