Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Environmental assessment of new technologies: two case studies, in a pear orchard and in energy crops

Abstract

dc:description

Sustainable agriculture aims at optimizing the inputs, increasing profits, and reducing the adverse environmental impacts. Assessment of environmental impacts of human activities is the aim of many studies and methodologies. LCA is a method used to evaluate the environmental burdens associated with products or processes while taking their whole life cycle into consideration; that is from raw material extraction, to the production of the product till its consumption and the final waste disposal. This is referred to as cradle to grave approach. LCA is a comprehensive assessment method which considers all aspects of natural environment, human health, and resources. The present research is an application of the LCA methodology in the assessment of the environmental impact of agricultural practices. The methodology applied is based on ISO standardization. Two different case studies have been evaluated: a) Variable Rate Application (VRA) of Nitrogen (N) in a pear orchard using Precision Agriculture (PA) technology, and b) Biomass production under conventional and conservation tillage systems.Precision agriculture (PA) is a management approach for sustainable agriculture, developed to manage the spatial and temporal variability in fields resulting in the optimization of inputs, profits and the environmental impacts. Although many studies have analysed the effects of PA system on production and profit, there are limited results concerning its influence on the environment. The present study comes to fill this gap by assessing the environmental impact of sustainable management practices and precision technologies using both experimental measurements and Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)methodology. Biomass production and use for second generation biofuels like bio‐ethanol,will remove all lignocellulosic material from the fields. This land use change can cause soil degradation. Using conservation agriculture this effect could be mitigated. The present study investigates the environmental implications of establishing a novel crop rotation system with double cropping per year and reduced or no tillage treatments, using the LCA methodology. The LCA goal and scope was defined for each study along with the system boundaries and the functional unit (FU).The ultimate aim for the pear study was to reveal and compare the environmental impacts of using different N fertiliser application techniques(uniform and VRA). The FU used was the 1 kg output of fresh pears. The ultimate aim for biomass study was to reveal and compare the environmental impacts of using different tillage practices for seedbed preparation (conventional and conservation tillage: Reduced tillage RT I, RT II, RT III and no‐till tillage) in an innovative crop rotation system, combining winter and spring crops, in order to achieve a continuous soil coverage of the field throughout the year. The FU used was 1 kg output of dry biomass. Both case studies concerned Cradle to Gate studies, i.e., an assessment of a partial life cycle of a product,from the extraction of raw materials (cradle) up to the production of the product, “gate”. Inventory step was compiled by three data systems. Primary data were used in the foreground data system, while the background data concerned all the information about the inputs production stage from raw material. A third category of data was developed,the semi‐specific data, which concerned data coming from the background database adapted for the circumstances of the present study. The direct and indirect emissions for all three environmental compartments, water, air and soil, were calculated using specific models. Assumptions were made for both case studies. The main assumption about the pear study was that the analysis will include all the emissions and resource uses of the orchard’s lifetime and all the production phases and as a next step the average of the pear orchard would be calculated. A methodology was adopted for modelling individual year sand averaging over the orchards life time, rather than calculating the impact results for each year and then averaging. The main assumption in the biomass study was the comparison of the proposed crop rotations system with the monoculture crop system,which is the prevailing cropping practice in the irrigated areas of the region under study. In Impact Assessment step, the ReCiPe midpoint method was used, for both studies, as the default method. This choice was relied on the fact that impact categories at the midpoint have a stand‐alone value in a midpoint‐oriented LCIA method, which is also usable as anintermediate step in an endpoint‐oriented method.The experimental results in the pear study showed that VRA of N fertilizer, resulted in up to 56% savings in two successive cultivation years, 2012 and 2013, compared to homogeneous N application. After the first year of N VRA the low yielding areas increased the yield of the subsequent year by 51%, while there was no effect in the high yielding areas. For the same study, LCA analysis revealed that when high fruit yield was combined with reduced over all N fertilisation amounts, using VRA technique, there was a reduction of the important emissions to air coming from the fertilisation agricultural practice.Climate change, Water scarcity, Fossil fuels and Particulate matter formation were the most contributing impact categories to the overall environmental impact of the whole lifespan of the pear orchard under study. For the biomass production study, the LCA analysis showed that the most important impact categories contributing to the total environmental impact were: Fossil and Land transformation CO2 (Climate Change), Human toxicity, Particular matter formation, Agricultural land occupation, and Water, Metal and Fossil depletion. The emissions due to fertiliser application and diesel fuel consumption, as well as for their production, were the processes with the greater influence on the overall environmental burden. When the different tillage practices were compared, reduced tillage treatments had the best environmental performance compared to conventional tillage in all important impact categories. The environmental impacts of the proposed crop rotation were compared with a single cotton crop prevailing in the area. When a mass based FU was used (1kg dry matter biomass), the results showed that cotton monoculture had higher environmental impacts. If an area based FU was used (1 ha), however, the results were reversed, except the total CO2 emission, where No‐tillage treatment had the best environmental performance. Using hectare as the functional unit does not take the productivity into account. In this case, yield is no more the key driver of the comparison but the amounts of inputs used, which comes in contrast with the concept of LCA methodology (LCA is a product oriented methodology).Generally, when the LCA analysis is combined with a long series of primary field data,it can be a valuable tool for assessing and analysing the environmental impact of different cropping systems and cultivation practices. The results from both experimental and LCA analysis of the first case study revealed that N VRA can be both a profitable practice for the farmer, due to fertilizer use reduction, and an environmentally sound technique due to improved N utilization; as N use efficiency increases, the environmental footprint of the orchard will decrease. As for the second case study, when crop rotation system is combined with reduced cultivation tillage practices, it can result in the lowest emissions per kg biomass produced. Thus, new technologies, VRA and conservation tillage, can be characterised as friendly to the environment agricultural practices that could be promoted by agricultural policy and adopted by the farmers.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2017

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Vatsanidou, Anna
  • Βατσανίδου, Άννα

Subjects

dc:subject × 13

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/47282

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Vatsanidou, Anna; Βατσανίδου, Άννα. Environmental assessment of new technologies: two case studies, in a pear orchard and in energy crops. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2017. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/47282