Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Ολοκληρωμένη αξιοποίηση των αλατούχων υγρών αποβλήτων από μονάδες αφαλάτωσης

Abstract

dc:description

Water is undoubtedly the source of life on our planet and the driving force of human progress. As both the world’s population and the pollution of existing natural water resources increase, the phenomenon of water scarcity has increased significantly in recent years. Desalination is seen as a feasible solution to this global problem. Although desalination produces freshwater, a critical environmental issue is the brine produced by desalination. Brine is usually disposed of in the environment by various disposal methods (surface water discharge, discharge into a sewerage network, deep-well injection, evaporation ponds, and land application). In addition to its high salinity, brine may contain hazardous pre-treatment chemicals, organic compounds, microbial load and heavy metals.Brine disposal methods have recently been considered unsustainable due to negative environmental impacts, stricter environmental regulations, and increased efforts to recover useful materials (e.g., freshwater, salts) from brine. The alternative approaches to brine management that are now being considered are not based on the disposal but on the minimization/elimination of waste (to achieve maximum freshwater production and minimum/zero solid waste production).The aim of the present doctoral dissertation is the analysis and evaluation of desalination technologies (thermal-based and membrane-based) that can be used for the integrated treatment and utilization of desalination brine, as well as the techno-economic analysis and evaluation of systems based both on the principle of zero liquid discharge (ZLD) and on the principle of minimal liquid discharge (MLD) to recover useful materials. Under the ZLD framework, about 100% of freshwater is recovered and a solid salt is produced that can be utilized or disposed of in a more environmentally friendly way. On the other hand, under the MLD framework, the freshwater recovery target is slightly lower (up to 95%), while at the same time, only membrane-based desalination technologies are used.Initially, desalination technologies (thermal-based and membrane-based) were analyzed and evaluated in terms of their ability to treat brine effectively. In particular, technologies were analyzed and evaluated in terms of maximum freshwater recovery, advantages, disadvantages, technological maturity, energy consumption and costs.The MLD and ZLD strategies for the treatment and utilization of brine were then analyzed and evaluated using nine (9) criteria for the first time in the international scientific literature. The criteria used covered various aspects (performance, economy, environment and society) and are (1) stages, (2) technologies, (3) freshwater recovery, (4) salinity of feed brine, (5) energy consumption of each technology, (6) greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs), (7) cost, (8) recovery of useful materials and (9) social acceptance. Subsequently, in order to better assess the energy consumption of desalination technologies, the minimum energy consumption (MEC) in the treatment of brine was studied. A mathematical model was introduced and various parameters were analyzed, such as the rate of recovery, the salinity and temperature of the feed brine, the purity of the freshwater produced. A techno-economic analysis and evaluation of ZLD systems for the treatment and utilization of desalination brine in the Eastern Mediterranean was presented. Initially, two systems with a capacity of 100 m3/day were examined: (i) a ZLD system producing both freshwater and a mixed solid salt from brackish water brine (system 1) (ii) a ZLD system producing both freshwater and a mixed solid salt from seawater brine (system 2). The results showed that the energy consumption in system 1 (9,48 kWh/m3) is 2,38 times lower than in system 2 (22,55 kWh/m3) due to the 7 times lower salinity of the feed. Differentiation in energy requirements also translates into cost, since system 2 (€0,85/m3) is 1,24 times more expensive than system 1 (€0,69€/m3). Whether only freshwater is sold or both freshwater and mixed solid salt are sold, both systems are profitable as the profit ranges from €176,34/day to €195,72/day. In both systems, the cost is at least 3,18 times lower than the cost of evaporation ponds, while it is at the same level as the cost of land application and deep-well injection. Subsequently, a techno-economic analysis and evaluation of a third ZLD system (system 3) was carried out, which, unlike system 2 that produced freshwater and a mixed solid salt from seawater brine, system 3 produces freshwater, a mixed solid salt and a high-purity NaCl salt from seawater brine. The results showed that both the energy consumption (31,81 kWh/m3) and the freshwater cost (€1,12/m3) of system 3 are higher than those of system 2. Whether only freshwater is sold or both freshwater and salts are sold, both systems are profitable. In particular, when freshwater and salts are sold, system 3 (€293,40/day) is 1,52 times more profitable than system 2 (€191,96/day), as NaCl production significantly increases revenues. In both systems, the cost is at least 2,39 times lower than the cost of evaporation ponds, while it is at the same level as the cost of land application and deep-well injection.Subsequently, for the first time in the international scientific literature, a techno-economic analysis and evaluation of five MLD systems for the treatment of seawater brine was carried out. The results showed that recovery ranges from 78% to 89% and is considered sufficient, as freshwater recovery is up to 95% in MLD systems. The results showed that the cost of MLD systems ranges from €0,65€/m3 to €1,12€/m3, while the profit of the systems ranges from €112,43/day to €157,07/day. The cost of evaporation ponds is at least 2,4 times higher than the cost of treatment of any of the five MLD systems. As for the cheapest MLD system (system 2), its cost (€0,65/m3) is close to the minimum cost of land application (€0,62/m3).Overall, the results of the present doctoral dissertation can contribute not only to the brackish water and seawater desalination industry but also to numerous brine-producing industries, such as the oil and gas industries, textile industries, dairy industries, etc. The MLD/ZLD strategies support the transition from linear to a circular economy, where waste generation is kept to a minimum, carbon emissions are limited and resource use becomes more efficient.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Panagopoulos, Argyris
  • Παναγόπουλος, Αργύρης

Subjects

dc:subject × 19

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/49861

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Panagopoulos, Argyris; Παναγόπουλος, Αργύρης. Ολοκληρωμένη αξιοποίηση των αλατούχων υγρών αποβλήτων από μονάδες αφαλάτωσης. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2021. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/49861