Back to search

Harokopio University

Στερεότυπα κατανάλωσης τροφής και εικόνας σώματος στα σύγχρονα μέσα επικοινωνίας: αποτίμηση μέσα από τις σειρές κινουμένων σχεδίων για παιδιά

Abstract

dc:description

Introduction/Aim: Animated cartoon characters/heroes are widely used for the promotion of foods in television, Internet and printed advertising. Research has shown that cartoon characters’ presence via food advertisements influence children’s perception of food, as well as their food choices. Nevertheless, there have been no studies which examine cartoon series in terms of food consumption context alongside the messages which are projected about foods, either through the spoken word and dialogues between cartoon protagonists or through televised frames in the context of children’s animated cartoon series. At the same time, a review of the relevant bibliography concerning the outward appearance of cartoon characters indicates an association between slim body and positive personality traits, without, however, investigation of accompanying messages relating to body weight and outward appearance. The aim of this study was to record the food-relevant content of popular children’s animated cartoon series and to identify foods consumed relative to characters’ body weight. Τraits inherent to main protagonists, such as outward appearance, physical activity and likeability by fellow characters were evaluated in relation to their body weight, and comments made about their outward appearance, either self-referential or made by fellow characters were recorded. Method: One hundred episodes of ten animated cartoon series with high television audience viewing (based on Average Minute Rating %) were reviewed. The series were selected from children’s TV programming reecting broadcasting ratings from year 2011 to 2013, on both public and private channels, and were aimed at children 4 to 14 years. Within the analytic framework of the episodes’ analysis, for the assessment of the consumption context, and of the messages from foods projected, food items projected were classified into ten categories and the various messages presented for each food category were rated as positive, negative or neutral, differentiating each according to whether it appeared in eating or non-eating scenes. In order to investigate food consumption relative to the body weight of the characters (thin, normal, overweight) foods were grouped into two basic categories: core foods, which could be consumed on a daily basis in order to meet the nutrient requirements essential for good health, and non-core foods, which could be included occasionally in the diet. The analysis focused on the main characters in each animated series. The context of heroes’ food consumption was recorded as alone or in the company of others, together with the place of consumption: home, restaurant, entertainment settings etc. Heroes' characteristics such as outward appearance, intelligence, kindness, mood and fellow characters’ general opinion for the character under analysis were evaluated as positive, negative or neutral. Engagement in physical activity were rated as high, medium or low. Finally, opinions expressed by characters concerning either their own outward appearance, or that of their co-protagonists were recorded verbatim, and evaluated as positive or negative. Results: Convenience foods (snacks, including chips, popcorns, pizza), sweets and soft drinks were seen to be consumed at least once in more episodes compared with the rest of the food categories (v=19, 27, 24 episodes respectively). Furthermore, these foods not only were they presented in far more episodes, but they also were found to be consumed in episodes where a higher frequency of consumption was recorded (more than five times per episode), (x2=15,43, df=2, p=0,001, x2=6,7, df=2, p=0,035, and x2=6,81, df=2, p=0,033, respectively). The analysis also showed that where snacks were consumed, it was also likely that soft drinks would also be consumed, irrespective of consumption rate (x2=6,45, df=1, p=0,001). In total 361 food-related messages were recorded: 213 neutral, 125 positive, 23 negative. Irrespective of whether they were accompanied by eating or non-eating scenes, snacks and sweets comprised almost half of the positive messages (61 out of 125) in the sample, whereas soft drinks, whether actually consumed or simply present on screen, were accompanied by neutral messages in the majority of cases (n=33). In the same sample of animated cartoons, with foods classified as core or non-core, it was found that 37 main characters consumed 179 foods, 120 of which were non-core. Overweight characters consumed 58% of the non-core foods, and 48% of the total foods, core and non-core. As for the consumption context, most of the food, whether core or non-core, was consumed in the company of friends (85%) and that most of the core foods were consumed in entertainment settings. On the other hand, non-core foods were more usually consumed at home (43%) rather than in eateries such as restaurants or fast-food outlets (31%). Of the 37 characters, 21 were of normal weight, ten were thin, and six were overweight. Significant correlations emerged between body weight and outward appearance/attractiveness (x2=21,84, df=4, p<0,001). Specifically, nine out of ten slim characters were considered good-looking. Also, co-protagonists’ acceptance/positive opinion for the characters differed (x2=12,70, df=4, p=0,013) according to their body weight category. The ten slim protagonists received positive comments/messages on their outward appearance from their fellow characters, whereas only one of the six overweight characters got positive comments. The body weight of the characters appears to be related to the number of positive comments they received from co-protagonists (F=6,821, df=2, p=0,003). Finally, the number of positive messages received from co-protagonists differed for slim (M=4,3, SD=5,87), normal weight (M=0,14, SD=0,35) and overweight (M=0,17, SD=0,16) characters. Conclusions: This study indicates that children’s animated cartoon series project numerous food-related messages. The messages mainly referred to foods of low nutritional value, such as convenience foods and snacks, sweets and soft drinks, items which were frequently projected in an attractive way, sometimes simply visually presented in the film shot, or as a topic of discussion between cartoon characters. Conversely, the projection of healthier food such as fruit or vegetables was limited. The findings of the study show an association between food consumption and body weight, indicating not only that slim characters consumed fewer portions of food, but also that overweight characters consumed more non-core foods than their normal weight counterparts. Positive character traits such as attractive outward appearance and a higher physical activity level were usually identified with slim characters, and most positive comments from other characters regularly referred to them. Children are vulnerable to media’s messages and the exposure to animated cartoons could form their perceptions about their own food choices, awareness of body image and weight, and other personality issues. This study’s results could be used to benefit public health as it was shown that body weight of cartoon characters seems to follow stereotypic perceptions which value slimness and relate unhealthy food consumption with overweight. At the same time, food messages in the animated series mainly reffered to foods of low nutitional value. Those findings raise concern about whether specic rules, similar to those already in force for advertisements, should be applied regarding the food and body image content of children’s programs.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Harokopio University
Year dc:date
2020

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Tzoutzou, Milia
  • Τζούτζου, Μήλια

Subjects

dc:subject × 19

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/47862

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Tzoutzou, Milia; Τζούτζου, Μήλια. Στερεότυπα κατανάλωσης τροφής και εικόνας σώματος στα σύγχρονα μέσα επικοινωνίας: αποτίμηση μέσα από τις σειρές κινουμένων σχεδίων για παιδιά. Harokopio University, 2020. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/47862