University of Peloponesse
Boosting organizational decision making through structured Super-Forecasting: a risk management based approach
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe success of the Good Judgment Project in harnessing the power of superforecasting naturally leads to the question as to how one can implement that approach on a smaller scale with more limited resources and fewer participants. Small(er) corporate environments and SME-type decision structures are prime examples where a modified superforecasting approach can be used. In this research we focus on a hybrid approach of judgmental forecasting on special events where we combine training of superforecasters- to-be via the concept of a modified version of structured analogies, a staple of judgmental forecasting in the literature. We call the resulting approach structured superforecasting and illustrate its efficacy over samples of participants from the wider public sector and the academic community. In particular, with a proper experimental design that includes a training and a control group, we apply the above methodology and compare performances. Our analysis of the results utilizes, beyond standard measurement concepts of judgmental forecasting, the methodology of stochastic dominance (SD) to evaluate the performance of participants -- for the first time to the best of our knowledge in this strand of the literature. The use of the SD concept is important for two reasons: first, it allows a complete/better view of outperformance compared to more traditional statistics and, second, it provides compelling visuals for the results across individual questions and across any sample split we wish. We find that, across most questions employed, analogies trained participants outperform the control group. Moreover, we also succeeded in the early identification of the consistently top-performing forecasters. This is an important and practical result which we validate for the first time. The implications of extending this research in other environments and different samples is obvious: expending effort and resources in training on analogies can super-charge super forecasting and thus tapping into the wisdom of the crowds does not need larger crowds but, importantly, smarter (by training) ones.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Peloponesse
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Katsagounos, Ilias
- Κατσαγούνος, Ηλίας
Subjects
dc:subject × 16Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/46808