Back to search

Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)

Η αρχαιολογία της κλινικής: ο Ιπποκράτης και η μανία στις επιδημίες Ι-VII του corpus Hippocraticum και στη δυτική επιστημονική παράδοση

Abstract

dc:description

The dissertation examines the role of Hippocrates in the subsequent history of Western Medicine and “Psy” disciplines. Drawing on Foucault’s “toolkit”, it explores the appropriation of Hippocrates by French physicians of the 1790-1815 era. During that time, Hippocrates appears to be (i) the founder of clinical medicine (le fondateur) and a clinical observation genius (au génie observateur), (ii) the author of the exemplary patient reports of Epidemics, (iii) the inventor of a new technical vocabulary and a new language for the description of diseases (qui inventa le langage propre à la méthode descriptive des maladies) and (iv) the model of a new observational method (Hippocrate n'en doit pas moins servir de modèle). Those are all representations brought to life by the pioneers of the ‘Paris School’—a group of clinicians as renowned as Ph. Pinel, M.-Fr.-X. Bichat, P.-J. Desault, J.-L. Alibert, R.-Th.-H. Laennec, P.-J.-G. Cabanis─ in support of their own views. The thesis demonstrates the function of these representations in the pre- and proto- psychological and psychiatric discourse. Sources include Hippocratic treatises (Epidemics I-VII); ancient and modern commentaries; treatises on medical history, meteorology, nosography; neohippocratic writings. The questions asked are: What is the role of Great Authors, like Hippocrates, within a field of knowledge? What could the demand for a "return to Hippocrates” during moments of “complex historical transformation” of a scientific field mean? The first chapter describes the methodological demands of a critical historical analysis, emphasizing (a) the system of concepts, methods, principles whereupon lies the analysis of the function of the "Great Authors" and (b) the elements of the above system used by the study. The second chapter investigates the uses of Hippocrates in the clinical discourse of the pioneers of the Paris School with emphasis on Ph. Pinel, R.-Th.-H. Laennec, P.-J.-G. Cabanis. The third chapter examines the relation of Hippocrates with the famous books of Epidemics which, in the 19th century become a point of reference and a theoretical springboard for clinical research. The fourth chapter examines the relation of Hippocrates with the construction of a new clinical description language and the remoulding of classical nosological categories claiming a «Hippocratic» descent. The fifth chapter examines the relationship of Hippocrates with a complex transformation of medical understanding that brought along «a number of requisites, or references» including «progress in observation», but also new institutions (the clinic) or methods (Analysis) which determined the interaction between the apparatus of Greek medicine and the elements of modern scientific discourse. The dissertation concludes that the European post-medieval “Hippocrates” was less of an actual historical figure and more of an invention of the French clinicians who used the “Father of Medicine” to strengthen their own status quo. The numerous reinventions of the ancient Greek thinker reinforce this hypothesis. One of the most attractive ones, during the 1790-1815 period was the Hippocrates of Francis Bacon’s “De Augmentis Scientiarum” (1623)1: a methodical observer of the natural history of diseases, of data taxonomy, of the deduction of general principles and laws through the study of individual clinical histories. This type became closely related to the appearance of a pivotal idea for the mythology of the modern medical ideal: that of the “médécin observateur”, of an “an empirical vigilance receptive only to the evidence of visible contents” as Foucault will say. As far as its historical documentation is concerned, that was provided by the “Epidemics” books (5th/4th cent. B.C.). The French neo-Hippocratics found in those an “art of observation” (art de bien observer) far from any vain theory (pour toute théorie vaine) and an empirical method of knowledge that could provide a solid scientific foundation to Western medicine. One condition for this method was, as Pétroz admits, the forming of a clinical description language modelled after the ancient Greek one. On this was founded a new knowledge, intended for the protection of “hygiene” and for the medical surveillance of the population —a “medical-administrative” knowledge that will, according to Foucault, form the core of “social economy” or 19th century sociology, and manage to minutely surveil individuals and groups.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Year dc:date
2019

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Stamati, Panagiota
  • Σταμάτη, Παναγιώτα

Subjects

dc:subject × 23

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY_NC_ND
Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/46540

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Stamati, Panagiota; Σταμάτη, Παναγιώτα. Η αρχαιολογία της κλινικής: ο Ιπποκράτης και η μανία στις επιδημίες Ι-VII του corpus Hippocraticum και στη δυτική επιστημονική παράδοση. Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH), 2019. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/46540