Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Διερεύνηση προτυποποίησης μεθοδολογιών εφαρμογής μη καταστρεπτικών μεθόδων σε έργα πολιτισμικής κληρονομιάς

Abstract

dc:description

The objective of this thesis is to investigate the standardization of Non-Destructive Testing (NDT) application methodologies on cultural heritage artifacts. In most cases, concerning works of remarkable archaeological and artistic value, sampling as well as their transfer outside the environment where they are exhibited is prohibited. For this purpose, the following cases of were studied. A) Mycenaean wall paintings and fragments (14th - 12th cent. BC) originated from the Acropolis of Mycenae and the Acropolis of Tiryns as well as the so-called “Spring” fresco (16th cent. BC) from Akrotiri, Thera [prehistoric collection of National Archaeological Museum, Athens, Greece] were studied, for the identification of the pigments, the binding media and the technique applied for their creation, as well as for the damage evaluation and the previous conservation interventions assessment. In this case, sampling was prohibited, while, only in one case, the collection of a micro-sample was allowed from a region of blue color impression of one of the fragments. Considering the need for protecting the archaeological findings, in addition to the sampling restriction, in many cases, in-situ analysis is required to be rapid. Therefore, for the development of the application methodology of NDT methods on the artifacts of this case, in-situ measurements were performed on the surface of the under investigation artifacts, utilizing XRF and FORS (VIS-NearIR) portable spectrometers for the characterization of the chemical elemental composition and the reflectance spectral analysis of the pigments, respectively. Moreover, the NDT method ATR-FTIR was applied on the micro-sample to characterise the molecular structure of the pigments and the organic binding media.The results obtained from this study led to reliable conclusions regarding the identification of the pigments, the binding media and the technique applied for the creation of the examined wall paintings as well as the damage evaluation and the previous conservation interventions assessment.From this research work, it is concluded that the combined application of the NDT methods XRF and FORS constitutes an appropriate and effective NDT methodology for examining historical wall paintings, contributing significantly to their conservation and restoration. The combined NDT methodology which includes the application of XRF and FORS is suggested in the direction of its standardization. Β) Canvas paintings (1927-1933) created by the famous Greek folk painter Theophilos Hatzimihail [1870(?) - 1934] were studied, which are part of an extensive collection of his paintings belonging to the Theophilos Museum in Varia, Lesvos [Directorate of Conservation of Ancient and Modern Monuments, Ministry of Culture and Sports, Hellenic Republic], for the characterization of the pigments and their application, the identification of the binding media, as well as the assessment of the preservation state. The selected objects were studied in two phases using two different methodologies developed for this purpose, the second one being the first one's optimised methodology. 1st Methodology: At first, the artifacts were studied with the combined application of the NDT methods XRF and FORS, using portable instruments for in-situ measurements on the surface of the paintings, of various color impressions, for the characterization of the chemical elemental composition and the reflectance spectral analysis of the paint layers, respectively. Then, the FTIR Spectroscopy was applied in the laboratory on limited micro-samples (as flakes) that were detached from the paint layers of representative color impressions of the paintings, for the characterization of the molecular structure of the pigments and the binding media.Additionally, a wall painting of Theophilos Hatzimihail, created at the same period of the investigated canvas paintings (1928) and being one of the few surviving wall paintings of his, was investigated, with the use of the first methodology (meaning a comparative study of the pigments used by Theophilos in his wall paintings and canvas paintings). Regarding the pigments used for creating the examined wall painting, it is concluded that they do not differ from those of the canvas paintings. 2nd Methodology: In addition the XRF and FORS, the NDT methods Digital Optical Microscopy (DOM), and Raman Spectroscopy were applied, for the surface structure observation and the investigation of the mixtures of the pigments and the characterization of the molecular structure of the materials, respectively, using portable equipment to perform in-situ analysis. Afterwards, limited micro-samples were detached from the paint layers and were studied using the NDT methods FTIR and micro-Raman in the laboratory to verify the optimized methodology developed that doesn’t require any sampling. From the results obtained from the two methodologies and their comparative study, it is concluded that the optimized methodology, which combines the in-situ application of the NDT methods DOM, XRF, FORS and Raman, is reliable and conclusive concerning the investigation of the pigments, the binding media, the technique applied and the preservation state of the under examination canvas paintings. In the direction of its standardization, this optimized methodology is suggested as an appropriate and effective methodology for the investigation of historical canvas paintings. C.1) Copper-based artifacts manufactured of different copper alloys and dated at the Early (2700-2300 BC) and Late Bronze Age (1600-1100 BC) [prehistoric collection of National Archaeological Museum, Athens, Greece] were studied by employing portable XRF spectrometer. In-situ measurements were performed at multiple spots of their surface, with the aim of investigating the suitability and efficiency, in terms of accuracy and reliability, of the analytical data that can be obtained for the identification of the alloy chemical composition of historical copper-based objects and their classification into different historical periods, in-situ and without any sampling.Also, a fragment of one of Late Bronze Age artifacts was studied using the NDT method ESEM-EDX in the laboratory for the chemical elemental analysis of its bulk and its surface corrosion products, as well as for the investigation of its microstructure.From the comparative study of the results obtained via the XRF and ESEM-EDX and the chemical composition of artifacts’ bulk, determined in previous laboratory studies by the destructive methods AAS and ICP-AES, it is concluded that the application of the NDT method XRF leads to reliable conclusions concerning the qualitative and quantitative analysis of the bulk of historic copper-based objects and their classification into their historical periods, without any sampling. Moreover, via the XRF application, the assessment of their preservation state and the previous conservation interventions to which the artifacts have been subjected is possible. In the direction of its standardization, the above-described methodology is suggested as the optimal for examining historical copper-based artifacts, especially for cases where both sampling and the transfer of the artifacts are prohibited. C.2) In the same framework of investigating historical metal objects, Mycenaean gold alloy artifacts (16th - 14th cent. BC) [prehistoric collection of National Archaeological Museum, Athens, Greece] were studied. In this case, sampling was not allowed at all, nor their transfer outside the Museum environment; therefore, only in-situ analysis could be performed. For this purpose, a combined methodology was applied, which includes investigating the artifacts via the NDT methods XRF and FORS, to perform in-situ measurements at multiple spots of their surface. The former was selected and applied for the determination of the chemical elemental composition of the main alloys, the joining areas of the different parts, the inlay materials as well as the areas with apparent traces of now missing decorative parts, the latter for the reflectance spectral analysis of the alloys and the inlay materials (present in traces). The results obtained via the application of XRF led to the determination of the use of native gold alloys to manufacture the examined artifacts, containing high Au and lower Ag concentrations while Cu was detected as a minor element, as well as the identification of the trace elements. Moreover, the XRF analysis results allowed the differentiation of the chemical composition at the joining areas of the different parts, thus, leading to the approach of the joining process followed as well as the determination of the traces the lost decorative parts have left, confirming the assumptions about their nature made by the Museum archaeologists. The application of FORS allowed the confirmation of the use of native gold alloys and the identification of the inlay materials.From the above-described research work, it is concluded that the combined application of the NDT methods XRF and FORS constitutes an appropriate and effective methodology for the investigation of objects of this case, and it is suggested as the optimal, in the direction of its standardization, especially when neither sampling nor the transfer of the artifacts is possible. D) In addition to all of the above-described, through the interdisciplinary collaboration with the research teams of Computer Science and Image Digital Processing and the Information Science, the results obtained through the investigation of the standardization of NDT application methodologies on the examined cultural heritage artifacts were applied in the framework of: a) the development of new tools/ techniques for the numerical analysis of the raw data obtained through the application of the NDT methods XRF and FORS on the historic wall paintings and the copper-based artifacts; and b) the study and selection of the appropriate metadata models and the employment of a conceptual application profile model for the Development of an Integrated Information Environment (IIE) for the assessment and the documentation of conservation interventions to cultural objects using NDT methods. These applications led to the following conclusions and achievements: a) the modelling of the value sets obtained from the application of XRF and FORS, the development of standard measurements libraries (of XRF and FORS spectra) that can act as guides as well as the automatic, reliable and fast identification of pigments in works of art bearing polychromy and the automatic classification of copper alloys of historical artifacts into their historical periods. b) the extension of the metadata standard CIDOC-CRM – ISO 21127: 2006, so as to include the data and metadata resulting from the application of NDT methods, which led to the standardization of the documentation of NDT application methodologies, the workflows and their results, in the framework of CIDOC-CRM. In this way, the methodologies become interoperable and transferable, while the individual information is semantically represented and is searchable and processable.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Saint, Amani-Christiana
  • Σαΐντ, Αμάνη-Χριστιάνα

Subjects

dc:subject × 47

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/49863

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Saint, Amani-Christiana; Σαΐντ, Αμάνη-Χριστιάνα. Διερεύνηση προτυποποίησης μεθοδολογιών εφαρμογής μη καταστρεπτικών μεθόδων σε έργα πολιτισμικής κληρονομιάς. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2021. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/49863