National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Prünhild, Brunhild, Brünnhilde: fremdheit und androgynie im lichte der metamorphosen der figur brunhildes in literatur und kunst des 19. jahrhunderts
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe dissertation depicts the figure of the mythical queen of Iceland and the Valkyria Brunhild and presents her reception as well as her various metamorphoses in literature and art during the 19th century as metamorphoses of the Feminine in the patriarchy. The dissertation focuses on two specific concepts: the concept of strangeness - Brunhild is the foreign woman arriving from the High North in the royal court of Worms by the river Rhine, an element that provokes concurrently feelings between fascinosum and tremendum - and the concept of androgyny, as Brunhild is under the patriarchal point of view a heroine with male characteristics such as determination, energy and braveness, qualities that gave her the name “the most male woman”. The research examines the origins of Brunhild elaborating on the “Historia Frankorum” of Gregor von Tours and the “Fredegar-Chronik” and illustrates the fact if the Merovingian queen Brunichilide is the literary sister of Brunhild. This section is completed by two hardly known examples, a) of Giovanni Boccaccio “Über einige Armselige und über Brunichildis, Königin der Franken” and b) of Ferdinand Freiligrath “Anno Domini”. The study clears subsequently the strands between the legend of winning Brunhild - referring to the Icelandic powerful queen - and the legend of waking her up - referring to the Valkyria, the daughter of God Odin in the Icelandic “Edda” -, and answers to the dilemma of the writers which Brunhild is to be chosen in literature and why. The theoretical section concerning the concept of strangeness is based on the studies of the philosophers Georg Simmel and Bernhard Waldenfels, whereas the studies of Αchim Aurnhammer and Carl-Gustav-Jung support the theoretical section of androgyny accompanied by works of Simone de Beauvoir, Virginia Woolf and Judith Butler under the aspect of the Gender Studies. Starting point in all examined literary works is Brunhild’s homeland in the light of the local strangeness which determines the main axis in the texts as it combines the local with the pagan and the non-cultural strangeness. The study further elaborates, in the theoretical part, on the relativity of the bipolar relationship between familiarity and strangeness, on the constructed character οf the identity and the strangeness and on the specific dimensions and gradations of the concept of strangeness according to the theory of the philosopher Bernhard Waldenfels. By and large he differentiates between the daily, the structural and the radical strangeness, in parallel with the geographical, the political, the religious and the social strangeness. The study further elaborates the meaning of the cultural shock, regarding the coexistence of the feelings of attraction and fear that proceed from the confrontation with the strangeness, on the sense of not-belonging and the conversion of a current unknown civilization to a non-civilisation. The concept of the strangeness is completed with the cultural evaluation of the two genders. It has been proved in the study hat the culture is gender-based and that the man is the establisher of a culture based on patriarchal criteria. The inquiry if the culture of the familiarity leads to the non-culture of the strangeness has been answered by the cultural evaluation of the two genders, male = familiar, female = strange. The concept of the strangeness became more specific through the culture of the two worlds or accurately of the one world, the male one, while the entire theoretical axes are connected, associated and applied inconclusively in the figure of Brunhild. Τhe end of the known world with his monstra and his amazons is depicted according to the descriptions of the “Old Testament”, of the antiquity and the medieval perceptions of the North, as examples for the constructed imaginative geography of Georg Simmel. The dimensions of the strangeness starting with the local strangeness explain and emphasize the choice of the homeland of Brunhild in the High North, where the Satan and the northern darkness rule. Starting with the theory of Αchim Aurnhammer (1986), who intergrades structurally the ancient ritual of hospitality called “tessera hospitalis” to the androgynous model, the androgynous figure of Brunhild has been studied and analyzed methodologically by following the “symbontisches Curriculum”, namely “entirety – chiasma – reunification” both as an “internal and external pair”. The retrospection to the androgynous model based on the presentation of the basic personifications of androgynous from the “Genesis” up to the round people of Plato in his “Symposium”, Ovid’s Hermaphrodites in his “Metamorphoses” and the legend of the amazons as sources of inspiration in literature confirms that the androgynous model does not suggest the symmetry between male and female, while the analysis of the Neo-Platonism, the critical control of the concepts “Αnima-Animus” of Carl-Gustav-Jung and the combination of the androgynous model with the “Holy Matrimony” complete the domination of the patriarchy at the expense of the female gender. The idea of the androgynous fails. The “Holy Matrimony” personified in the “High Pair” meets the death in love by the self-scarification of the woman. The heroine causes irritation with her male side. She reflects, she has an opinion and she acts, while she stands over the specific space of the Feminine defined from the patriarchy. The androgynous concept by Brunhild is constructed for no other reason but for his de-construction. The study - based on nine works - analyses in its second part the figure of Brunhild as tremendum and faszinosum on the literaly stage between 1810 and 1874. The first three analyzed dramas, the “Nibelungen-Hort” (1828) of Ernst Raupach presenting a possessed Brunhild, the “Ring des Nibelungen” (1853-1872) of Richard Wagner showing Brunhild as alter ego and instrument of her powerful father Wodan and the trilogy “Nibelungen” (1860) of Friedrich Hebbel in her role as “the most male woman”, a woman like “burning fire and black ice” examine the figure of Brunhild referring to the entire myth of the Nibelungs. The tree following dramas, “Brunhild” (1857) of Emanuel Geibel, whose Brunhild personifies the strange wildness of the North, “Brunhild” (1863) of Robert Waldmüller in her role as a “royal snake” and the “Turandot of the North” and “Brynhilde” (1875) of Reinhold Sigismund inspired from the cold northern legends and the Icelandic “Edda-songs” are named after the literary figure of Brunhild and they personalize the myth of the Nibelungs focusing on the fate of Brunhild. The three last sections, chosen from different genres, the procession text of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe “Maskenzug der romantischen Poesie” (1810) with his naive Brunhild, Johann-Gottfried Kinkels poem “Brynhildis” (1850) where she incarnates the entire male phantasies and the novel “Brunhild” (1870) of Johannes Scherr as a mirror of the patriarchal rules, widen the various aspects of Brunhild in literature.The third part outlines Brunhild in art, examines the figure from 1805 to 1920 by defining the works of 16 painters and sculptors and completes the related topics and motives analyzed in the literature part. The pictures include - apart from the paintings - frescos, illustrations, sketches, statuettes, lithographies mural paintings and the huge bronze sculpture of the Valkyria in Copenhagen. Based on four German and one Swiss painter the study provides in the first section the metamorphoses of Brunhild under the influence of the “Song of the Nibelungs”, the German epos. Furthermore, the works of nine painters and illustrators, five Germans, two French, one Russian and one British artist depict in the second section the characteristics of Brunhild under the influence of Richard Wagner and his masterpiece “Ring of the Nibelung”. This part ends with two artists, a Belgian painter and a Norwegian sculptor, who create art by following no conventions. The metamorphoses of Brunhild in literature as well as in art contribute crucially to the substantial understanding of the polar relationships between the two genders during the “long” 19th century.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tsonaka, Konstantina
- Τσονάκα, Κωνσταντίνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 10Rights
- Language dc:language
- ger
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/48042