Hellenic Open University
Methods of assessing the students’ perfomance upon utilization of a virtual reality educational tool for laboratory biology courses
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn Natural Sciences, knowledge is based on two strongly-related but different components: Content and Skills. Educators in Institutions are well qualified in content development and well trained to choose the appropriate learning method to transfer it to their students through their teaching. But skills development is another matter and it is much more linked to specific instruction approaches and technologies. Virtual Reality (VR) technology, as a tool to communicate to students the understanding of content and at the same time to offer practice on hands-on skills, has been very eminent during the last decade and is poised to significantly transform the landscape of science education. Big investments, by leading technology companies like Apple, Google, Facebook, Microsoft and Samsung, indicate that VR will be used in the future for many applications, including learning. In the field of Natural Sciences, the innovative VR-enhanced laboratories are the new educational trend as they are aligned with the modern idea that learning is an active and iterative process. The overall aim of this thesis was to use a variety of assessment methods to explore the potential predominant effectiveness of acquiring knowledge in the domain of microscopy, by the use of a 3D, VR educational tool of high level of realism, versus more traditional didactic practices. The research was focused on the microscopy experiment, a common entry-level experiment in the field of Biology. The need to investigate the contribution of a VR educational tool in the learning procedure of a laboratory course is nowadays more imperative than ever. The field of education faces new challenges, posed by the COVID-19 pandemic crisis, with 1.53 billion students out of school during compulsory home confinement. The educational community is called upon to deal with the new data created by the recent pandemic: (a) the educational institutions closure and (b) the need for reviving online teaching and learning. Although through the pandemic, there has been a distinctive rise of e-learning through digital platforms, the distance learning arrangements in universities didn’t cover the need of communicating laboratory skills to students. Science experiments, traditionally performed in biology labs, were cancelled. Our research is a start towards giving an answer to the critical question: Does a VR educational tool help students acquire basic experimental skills and content knowledge in Biology? For the scope of this research, we have collaborated with four different target groups, who took part in four empirical studies: one group of 4th year, undergraduate students of the Department of Primary Education of the University of Patras in Greece, two groups of 3rd year undergraduate, distance learning students, enrolled in a Biology laboratory course in a Natural Science module at the Hellenic Open University, and one group of 2nd year postgraduate students of the Department of Primary Education of the National and Kapodistrian University of Athens also in Greece. In each of these studies, the participants were equally separated into cognitively balanced groups to be educated on the microscopy experiment by different educational scenarios. In the context of these scenarios, students’ conceptual understanding in the domain of microscopy, as well as their ability to handle and operate successfully a real photonic microscope in the physical biology lab, were evaluated through specially designed assessment material that included written tests and worksheets. The educational material was developed based on the objective outcomes of the experimental course of microscopy and other parameters derived from the profile of the different target groups. The VR software playing a central role in this thesis, was Onlabs, a 3D educational application that simulates the environment of the physical biology lab of the Hellenic Open University. Onlabs was embedded, in all the educational scenarios applied in the current research. The results of this thesis provided evidence in favor of the use of a VR educational software, as a supplementary tool to the traditional learning methods in laboratory biology courses. Students who were trained on microscopy by following a scenario that involved the use of a VR educational application, obtained statistically significant higher scores in written tests, were more confident of the acquired knowledge and exhibited a greater ability in performing the microscopy experiment in the physical lab, compared to their fellow students who were only exposed to more traditional learning methods. In other words, when comparing VR instruction scenarios with traditional educational procedures, simulation environments provided students with benefits in terms of both conceptual understanding and practical skills. Basically, simulation helped students understand the principals of microscopy and prepared them in a more efficient way for their microscopy experiment. It seemed to connect theory and practice and help students, even the weaker ones with zero or minimum science background, to obtain higher scores and demonstrate a better experimental performance. According to this thesis, and having in mind that preparation is the most important factor for success in lab exercises, a VR educational software proved to be a technologically modern and promising tool that could serve the efforts of the institutions to improve the engagement of their students in the learning process of laboratory-based courses while, at the same time, saving time and money by exploiting cutting-edge technologies.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Hellenic Open University
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Paxinou, Evgenia
- Παξινού, Ευγενία
Subjects
dc:subject × 27- Εικονική πραγματικότητα
- Εργαστηριακά μαθήματα βιολογίας
- Εκπαιδευτικό λογισμικό εικονικής πραγματικότητας
- Onlabs
- Μικροσκόπηση
- Αξιολόγηση επίδοσης φοιτητών
- Εργαστηριακές δεξιότητες
- Μοντέλο Rasch
- Κλασική θεωρία των μετρήσεων
- Κριτική σκέψη ειδικού πεδίου
- Virtual reality
- Laboratory biology courses
- Virtual reality educational software
- Microscopy
- Assessment of the students' performance
- Rasch model
- Classical test theory
- Experimental skills
- Domain-specific critical thinking
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Βιολογία
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση
- Natural Sciences
- Biological Sciences
- Social Sciences
- Education
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/47960