Back to search

Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)

Ανάπτυξη μεθοδολογίας για την αξιολόγηση δικτύων δημοσίων συγκοινωνιών ανταποκρινόμενων στη ζήτηση σε περιαστικές περιοχές

Abstract

dc:description

Public Transport Systems on demand (referred as Demand Responsive Transport Systems - DRT) are a technologically innovative form of flexible transport services and constitute quite popular services in many European countries as well as in the USA, Canada, Australia and New Zealand. These transport services are flexible in terms of routes, vehicles, payment methods and booking, passenger categories and areas they serve, as well as in terms of design and implementation. With respect to its flexibility, a DRT service is positioned between the service provided by taxis and that of buses which run on predetermined routes. The growing interest in these systems during the recent years makes the evaluation of DRT systems necessary, while there is a requirement for ever more efficient and more sustainable transport, due to both the steady increase in demand for such services and, secondly, the restrictions posed by the current economic conditions. It is becoming increasingly evident that the traditional Public Transport Networks is not sufficient to cover the full range of the population, and the spatial extent of modern urban areas. As a result, vulnerable groups (elderly, people with disabilities (PwD), unemployed, etc.), but also regions in the periphery of urban areas (suburban complexes, villages, settlements) cannot successfully satisfy their needs to have access to goods, services, and opportunities as opposed to the residents of large urban agglomerations. DRT systems constitute a possible solution and is currently being proposed and tested due to the advancement of relevant technologies, such as smartphones, web applications for user information, etc., required for their implementation. In their first form, flexible transport systems implemented in the 1970s, with mixed results, at times positive but also frequently without much success considering the initial objectives set. Although the emergence of new information technologies has solved many of the operational problems and has made (DRT) one of the most relevant and innovative forms of Public Transport, yet many of the reasons why these systems are not successfully implemented in practice have not yet been well understood. This Τhesis aims at helping to understand those reasons, ie. the conditions which lead to a DRT system being successful (or not) and how this can be modelled and evaluated during the design phase of such a service. To this end, the current Thesis begins with a brief description of the general characteristics of DRT systems organization and their position in the "market" of public transport services as well as a breakdown of the main studies and research dealing with the theoretical aspects as well as the practical application and implementation of DRT systems. This examination is followed by a critical review and synthesis of the literature on the design and organization of DRT on a methodological level, having as a starting point the design methodologies for the conventional fixed route transport systems. The review concludes with the identification of research gaps concerning DRT and specifically the lack of an integrated methodological framework for DRT systems evaluation which would offer a comprehensive guide in terms of their design. In the next stage, the methodological approach adopted to address this issue is described; by firstly proposing a new categorization of DRT network problems using a different rationale which links the research questions with the business models of the systems and the corresponding "markets" which are served. This categorization of research problems for DRT systems is necessary as a first step in order to reveal the methodological requirements concerning the modelling and evaluation of DRT systems with respect to the specific transport network and geographical characteristics of DRT and conventional bus services. At this point (Chapter 3) the main research question of the Thesis is identified and outlined which concerns the development of models to assess and compare a DRT system for interurban areas of low demand with a "conventional" fixed bus line. Chapter 4 describes how to design, evaluate and optimize a public transportation system using analytical models for identifying the optimal operational characteristics with respect to (predefined) passenger demand levels (supply side). For each transport mode examined (bus, DRT), the corresponding total cost function of the service is defined, and these functions are compared to determine the most efficient mode, with respect to alternative scenarios and passenger demand levels. Apart from the study of the supply side, the current Thesis also examines the demand side through the development of transport mode choice models (Ch. 5). Specifically, binary logit models are used to calculate the modal split between the alternative modes (private car - bus - DRT) available to the users. Furthermore, the data collection method is described which employed questionnaires and revealed and stated preferences (RP / SP survey) methods to understand and model the potential demand shift to the new mode of transport (in our case the DRT). The ultimate goal of the demand analysis is to calculate the percentage of passengers that will change their mode choice, ie the percentage of private car users who will choose DRT as well as the percentage of bus users who prefer to choose DRT, in case this is introduced by replacing the existing conventional bus line. Combining supply with demand, the next chapter (Ch. 6) of the Thesis proposes a computational framework formulating the DRT evaluation problem as a bi-level programming optimization problem. Specifically the mathematical problem is approached using non-cooperative game theory (NCGT) and specifically defined as a Stackelberg (non-cooperative) game. Stackelberg game theory problems can be represented and solved as bi-level programming problems. The specific formulation and solution of the mathematical problem defined, addresses the central research question of the Thesis, and the corresponding analytical and statistical models as well as the solution algorithms developed are thoroughly discussed. The Thesis concludes with the application of the evaluation framework in an interurban areas of Thessaloniki: the area of Lagadas (Chapter 7). The aim of this chapter is twofold: on the one hand to apply the evaluative framework and validate the results (using parameter values which are currently used in practice by the Thessaloniki Urban Transport Organization (O.A.S.TH.)), and furthermore to support the decision-making process at a policy level in the case of a potential substitution of the existing bus service by DRT to improve network efficiency. For the implementation of the methodology, there was a need for both aggregated transport data as well as microscopic travel demand data, which were provided by the Transport Authority of Thessaloniki S.A. (aggregated demand data) as well as by a questionnaire survey conducted as part of the undergraduate Diploma Thesis of Mr. Mihalis Mpelimpasakis, Mr. Ioannis Provatenos and Mr. Charitos Kouderis, with the guidance of the PhD candidate. The responsibility of the candidate was to organize and define the revealed and stated preference experiments for the region of Lagkadas, following the methodology of the Thesis as described in chapters 4-6. In conclusion, this Thesis offers an innovative way of modeling and evaluating conventional Public Transport (bus) networks and compare them to Demand Responsive Transport (DRT) ones. The work combined analytical methods and operational research, statistics and game theory to create an integrated evaluation methodology for DRT networks for interurban areas, which can provide new research directions at both strategic level planning and practical application of the findings. The Thesis ends with the overall conclusions, which include the detailed analysis of its added value and the potential future research directions and extensions of the models developed.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Year dc:date
2020

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Papanikolaou, Anestis
  • Παπανικολάου, Ανέστης

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/48068

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Papanikolaou, Anestis; Παπανικολάου, Ανέστης. Ανάπτυξη μεθοδολογίας για την αξιολόγηση δικτύων δημοσίων συγκοινωνιών ανταποκρινόμενων στη ζήτηση σε περιαστικές περιοχές. Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH), 2020. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/48068