University of Thessaly (UTH)
Επικοινωνιακά χαρακτηριστικά στην εκπαίδευση: αλληλεπιδράσεις λεκτικής επιθετικότητας, επιχειρηματολογίας και κλίματος παρακίνησης
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of the present doctoral dissertation was the qualitative and quantitative exploration of: a) verbal aggressiveness, b) argumentativeness and c) motivational climate, as manifested by P. E. teachers and perceived by their students, along with d) factors that affect the variables above (such as age, sex, as well as educational, social and hierarchical-structural features). To this aim, and in an effort to sketch the profiles of P. E. teachers in relation to the aforementioned communicative traits, to examine the convergence or divergence between the teachers’ and students’ views, to establish the causes of verbal aggressiveness, argumentativeness and motivational climate, and to identify the hierarchical structures of teachers, three independent but interrelated studies were adopted in the present research design. More specifically, the first study focused on determining how the three concepts above are perceived by P. E. teachers and students, in order to consolidate the interpretation of quantitative data that followed. The second study identified factors of the three independent variables as self-perceived notions (psychometric approach). The third study was quantitative network analysis, which approached the three variables as other-determined notions (structural approach) and catered to a comparison between psychometric and structural data. In addition, the first study followed a mixed method. Within the qualitative approach, 15 P. E. teachers (9 men and 6 women) participated and the data were collected through semi-structured individual interviews. Within the quantitative approach, 903 students (448 boys and 455 girls) filled in standard questionnaires. The most significant results showed that verbal aggressiveness and argumentativeness are co-existing features. Distinct communicative teacher profiles were identified, which related to the extent of using aggressiveness and argumentativeness, as well as to the quality of motivational climate, indicating that when argumentation is avoided, verbal aggressiveness increases and assumes a disciplinary role. As to the causes of verbal aggressiveness of teachers, anger, the need to impose their will on their students, a poor psychological condition, emotional vulnerability (due to the financial crisis) and lack of patience were identified. This stage of the research showed that the teachers’ profiles (drawn from the interviews) in relation to verbal aggressiveness, argumentativeness and motivational climate converge to a great extent with the respective views of students. In the second study, a multi-factor quantitative analysis was carried out, drawing on the standard questionnaires completed by the sample of 903 students during the first study. The analyses indicated that: a) the verbal aggressiveness of P. E. teachers positively relates to a performance motivational climate and negatively with argumentativeness and a mastery motivational climate, whereas argumentativeness positively relates to a mastery motivational climate, b) senior high school students view P. E. teachers as more argumentative, while junior high school students as verbally aggressive and c) primary school students, more than students in other levels, view the motivational climate present in the lesson of P. E. as mostly performance rather than mastery oriented. Further analyses showed that P. E. teachers in urban centers demonstrate higher levels of verbal aggressiveness and performance-oriented motivational climates, in relation to their colleagues working in rural areas. In the third study, an analysis of social networks was carried out within 8 students’ networks (including the P. E. teachers) in order to identify hierarchical structures and factors that shape them. The sample consisted of 165 nodes (80 students, 77 students and 5 male, 3 female P. E. teachers), who came from the 903 student sample used in the first study. Standard questionnaires were used with network and non-network variables. The most significant results of this stage can be summarized as follows: a) verbal aggressiveness among primary school students in rural areas is lower, while in high school students in urban centers are targeted and in upper classes they become both perpetrators as well as victims of verbal aggressiveness, b) in primary school and in senior high school using the Internet for educational purposes protects from verbal aggressiveness. Moreover, primary and junior high school students’ interest in lessons and their future helps and protects from verbal aggressiveness and also relates to argumentativeness, c) in senior high school the existence of organizational culture is more evident, but students with vocational ambitions are more aggressive, d) interest in academic subjects partially hinders the development of aggressive behaviors, while sports relate to verbal aggressiveness, e) the older students grow, the more they resort to argumentation and f) senior high school students consider those of their classmates who are interested in team sports to be more argumentative, whereas argumentativeness correlates with the parents’ educational level and high school performance. The sum of the results constitutes fertile ground for thinking, properly evaluating and shaping teachers’ self-awareness in relation to the communicative educational framework, providing knowledge and information concerning the way in which this framework is understood among P. E. teachers and students. More specifically, feedback is of paramount importance through identifying behaviors and causes that urge teachers to use non-constructive forms of communication. In addition, the present study aids in identifying and further exploiting determining factors towards curbing verbal aggressiveness or enhancing argumentativeness and motivational climate through the exploration of students-teachers relationships. The educational community will be assisted towards adopting those forms of communication that influence the development of a positive climate between teachers and students, which, in turn, will promote a harmonious, constructive learning environment, appropriate role models and effective teaching as a result.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Deliligka, Stergiani
- Δεληλίγκα, Στεργιανή
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Λεκτική επιθετικότητα
- Επιχειρηματολογία
- Κλίμα παρακίνησης
- Ποιοτική ανάλυση
- Ποσοτική ανάλυση
- Ανάλυση κοινωνικών δικτύων
- Verbal aggressiveness
- Argumentativeness
- Motivational climate
- Qualitative analysis
- Quantitative analysis
- Social network analysis
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση
- Social Sciences
- Education
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- BY_NC_ND
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/48158