Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
Frontex and the evolution of European border control: a cultural approach
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn 2005, Frontex, the EU border control agency, started its operational function at the EU external borders. Since then, it has become a central component of the EU border control regime leading EU and national actions for the management of irregular migration. With continuous presence at the EU external borders and substantial mandate enhancements especially amidst the 2015 migration crisis that have rendered it the European Border and Coast Guard, Frontex constitutes one of the most controversial EU agencies. But, Frontex is not just an EU agency, as the academic literature often contends. Rather, it constitutes a key border control actor that shapes borders and border control in Europe. Zooming in Frontex as a border control actor, this thesis explores Frontex’s role in EU border control and at the EU external borders bringing culture in the analysis. Drawing on a social constructivist perspective, this thesis employs Ruben Zaiotti’s analytical framework of ‘cultures of border control’ focusing on border control assumptions and practices. This offers a new prism for Frontex’s scrutiny, because it allows the incorporation of ideational and inter-subjective elements in the analysis. Remedying a gap in the literature, which refers to the neglect of the existence and function of a border control community, this thesis examines Frontex as a border control actor embedded in a policy community. The central research question is ‘how does Frontex impact on the culture of EU border control?. To answer this question, this research follows a qualitative methodology comprising document analysis, institutional discourse analysis, semi-structured interviews with national border guards and Frontex officers, process-tracing, comparative case study analysis of the Greek land border Evros and the Italian sea border Lampedusa and in-situ analysis with fieldwork in these two borders. This thesis argues that Frontex shapes the EU border control by pursuing a new border control culture, which has contested the Schengen regime and now constitutes the dominant culture of border control in Europe. This culture consists of a new border control community, which promotes assumptions and practices for border control encountered not only in Frontex but also at the borders. Thus, there has been an evolution from the Schengen regime of border control to a new model. Through the conduct of primary research and analysis, this thesis reveals a new reality at the borders and a different function of Frontex that transcends the agency’s technical and managerial role set by its original mandate. Hence, this thesis contributes to the discussion on the EU-level response to irregular migration and the nature of border control especially in today’s highly polarised environment dominated by irregular migration concerns.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Sarantaki, Antonia-Maria
- Σαραντάκη, Αντωνία-Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 13Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/46930