Back to search

Πανεπιστήμιο Μακεδονίας

Integration of management standards and systems: impact on corporate sustainability performance

Abstract

dc:description

Corporate sustainability is at the center of interest for many academics and professionals, especially in today's uncertain economic environment. The ability of companies to withstand and meet modern challenges in the highly volatile market conditions is being tested now more than ever. The oxymoron lies in that while the accounting and reporting of corporate sustainability performance have been greatly developed, its management within businesses remains a 'black box'. Corporate sustainability and corporate social responsibility reports are often limited to individual indicators and outcomes, without providing information on the processes and ways in which these outcomes emerge. The ambiguity and lack of documentation is reinforced by the confusion of terms and concepts, such as performance measurement, performance management and management system. In order to address this ambiguity, this doctoral dissertation offers a holistic systemic view of the performance of corporate sustainability extending beyond the 'measuring fixation and myopia'. In this context, business sustainability must first be integrated into a management system. Subsequently, the performance of this system should be managed and monitored. Effective corporate sustainability management requires the alignment of strategy, mode of operation and the results of business activities in terms of sustainability. In other words, the company needs to reconsider its 'introverted' perspective and manage the effects of its operation on a number of stakeholders in a systematic way. There are certain management systems that address corporate sustainability aspects and are based on international standards and guidelines, such as the ISO 9001 quality standard, the ISO 14001 environmental standard, the OHSAS 18001 standard (recently replaced by ISO 45001) for health and occupational safety, and the ISO 26000 guideline on corporate social responsibility. By definition, a fully integrated (unified) management system meets all the requirements posed by the standards, while management processes extend to all areas of business so that organizations get the maximum possible benefits from integration. In this context, the integration (unification) of the corresponding management systems 'comes naturally΄ to organizations that aim for sustainable development. Moreover, it has been established that integrated management systems, through the harmonized adoption of management standards, meet the requirements of all stakeholders. Having acknowledged the deficit of a systemic approach to the performance management of corporate sustainability on the one hand and the excess dynamics of integrated management systems to cover this deficit, this dissertation addressed the theoretical/conceptual and empirical correlation of these variables. In particular, the initial literature review identified the main research streams and their findings in terms of the motives, the benefits, the barriers and the audits of integrated management systems. Then, the combined adoption of generic and sectoral standards was examined both theoretically and empirically. The integration mechanism was analyzed in depth by the case study method. Some critical factors for the success or failure of integration systems, such as top management commitment, data and information management, integration level, resource constraints, and business relationships with customers, suppliers, consultants, government agencies and the environment have emerged. This was followed by the composition of a conceptual framework, the formulation of the main research hypothesis and the operationalization of the research variables. For the in-depth study and analysis of the main concepts, a systematic literature review was designed and implemented, in which the theories of stakeholders, resources and institutions were used. The main concepts are the internalization of integrated management systems and corporate sustainability performance. Internalization is first analyzed in two components: a) the resources (strategic, human, external, information, awareness and integration methods) allocated to integrate the systems, and b) the integration level. Corporate sustainability performance is analyzed in terms of the organisations’ stakeholders, which include customers, suppliers, employees, investors / shareholders, financial institutions, the environment, government agencies and society. According to the main research hypothesis, the internalization of integrated management systems has a positive effect on corporate sustainability performance. Survey research confirmed the correct formation of variables through exploratory and confirmatory factor analysis. More specifically, two measurement scales have been developed, one of which concerns the degree to which an integrated management system is internalized by the organization or, in other words, the extent to which experience from its implementation (resource use and process integration) is integrated into organizational knowledge. The second scale concerns the measurement of corporate sustainability performance. Then, the main research hypothesis was tested and confirmed using structural equation modeling. This method is suitable for testing models with a strong theoretical background (as in the case of this doctoral dissertation). The two measurement scales, derived from the conceptual framework and the operationalization of latent variables, were used to test the underlying causal relationship between internalization and performance. The main research hypothesis was confirmed, proving the positive effect of internalizing the integrated management system of an organization on its performance in terms of sustainability. In fact, best fit solution suggests that an integrated management system that invests in strategic development, raising employee awareness, formulating and using appropriate integration tools, and completing internal processes and audits has a positive impact on the organization's relationships with customers, suppliers, employees, investors / shareholders, government agencies, the environment and society. The performance evaluation framework that has been substantiated offers new arguments in the discussion of management system performance. In general, literature findings on the performance of standalone management systems are contradictory. This dissertation examines the combined effect of individual systems on an equally complex type of performance. Also, this is the first time the internalization of integrated management systems is being empirically investigated. For managers and other professionals that are involved in managing business operations, the results of this dissertation are equally important. The allocation of resources for the integration of systems that individually manage parameters, such as quality, environmental protection, energy and natural resources, health and safety of employees, corporate social responsibility, as well as the integration level of processes and procedures, can play a vital role in the survival and well-being of organizations. In addition, it is proven how important it is to change the stance of organizations towards management systems and, to the integrated ones, in particular. It is not enough to keep bureaucratic procedures and files. Streamlining and transforming integration experience through allocated resources and well-adjusted processes into organizational knowledge is imperative for the organisations’ prosperity.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Πανεπιστήμιο Μακεδονίας
Year dc:date
2020

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Gianni, Maria
  • Γιαννή, Μαρία

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY_NC
Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/47540

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Gianni, Maria; Γιαννή, Μαρία. Integration of management standards and systems: impact on corporate sustainability performance. Πανεπιστήμιο Μακεδονίας, 2020. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/47540