National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Essays in alternative money, banking, finance: the monetary and financial nature of cryptocurrencies in distributed ledgers
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis PhD thesis is motivated by the unprecedented monetary and financial nature ofcryptocurrencies issued and circulated in Distributed Ledgers for that it has not beencollectively studied. Distributed ledgers can be viewed as payment networks operatingwithout intermediary for exchanging wealth wherein two roles are assumed. Morespecifically, that of clearing house (in settling transactions) and that of regulator (forcontrolling the supply). Aside from the former service which is commonplace in money issuance industry’s ordinary business of life, there is something unusual that stems from the latter that is, the system itself creates its own num´eraire referred to as cryptocurrency. Such alternative systems at least outwardly challenge and as though may supplant the established today’s banking and finance paradigm which is traditionally associated with (a) currencies (sovereign money) and (b) securities (either in the form of debt or equity). Interestingly, the latter, so far, are only expressed in the unit of account of the former. In the foreign exchange market, the supply of currencies is linked to the activities of commercial banking which are monitored by national and international monetary authorities. To that extent, cryptocurrencies can offer a wide variety of alternatives that were not previously available to private entities and the general public when it comes to designing investment assets, credit instruments and, of course, cash. Traditionally, these have been provided by institutions such as centralized exchanges, accredited banks by a central bank and the State. The first two chapters broadly examine the relevance of the newly established Distributed Ledgers ecosystems as well as the impact on the economic literature through ages. Chapter 1 first endeavors to collect and describe the varieties of Distributed Ledgersspanned throughout the first ten years following the inception of Bitcoin, yet from acritical perspective aiming to mark not only the dissimilarity with traditional monetaryand financial assets but also growth potential. This allows to better grasp the diversitywithin the market as all cryptocurrencies are not alike rather are created to serve different causes. Other pure financial (to fund a project in the form of a pre-payment), other pure monetary (to reward benevolent economic behavior, settle transaction cheaper than traditional banking systems or/and ensure stable purchasing power of a bundle of goods) and other a combination of the two. Cryptocurrencies only live in distributed ledgers and can be broadly distinguished between Algorithmic (if decentralized) and Token (if centralized, thus IOU). As the cryptocurrency market matures in volume and number of participants, we identified the need for a taxonomy able to classify the constant diffusion of wide-ranging cryptocurrencies into standard categorical asset classes on the basis of the criteria of liability, convertibility of collateral and revenue recognition which we embed. This is suited to formulate distinct accounting standards and tax policies of Initial Coin and Token Offerings. Chapter 2 contributes an all-encompassing survey of literature on this still unchartedbreed of research looming anew. A critical approach is employed in reviewingall related works on blockchain and cryptocurrencies research through ages. The maincontribution is filling the evident shortage of a literature review able to collectively record the chain of evolution of research on distributed ledgers, cryptocurrencies and blockchain. The inherent scope is to point out that this new research field embraces economic literature across all its main branches, thus not limited to financial economics in examining a new (alternative) asset market. To do so, we further contribute by identifying the four alternative perspectives that blockchain and cryptocurrencies blueprints have introduced and in turn, effectively challenge industry and literature for that they deliver new frameworks of (i) auctioneer (in clearing), (ii) organization (in governance), (iii) money (in exchange) and (iv) capital (in raising financing) which have been traditionally linked to the necessity of centralization. The next two chapters probe into the monetary nature of cryptocurrencies. Themotivation is to show why and how cryptocurrencies could play a significant role as asubstitute to traditional banking. Chapter 3 contributes a conceptual monetary analysis of cryptocurrencies. Ourapproach differs from all previous attempts by introducing all kinds of cryptocurrencies to the theory and practice of money and currency exchange rate arrangements. At the beginning, we attempt to position cryptocurrencies in the theory and concepts of money and banking. This work will have the effect of bringing cryptocurrencies as closely as possible to the definitions and operations of central and commercial banking. By mastering all varieties of cryptocurrencies (algorithmic, tokens, stablecoins) with respect to their monetary foundations, we envisage how competition with traditional banking in the money markets is likely to occur. Note that as monetary assets, cryptocurrencies are closer to currency, thus cash items rather to bank checking accounts, thus cash equivalent items for that the peer-to-peer (distributed) nature of the blockchain renders cryptocurrencies’ issuance irreversible. Though, cryptocurrencies look alike bank deposits for that their electronic nature allow geographically distant trades as opposed to currency. We conclude that (a) Token cryptocurrencies under quantity rules by meeting the deferred payments function can introduce competition to commercial banking’s checking accountsand pledged asset (short-term) lines of credit and (b) Stable cryptocurrencies by meeting the media of exchange function can introduce competition to commercial banking’s deposits alike e-money issuance institutions. Finally, (c) Algorithmic cryptocurrencies under quantity rules such as Bitcoin pertain investment nature whose intrinsic value stems from the usage of these coins in the decentralized built-in blockchain. These may be perceived as alternative commodities of digital nature chiefly demanded to store value. Notably, traditional currencies are still of the greatest value and importance to the real economy and surprisingly to cryptocurrency ecosystems as well for that they convey the intelligence of the prevailing num´eraire. The absence of inside money, however, due to lack of portfolio management activities impedes cryptocurrencies’ penetration into capital markets where the banking sector continues to prevail. In addition, we demonstrate the existing pluralism in cryptocurrency asset classes by showing all different trajectories of supply and demand functions in these markets. Chapter 4 focuses on Stablecoins. We set up a sample of 4 representative cryptocurrenciescorresponding to the main categorical cases of Stablecoins. This work contributesfresh insights with respect to their diverse monetary structures which adhere tofixed exchange rate regimes. We provide an empirical framework analogous to Impossible Trinity for exploring monetary arrangements across Stablecoins wherein reserves are held. While the hypothesis is supported for all cryptocurrencies in question, the trade-off combination among exchange rate stability, capital openness and monetary independence varies with the categorical types of Stablecoins. This uncovers the inherent constraints of their monetary structures compared to the rest genres of cryptocurrencies. This is the first work in this attempt for that the literature, so far, only focuses on empirically investigating the presence of financial theories in cryptocurrencies. The last two chapters delve into the financial nature of cryptocurrencies. The motivation is to infer trading behavior by showing recent developments in investment practice in constructing cryptocurrency portfolios while highlighting the role of grouping cryptocurrencies into asset classes and indexes for comparing and forecasting performance more evenly. Chapter 5 introduces cryptocurrencies to investment theory and practice. We firstlook at the different risk-return profiles of each asset class market leader and then construct various mean-variance portfolios to only include cryptocurrencies or blend these with traditional investment assets such as equities and currencies as well other such as commodities using a dataset of 6 cryptocurrencies and 10 ths. observations. The results are compatible with the literature highlighting the effect of reducing non-systemic risk. Chapter 6 contributes empirical evidence of market efficiency of cryptocurrency markets. We focus on examining trading behavior within and across cryptocurrency indexes which we set up. This work contributes to a growing literature which calls forconstructing crypto market indexes. The study of peer groups and indexes is important for matching investors’ tastes and preferences. The motivation is to identify similarities and differences in trading activity both across and within these composite indexes. We build indexes of daily returns using market capitalization data but useful extensions may include other variations. For assets, we use the daily change in prices (exchange rates). We use daily data frequency of 57 cryptocurrencies throughout their entire trading history corresponding to approximately 100 ths. observations, aiming to draw inferences about the weak form efficiency hypothesis, yet conditional on the varieties of crypto-asset classes (indexes). Against this background, we investigate stylized facts traditionally found in daily returns, by employing tests for the presence of random walks, white noise as well as tests for effects namely symmetric time-varying, risk premium, leverage, calendar and regime switching. The results support the existence of switch of states (high-low volatility, from negative to positive returns) while do not support the existence of calendar effects on Monday. With regards to the market cap indexes, most exhibit positive in-excess returns going towards the end of the week and especially on Friday and during the Weekend. The less likely anomaly this study can support is the existence of leverage effects.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Koutsoupakis, Dimitrios
- Κουτσουπάκης, Δημήτριος
Subjects
dc:subject × 9Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/47712