Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Το καθεστώς της ακίνητης περιουσίας των Μονών του Αγίου Όρους: ιστορική διαμόρφωση - σύγχρονο θεσμικό πλαίσιο
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn the present thesis is studied and examined the gradual formation of the real property rights of the Monasteries of Mount Athos through their historical development as well as their current legal status. Consequently, an attempt is made to collect and present opinions and scientific positions on particularly difficult legal problems that concern the courts, of all levels of jurisdiction, as well as the academic theory regarding the issue of real property belonging to monasteries. The main goal of the present thesis is the detailed record of the content and the extent of the real property rights of the Mount Athos monasteries, taking into consideration the extensive case-law, older and more recent, in Greek and in European level as well. The legal validity of the so-called «historical» titles of ownership which the Monasteries invoke in order to substantiate their property rights, constitutes a prominent matter of controversy in both theory and case-law within the contemporary legal order. Especially when similar claims are made by the State (the usual opposing party of the Holy Monasteries) appearing as a successor state of the Ottoman Empire. These are documents with property rights references, such as, indicatively, the Byzantine “chrysobullons” and “sigillions”, etc. or the “Ottoman firmans”, “tapus”, “huccets”, etc., whose legal validity strongly concerns the courts of all levels of jurisdiction in a great extent, even in cases that provoked the public opinion and from time to time triggered political developments. Within this frame, the research axis of this thesis and in order to enhance its originality, the present thesis aims to highlight this subject from, the constitutional, legislative and case-law perspective, the extensive study of the legal status of Mount Athos real estate property (area, origin, historical title deeds) in combination with the various and frequent complex legal issues that arise during the claim, recognition, registration and utilization of that property. And all this, with the new data formed by the inclusion of all kinds of rights of real property ownership within the status of the National Land Registry which settle those issues that were pending for centuries. Therefore, an attempt was made to critically examine the relevant Greek and European case-law, which raise plentiful and very interesting issues, not only theoretical, but also highly practical. A careful analysis is also attempted in the case-law regarding the glebes belonging to monasteries (metohi) of Mount Athos, as this issue has repeatedly concerns the relations between the Greek State and Mount Athos Monasteries, being an almost constant and permanent source of tension and of legal disputes. Within this frame, a special and detailed analysis is made to the institution of the constitutional non-expropriation of the real estate property of the monasteries incorporating an extensive record of case-law, in combination with the way this relevant legislation can be legally bent, taking into consideration the binding terms regarding the transfer of ownership rights of the glebes belonging to monasteries (metohi), as these terms are now set by the current legislation. At the same time, an extremely interesting and very practical issue that is being examined is the property titles of ownership due to the hereditary succession of the monks of Mount Athos, the distinction between “cenobitic” monks and “idiorrythmic” monks and the subsequent different legal consequences in respect of that distinction and the not so rare judicial disputes with relative heirs of the monks.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Apostolidis, Christos
- Αποστολίδης, Χρήστος
Subjects
dc:subject × 13Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/49004