Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Συμμετοχή και αειφορία: μέθοδος υποστήριξης λήψης αποφάσεων για τη βιώσιμη διαχείριση κοινόκτητων πόρων
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis PhD Thesis deals with the research and the development of an applied, practical method for the management of non-linear, non-regulatory human and natural common systems, such as the coastal zone, aiming to strike a balance across the three pillars of sustainability: economy, society and environment. With the Coastal Zone – one of the most complicated systems to manage – as the starting point, the aim of this Thesis evolved and expanded into the development of a wider method/framework, which could serve both as a robust, well documented decision support system and as a comprehensive framework of integrated management. Existing decision support methods are too complex and time consuming, and they usually demand expertise and highly accurate datasets (Loizidou, 2013). However, decisions are made by politicians, by Mayors and Municipal Boards, by people who have neither the capacity to use such complicated and sophisticated decision support systems, nor the time that is required to become familiar with these systems. It is thus important to develop decision support systems that are friendly to the non-expert users, i.e. the real decision makers. The relevant literature has been demonstrating for years that effective management of human/natural systems can be achieved through the development and implementation of decision support methods and through the structured participation of stakeholders (e.g. Clark, 2007; Reed, 2008). This concept guided the evolution of this Thesis towards developing an integrated management method, which would begin from a structured decision support process and develop into an integrated framework for the best possible inclusion of human actions into the natural system being studied. A simple and friendly-to-use method, addressed to the non-expert user who is the decision maker. A method that can also serve as a tool for capacity-building and knowledge transfer to the non-expert stakeholders. The result of this Thesis is the decision support method DeCyDe-4. It is a highly participatory, site and problem specific method, which incorporates a comprehensive and integrated management framework into the decision making process. The name of the method derives from the English word “decide”, where the “ci” is replaced with “Cy”, which is the shortcut for Cyprus, the writer’s homeland. Through a series of consecutive self contained, but at the same time interrelated steps, the method “produces” a specific structure for the problem/issue under study. The method considers the problem itself as the “system” and this “system” becomes the level of analysis, assessed in the parameters that better describe it. The success of DeCyDe-4 relies on the very detailed baseline study and the high level of expertise of the study team. The description of the existing situation and a detailed, accurate analysis and structure of the problem to be studied are important aspects of the success of the implementation of the method. Based on the System Approach Framework, DeCyDe-4 builds a dynamic system with four major characteristics to better describe the problem for which decision and management is required: 1. the problem is parameterized; 2. each parameter is broken down into the variables that better describe it; 3. inter-relations among parameters and their variables are identified; 4. active participation of stakeholders and decision makers is safeguarded. The results of the method must derive from a consensus by all the participants. The Adaptive Management framework (Tomlinson et al., 2011) is implemented throughout the process: the expert knowledge of the study team is transferred to the participants through the facilitator and the participants feed the facilitator with the good knowledge of the specific local conditions and the specific problems, gaps, and suggestions. The credibility of the results is combined with the simplicity in the implementation of the method and its short duration. This well structured participatory process incorporates knowledge transfer and capacity building and records collective intelligence. Innovative tools such as the “scoring through ranges” matrices, smart solutions such as the weighting “scores” through comparison between pairs, statistical, linguistic, analytical and numerical techniques, form an innovative and effective decision support system. The method aims towards simplicity, speed and ease of use, through the creation of enthusiasm and a pleasant, game-like atmosphere. Its target is to ensure that decision-makers (who lack expertise and scientific knowledge) will want to and be able to use a decision support system that they understand, and thus trust, and that helps them to identify their gaps, support their decision with data, try various scenarios, and become aware of new management possibilities. However, to achieve the level of simplicity and effectiveness that the user requires of DeCyDe-4, the developers/facilitators must be extremely well-prepared for the problem at hand. The expert team must have the necessary technical knowledge and a good under-standing of the site-specific parameters and the peculiarities of the problem, and must be able to gather the necessary scientific documentation. The most important characteristic of the method is that it can be adapted and developed to meet the specific needs and characteristics of the issue at hand, due to its highly flexible toolbox, which can be modified to meet the local peculiarities. The method’s modular structure allows the individual and independent use of each of its stages. The baseline study and the structured participation of stakeholders are mandatory elements, however. Since the completion of its evaluation and improvement phase, the DeCyDe-4 method has been implemented, in various forms, in over 20 different cases, providing solutions to a multitude of problems within the framework of national (Cyprus) and international projects. The various applications of the method have been published in international, peer reviewed journals (e.g. Marine Pollution Bulletin and Marine Policy), presented in international conferences and events, and included in the technical reports of research and applied projects where DeCyDe-4 was implemented for participatory decision-making on strategic development topics (e.g. for the implementation of the Marine Strategy Framework Di-rective in the Black Sea, the Adriatic and the Mediterranean, and the prioritization of measures to be implemented by the Republic of Cyprus within the framework of its Biodiversity Strategy). Finally, the DeCyDe-4 method has also been used for the development of several policy tools (ranging from marine litter management to the selection of practices for mitigating and adapting to sea level rise and extreme events in the Adriatic).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Loizidou, Polyxeni
- Λοϊζίδου, Πολυξένη
Subjects
dc:subject × 15- Αειφόρος ανάπτυξη
- Διαχείριση κοινόκτητων πόρων
- Συμμετοχική διαχείριση
- Διαδικασία λήψης αποφάσεων
- Εργαλεία πολιτικής
- Sustainble development
- Decision support method
- Stakeholders participation
- Policy tools
- Solution oriented method
- Adaptive management
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Πολιτικού Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Civil Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/46815