National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Αλγοριθμικές διαδικασίες ως κύρια μαθηματική γνώση: διδασκαλία και μάθησή τους στο δημοτικό σχολείο
Abstract
dc:descriptionAlgorithms are a main and essential part of procedural knowledge in Mathematics. Indeed, Mathematics, in a broad sense, is only algorithms. Algorithms, according to the modern conceptual definition, do not have the meaning of exclusively standardized procedures, such as performing arithmetic operations, but all sequences of well-defined, finite steps (commands or actions) that may be repeated, which define ways so as to complete successfully a particular process. An algorithm is a methodical set of steps that can be used to perform operations, solve problems and make decisions. An algorithm is not a specific calculation, but the method used when making the calculation. However, in Primary Education, the definition of algorithm is restricted, since only standardized procedures, in order to perform the four arithmetic operations, are considered as algorithms. The "mathematical" algorithm differs from the "computational-symbolic" algorithm, as the latter is determined by its computer applicability, where each step must be precisely defined so that it can be described by a programming language and then performed by a computer. Nowadays, it is believed that algorithms are the keys to deciphering the universe and revealing its hidden secrets, as the step-by-step dynamics of algorithms manage to manipulate the deluge of information of our era, enabling humankind to carry out unthinkable, supernatural and unreal mental exceedances. This fact may justify the current prestigious position of algorithms as a scientific tool, but it also highlights their importance as critical mathematical knowledge. The present PhD thesis is a study on the “mathematical” algorithm and it is divided into two parts, in accordance with the two phrases of its title. The first part is devoted to algorithmic procedures, as main mathematical knowledge, while the second one focuses on the teaching and learning of algorithms in Primary Education. The first part, aiming at the improvement of the teaching and learning of algorithms and having taken advantage of the important role of the history of Mathematics in improving its teaching and learning, examines many factors which have a decisive impact on the teaching practices adopted in schools. Its purpose is, through the rich scientific, didactic and historical material presented, the students (as well as the teachers) of the Primary School and the Compulsory Education, in general, to benefit in terms of cognition, learning and pedagogy, perceiving, at the same time, the importance and centrality of teaching algorithmic procedures. The low level of popularity of the Mathematics as a school subject, the conceptual delimitation, the characteristics and properties of the algorithm, the Euclidean algorithm, the numerous types of algorithms, elementary or non-elementary (with particular emphasis on those algorithms relating to prime numbers and factorization), as well as the first, historically, non-trivial algorithm consist the first chapters of this doctoral thesis. Extensive reference is also made to categorizing of P and NP decision problems. In addition, many parameters and algorithmic steps, which are related to problem solving as well as to problems that can be solved algorithmically, are taken into consideration. Algorithmic problem solving is a challenging educational process, as it can offer effective solutions to many similar mathematical and non-mathematical problems. Furthermore, a lot of the most common problems that have been faced and remained unresolved for centuries, which have been solved by a computer, using relevant algorithms, computer programs and exhaustive calculations, are presented and discussed in detail. Moreover, within a purely historical context, a 4,000-year-old path to date is recorded, and two ancient algorithms, which exploit errors and solve almost all the word problems, are examined. The Egyptian and Babylonian algorithm of simple false position requires a trial and solves problems that result in a first degree equation without a constant term, while the Chinese algorithm of double false position requires two trials and solves problems that result in a first degree equation with a constant term. Thereafter, many archaic additive, non-place-valued number systems are studied, as well as the current place-valued Hindu-Arabic number system which prevailed during the Renaissance, ending an idiotic controversy of more than 500 years in medieval times, between Abacists and Algorists. Up next, crucial historical snapshots of a 1,200-year-old period, are cited. The etymology of the terms «algorism» and «algorithm», as well as the path of the conception of the algorithm from the era of (its godfather) Al-Khwarizmi, until the 20th century, are the main branches of this rich course. In the second part of this thesis, many of the factors that shape the teaching, pedagogical and learning climate, concerning the teaching of algorithms in Primary Education, are initially examined, with the main focus being on the algorithms of the four basic arithmetic operations. Subsequently, it is researched, through qualitative content analysis, the pedagogical and scientific quality and contribution of all six current Primary Education mathematics textbooks on the presentation and teaching of algorithms. In general, it has been found that the series of the six Primary Education mathematics textbooks meet several pedagogical and didactic specifications and do not abstain from modern scientific perceptions as far as the presentation and study of algorithms is concerned, with the exception of the almost zero reference to the word as a mathematical term. Lastly, in the final chapters of this PhD thesis, the main body of the research is presented. The main purpose of the quantitative research, which was conducted through a questionnaire, with 614 Primary Education teachers as subjects, was to examine teachers' views on the quality of current mathematics textbooks in Primary Education as well as the role, value and learning contribution of algorithmic procedures (of all types) and the way they are taught and learned in Primary Education. Some critical educational aspects, such as teachers’ training and views on how their students perceive Mathematics as a Primary Education subject, have also been some parts of this research. By reading and interpreting the results of the survey it has been found that the teachers’ beliefs were almost in line with the prevailing pedagogical and teaching theories. The only differences in the beliefs of the sample of teachers focus on the lack of awareness of the necessary multimodality that should rule the teaching and learning of algorithms (especially the value of using calculators, as an important cognitive and mediating tool in Mathematics, is too undervalued). In addition, the decline in teaching of standard, traditional written algorithms, for the benefit of cultivating and developing invented alternative strategies, does not seem to be a teaching priority for teachers yet. Overall, there was also an unequivocal rejection of the current Primary Education mathematics textbooks in terms of their contribution to the teaching and learning of all ways of performing arithmetic algorithms. Finally, the majority of the sample of the teachers’ beliefs admits that Primary School teachers have didactic and cognitive shortcomings regarding the subject of Mathematics in upper grade classes. Furthermore, teachers consider that the in-service training provided to them, concerning the use of current mathematics textbooks, was ineffective.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Mastrogiannis, Alexios
- Μαστρογιάννης, Αλέξιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Αλγόριθμος
- Μαθηματικά
- Δημοτικό σχολείο
- Επίλυση προβλήματος
- Αλ-Χουαρίζμι
- Algorithm
- Mathematics
- Primary school
- Problem solving
- Al-Khwarizmi
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Επιστήμη Ηλεκτρονικών Υπολογιστών και Πληροφορική
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση
- Natural Sciences
- Computer and Information Sciences
- Social Sciences
- Education
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/48056