Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Αποτίμηση του οφέλους μιας εθνικής πολιτικής προστασίας των πλανητών μεταξύ Γης και Άρη, υπό το πρίσμα των αναδυόμενων ιδιωτικών πρωτοβουλιών για το διάστημα

Abstract

dc:description

The emergence of private space initiatives has begun to expand the boundaries of the space industry, because of technological innovations that will soon be able to facilitate the development of novel sectors that have been neglected in the past, such as scientific research in space, space exploration, space resources utilization, and human access to space. Private initiatives are now considered a key enabling factor in expanding the human presence from the Low Earth Orbit to the Moon and Mars. The activities of private companies on the Moon have already commenced and they will be implemented in the near future, while Mars seems to be the desired long-term goal for some of them, especially for those who are interested in expanding the human presence on its orbit and on its surface. These private initiatives in the aforementioned novel sectors of the space industry are expected to bring to light important policy gaps, especially in the case of missions to Mars, in the exploration of which significant public investments have been made these past decades. Mars is a planet in our solar system that has held scientific interest for decades due to its potential for life. However, despite the number of relevant exploration missions and the important findings that have come from them so far, its exploration, particularly the exploration of specific regions in which terrestrial organisms could survive and reproduce and which have a high probability of hosting extant Martian life-forms, requires the strict compliance with certain technical requirements for "Planetary Protection". The term "Planetary Protection" refers to all the measures, policies, practices, and techniques aimed at preventing the contamination of celestial bodies with biological material from Earth and the contamination of the terrestrial biosphere with potential extraterrestrial biological material. The contamination of celestial bodies with biological material from Earth is called "forward contamination", while the contamination of the Earth's biosphere with potential extraterrestrial biological material is called "backward contamination". The body of internationally accepted guidelines for upholding Planetary Protection is reflected in detail in the relevant "Planetary Protection Policy" maintained by the scientific organization COSPAR (Committee On Space Research) of the International Council for Science, the power of which is essentially drawn from international law, namely from the 1967 United Nations Outer Space Treaty. According to this Treaty, its Member States have a national responsibility to comply with its provisions and to establish appropriate procedures for the approval and the constant supervision of the activities of even their non-state actors. The case of missions to Mars, in particular, has received special attention in COSPAR's Planetary Protection Policy, as the scientific interest in its astrobiological exploration is significant. Spacecrafts destined for Mars are strictly treated by this Policy, which is why they fall into special treatment subcategories. However, the missions that pose the greatest challenge to the overall Planetary Protection of Mars are those that involve human crews. At the moment, a comprehensive protocol for manned missions to Mars has not yet been developed to cover all Planetary Protection issues, while the highest Planetary Protection priority is given to the protection of the Earth from potential backward contamination. In the case of private endeavors in space research, in space exploration, in space resources utilization, and in human access to space, there seems to be a convergence of significant knowledge gaps which are related to the inability of enforcing international law without its integration into national law, as well as to the need for the development and implementation of Planetary Protection measures for missions with human crews and for the prevention of backward contamination, which creates great uncertainty at the policy level. In an attempt to address this policy uncertainty, this doctoral dissertation has introduced for the first time in the international literature an Environmental Economics approach to the problems of Planetary Protection, especially between Earth and Mars, which may arise in the future due to the activities of private companies in novel sectors of the space industry. In particular, the proposed approach was based on theoretical framings of the issues of forward contamination and backward contamination as problems of Environmental Economics, but also on best practices for the proper implementation of an original empirical research using the Contingent Valuation Method (CVM). This empirical application focused on the ex-ante valuation of the external benefit -i.e. the Total Economic Value- of a national policy aiming to prevent forward and backward contamination between Earth and Mars that could be caused by future private missions, in the case of Greece. In other words, this empirical research attempted to estimate the value of a hypothetical policy aimed at preventing a decrease in the quality of the good of the "interplanetary biological isolation between Earth and Mars". The results of this empirical research show that only 14.29% of the respondents assign a true zero value to the adoption of such a national policy. 48.26% of the respondents are willing to pay for the adoption of this policy, while 37.45% of them oppose this policy due to protest behavior. Using three statistical approaches, the mean willingness to pay amount for the implementation of such a policy was estimated based on the data at €14.77, €18.21, and €23.84, while the median was estimated at €0 in all three cases. Respectively, the annual Total Economic Value for the general population of interest was estimated at €131,839,398, €162,545,392, and €212,799,678, while the Present Value discounted for a decade was estimated for each case at €1,068,930,329, €1,317,889,051, and €1,725,341,844. In addition, the descriptive statistics and the correlation tests of the survey questions revealed the following. The attitude of the majority of the respondents towards the activities of private companies in novel sectors of the space industry is positive, both in general and in the particular case of private facilities in Greece, for missions both from Earth to Mars and from Mars to the Earth. This finding indicates that there is no perceived significant differentiation of these facilities by the respondents based on, for example, their level of hazard. An important factor in the positive attitude of the respondents towards these private activities is their trust in private companies for the upholding of Planetary Protection. In the case of private facilities in Greece for return missions from Mars to Earth, in particular, respondents’ acceptance of the adequacy of scientists’ knowledge internationally about backward contamination plays an important role. This positive attitude of the respondents towards private activities, provided that Planetary Protection will be upheld and on the condition of the adequacy of scientific knowledge for the protection of the Earth, stems from rational motives: the respondents perceive the existence of potential benefits that can arise from both the protection of Mars and the protection of the Earth. In fact, a significant percentage of them are willing to pay for the adoption of additional measures that will ensure the operation of private companies in a way that will be aligned with Planetary Protection. Both the aforementioned theoretical approach and the empirical application were attempted here for the first time in the published literature. The results of this study and the relevant questionnaire that was built specifically for the needs of this research are expected to be critically useful at the international level and to support the decision-making processes for the development of new Planetary Protection policies through the reproduction of this application in the cases of other states as well.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2020

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Profitiliotis, Georgios
  • Προφητηλιώτης, Γεώργιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 28

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • BY_NC_ND
Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/48978

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Profitiliotis, Georgios; Προφητηλιώτης, Γεώργιος. Αποτίμηση του οφέλους μιας εθνικής πολιτικής προστασίας των πλανητών μεταξύ Γης και Άρη, υπό το πρίσμα των αναδυόμενων ιδιωτικών πρωτοβουλιών για το διάστημα. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2020. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/48978