Back to search

Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)

Ο «λευκός» χώρος και οι οπτικές μεταφορές στη σύγχρονη, έντυπη διαφήμιση: διερεύνηση της αποτελεσματικότητας τους ως προς τη δημιουργία ασιθητικής απόκρισης και απόλαυσης και τη στάση απέναντι στη διαφήμιση και τη μάρκα

Abstract

dc:description

Visual metaphorical language has prevailed in print advertising over the last few years. Consumers are bombarded with numerous advertising messages, thus advertisers seek to attract attention, gain interest and generate favorable attitudes with creative, aesthetic and incongruent metaphoric advertisements. At the same time, consumers are accustomed to highly aesthetic and sophisticated advertisements that are open to multiple interpretations. Such type of advertising tries to express a particular sense of aesthetics and subject consumers to deeper elaboration with the message. Metaphoric advertisements neither explicitly promote the product nor tell consumers what to think or how to interpret the stimulus. On the contrary, they allow consumers to reach their own conclusions on their own pace. Abstract or minimal design, mainly expressed via extended “white” space, and visual metaphors constitute two fundamental design tools in print advertising that are characterized by their high aesthetics and their rhetorical aura that seek to aesthetically intrigue consumers and lead them to positive attitudes. Minimal design is expressed through simplicity and modesty, while visual metaphors through ornamentation and exaggeration, which together can cause a balanced and harmonized advertising stimulus. Minimalism constitutes a design movement that defends the construction of rhetorical, artful and functional stimuli with a minimum level of means and materials. The interdisciplinary nature of minimalism allows it to appear and affect a wide range of scientific and non-scientific fields and aspects of everyday life, such as architecture, arts, marketing and fashion. Extended “white” space, or otherwise called, blank space is the dominant characteristic of minimal design that is tracked in each of the above mentioned fields. Limited means and materials, lack of colorfulness, and simple geometry are some other characteristics of minimal design. Such design characteristics are more prominent in the literature in the architecture and arts field and less prominent in the marketing field (i.e., studies that focus on product, website, logo and packaging design). Nevertheless, in the advertising field there lie some, fragmented references on the appearance, aspects and impact of minimal design. Visual metaphors represent another design tool of contemporary, print advertisement that is defined by its artistic and rhetorical nature. Visual metaphors in advertising are able to communicate the brands’ messages in a sophisticated manner, in order to please consumers through the process of solving the advertising riddle. A wide range of studies in the past has concentrated on different types of visual metaphors and how each of them can affect comprehension, appreciation, attitudes towards the ad and the brand, recall and recognition, depending on the level of their complexity, depth of meaning and incongruity. The aim of the current thesis is threefold. First, it develops a definition of minimal print advertisement by applying a quantitative content analysis on four hundred print advertisements. In other words, it establishes a typology of minimal print ad characteristics of. Sample ads were selected on the basis of incorporating at least an extended and/or monochrome “white” space, which as previously mentioned, serves as the focal characteristic of minimal design. The results of the analysis demonstrate that minimal print advertisement consists of an extended (more than 1⁄2 of the total ad layout), monochrome and in shades of gray “white” space. Furthermore, it is unveiled that images in minimal advertising are restricted in number (mostly one to two) and extent (less than 1⁄2 of the total ad layout), are of simple geometry, but colorfulful and not only in grayscale. Text is restricted in terms of the number of words (mostly fifteen) and its overall extent (less than 1⁄2 of the total ad layout), the size of the font is mostly “12”, it is mainly monochrome and in shades of gray. The second aim of the thesis is to investigate to what extent visual metaphors are used in international and Greek print advertising, to find which is the most commonly used type of visual metaphor and to what extent visual metaphors are combined with “white” space. Also, it seeks to explore the design characteristics of “white” space included in metaphoric ads. A second quantitative content analysis demonstrates that the vast majority of the research population consists of at least a metaphoric image. Furthermore, building on the typology of visual metaphors by Phillips and McQuarrie (2004), it is evident that fusion is the most common type in international sample, whereas no statistically significant differences were found in the Greek sample between fusions and replacements. Moreover, the majority of both the international and Greek sample that included a metaphoric image incorporated also an extended and/ or monochrome, mainly in grayscale colors, “white” space. Only a few studies have to date focused on the effect of minimal design on consumers and those who did it, mainly concentrated on the effect of “white” space on consumers’ responses. Academic literature pays attention to “white” space and perceives it as a rhetorical tool of contemporary print advertising that can deliver its own messages for the brand. Furthermore, it is underlined that “white” space is a smart but modest design tool that communicates high aesthetics and high quality, trustworthiness and status for the brand. On the contrary, a number of studies in advertising have proved that different types of visual metaphors lead to elaboration, attention, different interpretations, appreciation and attitudes, depending on the level of their creativity, complexity, incongruity, artful divergence and divergence from reality. However, despite the academic interest on “white” space and visual metaphors, no previous study has ever examined the impact of their synergy on consumer behavior. As a consequence, the third aim of the thesis is to investigate the interaction effect of “white” space and visual metaphors on consumers’ attitudes. First, an online, experimental study on seven hundred fifty six Greek participants, for an unknown coffee brand, tests the impact of “white” space, visual metaphors and their synergy on attitude towards the ad and the brand. The manipulation of the visual metaphors was based on Gkiouzepas and Hogg’s (2011) study that pays attention to the divergence of visual metaphor. The manipulation of “white” space was built on the typology of minimal print advertisement constructed by the first content analysis and particularly on the criterion of at least an extended and/or monochrome “white” space. The results of the study demonstrated that the combination of visual metaphors and “white” space lead to the most positive attitudes towards the ad and the brand. Also, it is unveiled that visual metaphors lead to positive attitudes towards the ad and the brand, whereas no statistically significant differences were found between the presence and the absence of “white” space on ad and brand attitude. A second online experiment on four hundred three Greek students tried to shed light on the reasons why visual metaphors and visual metaphors with “white” space lead to more favorable attitudes towards the ad and the brand. The manipulation of visual metaphor was again based on Gkiouzepas and Hogg (2011) study, while the manipulation of “white” space was based on the study of Pracejus, O’Guinn and Olsen (2013). Building on the theory of aesthetic preference of Berlyne (1971), it is proved that ads with visual metaphors (vs. ads with literal images) and ads with visual metaphors and extended “white” space (vs. ads with visual metaphors and restricted “white” space) lead to more positive attitude towards the ad and the brand, via increased aesthetic responses and enhanced pleasure. Moreover, it is confirmed that ads with visual metaphors (vs. ads with literal images) and ads with visual metaphors and extended “white” space (vs. ads with visual metaphors and restricted “white” space) exert increased aesthetic responses. Additionally, aesthetic response is positively correlated with pleasure and pleasure is positively correlated with attitude toward the ad and the brand. A third online experiment examines whether the results of the second experiment can be generalized or they are context and product specific. The third experiment was conducted on two hundred and nine Greek participants, applied on a different product (toast bread) and manipulated visual metaphor and “white” space similarly to the second experiment. The results confirm that ads with visual metaphors (vs. ads with literal images) and ads with visual metaphors and extended “white” space (vs. ads with visual metaphors and restricted “white” space) lead to more positive attitude towards the ad and the brand, through enhanced aesthetic responses and pleasure. Additionally, ads with visual metaphors (vs. ads with literal images) and ads with visual metaphors and extended “white” space (vs. ads with visual metaphors and restricted “white” space) generate increased aesthetic responses. Furthermore, aesthetic response is positively correlated with pleasure and pleasure is positively correlated with attitude toward the ad and the brand. As such, the results of the third experiment confirm the results of the second one, enhancing the validity of the study. On a final note, the current thesis provides evidence for the effectiveness of an exceptionally novel and creative combination of two design styles in contemporary print advertising, these of “white” space and visual metaphors. As it is highlighted in the study, minimalism, especially expressed via “white” space, is extensively combined with visual metaphors that are mainly in the category of fusion. Metaphoric images and metaphoric images combined with “white” space are highly popular in print advertising and lead to positive attitude towards the ad and the brand via aesthetic response and pleasure. The outcomes of the study provide fruitful readings to both academics and practitioners.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Year dc:date
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Margariti, Kostoula
  • Μαργαρίτη, Κωστούλα

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/48722

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Margariti, Kostoula; Μαργαρίτη, Κωστούλα. Ο «λευκός» χώρος και οι οπτικές μεταφορές στη σύγχρονη, έντυπη διαφήμιση: διερεύνηση της αποτελεσματικότητας τους ως προς τη δημιουργία ασιθητικής απόκρισης και απόλαυσης και τη στάση απέναντι στη διαφήμιση και τη μάρκα. Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH), 2021. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/48722