National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Μεθοδολογία σχεδιασμού συμβατών και επιτελεστικών κονιαμάτων αποκατάστασης για την αντισεισμική προστασία μνημείων και ιστορικών κατασκευών
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of this doctoral thesis is the development of an original methodology for the design of compatible and performing restoration mortars for the earthquake protection of monuments and historic structures. In order to achieve this aim, the study of three important historic structures is utilized. Specifically, the Catholicon of Kaisariani Monastery, an important mid-byzantine church and the Plaka Bridge of Arachthos river, a traditional historic bridge, located in the seismic areas of Athens and Epirus respectively, are studied, as well as the Holy Aedicule of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem, the most important monument of Christianity, whose structural integrity was at risk. These three monument were selected, as they present different construction materials and different structural systems, while they are also subjected to different environmental loads, thus guaranteeing the development of a universal approach which can be applied on any monument, taking its specific characteristics into account. Most importantly, these monuments were selected as study cases, on behalf of the interdisciplinarity employed during their study, which provides, within the framework of this doctoral thesis, the possibility of defining the critical thresholds of mechanical properties, which the restoration mortars must comply with in order to ensure their structural integrity and their seismic protection. The monument itself is at the core of the developed methodology. Each monument is studied in the current state and the results are taken into account in order to specify and prioritize design criteria for compatible and performing restoration mortars. Within this process, emphasis is given to the critical thresholds, which the physicochemical, microstructural and mechanical characteristics of the restoration mortar must abide to. It is obvious that the demands of the design criteria and the assignment of critical thresholds regarding the restoration mortar characteristics, create a defined space of acceptability, where the restoration mortar is both compatible and performing. Regarding the compatibility design criteria, acceptability limits set for different types of restoration mortars, related to compositional characteristics, as measured through thermogravimetric analysis and microstructural characteristics, as measured through mercury intrusion porosimetry, are utilized as critical thresholds regarding physicochemical compatibility of the restoration mortar. Characterization and decay diagnosis of the historical materials is at the center of both the design and assessment of any restoration mortar in terms of compatibility. All instrumental techniques which have already been established in the Materials Science and Engineering Laboratory, are utilized for the study of both historical materials and restoration materials, and the results allow for the definition of critical thresholds regarding additional restoration mortar characteristics, where compatibility is ensured.Regarding the performance design criteria, the mechanical properties of the restoration mortars are taken into account and assessed in relation to the critical thresholds set by the finite element model analysis (in the case of the Holy Aedicule of the Holy Sepulchre) or by the fragility analysis (in the case of the Kaisariani Monastery Catholicon) results, corresponding to the demanded value of the restoration mortars compressive strength, capable of ensuring an adequate response of the monument under static and dynamic loads. In both cases the real material data were incorporated within the computation models. Thus, structural analysis results reveal the minimum demanded compressive strength that the restoration mortar must present. In the case of the Holy Aedicule, where the proposed restoration mortar was applied during the restoration project, non-destructive techniques were utilized to assess the effectiveness of their application in terms of compatibility and performance, thus leading to a methodological approach regarding the assessment of mortar application in situ, in real scale and time. The design criteria are parameterized in order to define an area that delimits the characteristics that a restoration mortar must present in order to be compatible and performing, and which allows the selection of the most suitable raw materials from a wider range of materials. At the level of processing the big data that emerges, an original system for evaluating the restoration mortars is proposed, based on the above criteria and using importance weights, which differ for each monument, thus offering the possibility of choosing the optimal mortar for each case. The use of principal component analysis (PCA) proved particularly useful for the study of the restoration mortars examined in this thesis, as it managed to correlate their characteristics and distinguish restoration mortars according to their characteristics, thus facilitating the simultaneous investigation of both their compatibility and performance. At the same time, it is possible to use the PCA method as a tool to assess the compatibility of historical and restoration mortars in terms of composition and microstructural characteristics. In the last section of this thesis, artificial neural networks (ANNs) are developed and trained, aiming to facilitate the design of restoration mortars and creating an added, necessary innovation in the field of mortar design. It is the first time that ANNs are implemented within this framework, and the results highlight their potential as a tool in mortar design. In addition to revealing the effect of each parameter of synthesis (binder to sand ratio, water to binder ratio, maximum aggregate diameter and age of specimen) on the different mortar characteristics, ANNs can also reveal a recommended area of design, regarding mortar synthesis parameters, within which the restoration mortar is expected to develop characteristics as set by the compatibility and design criteria of each monument. Thus, while discrimination analysis within PCA facilitates the management and correlation of experimental data, the use of ANNs allows the examination of a wider area of mortar design, even of synthesis parameter combinations where no experimental data exists, allowing the study and design of the material in the multidimensional space defined by the parameters of mortar synthesis and allowing research to surpass the experimental process. The mortar design methodology developed in the current doctoral thesis, is conducted in a wide design framework, also at the level of correlation and simulation of mortar characteristics, thus configuring an integrated design framework. Mortar design is thus conducted within a continuous and integrated space of compatibility and performance, thus marking the developed methodology –parameterization of criteria, correlation of independent variables, discrimination analysis and simulation with ANNs– as an important tool for the design of compatible and performing restoration mortars, which can contribute to the earthquake protection of monuments and historic structures, as well ensure their structural integrity.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Apostolopoulou, Maria
- Αποστολοπούλου, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Προστασία μνημείων
- Συμβατότητα
- Επιτελεστικότητα
- Τεχνητά νευρωνικά δίκτυα
- Κριτήρια σχεδιασμού
- Κονιάματα αποκατάστασης
- Monument protection
- Compatibility
- Performance
- Artificial neural networks
- Design criteria
- Restoration mortars
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Επιστήμη Χημικού Μηχανικού
- Engineering and Technology
- Chemical Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/47665