National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Διερεύνηση παραμέτρων για τη βελτίωση της ακρίβειας προσδιορισμού υψομετρικών διαφορών με τη μέθοδο της χρονομετρικής χωροστάθμησης
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of the dissertation is to study, analyze and evaluate the parameters involved in the accuracy of determining height differences by using the methodology of chronometric levelling. This methodology refers to the utilization and adoption of the principles of the general relativity theory in the corresponding theory of classical geodesy.The study and analysis of the parameters focuses on both the fundamental part of the application of the methodology as well as those referring to the optical atomic clocks that will be used for comments.The motivation was the combination of two thoughts: the introduction and adoption of the general relativity theory in most disciplines (Physics, Astronomy, Metrology etc.) and the introduction of using an heights’ differences determination methodology taking into account the Earth's gravitational field but at the same time it is not affected by the cumulative errors of conventional methods.The originality of the dissertation lies in:•The basic principles of the GRT are used in accordance to the classical Geodesy principles. Also, the possibility of determining orthometric height differences is confirmed, based on relativistic Geodesy.•The analyzed parameters have resulted from the comprehensive study of different scientific areas.•The utilization of an overall inclusive study of the parameters affecting the final accuracy of height differences, using chronometring levelling. •The comparison of the parameters by means of their qualitative and quantitative characteristics.•The development of an evaluation process, for different theoretical scenarios by using an overall rating scale.•The creation of general guidelines regarding the implementation of the methodology.The dissertation is developed in three parts, which are divided into chapters.First partThis part of the dissertation, which consists of three chapters (1st, 2nd and 3rd) focuses on the detailed recording of international bibliography of scientific issues related to it. Specifically, the dissertation is based in the combination of the principles of classical and relativistic geodesy to achieve the best accuracy of height differences determination. Therefore, each chapter of the first part is an in-depth reference to different but related scientific areas.Also, in sub-chapters 2, 3 the analysis refers to the parameters that affect the final accuracy of time-frequency determination. The parameters are separated into constants or variables, depending on the rate of influence on uncertainty.The first chapter analyzes the elements of the classical geodesy relating to heights’ information. A separation between different height categories as well as well as the various reference systems been created for the expression, implementation and quantification of altitude information. In addition, all conventional methodologies are recorded in order to derive the advantages and disadvantages of each one. Reference is also made to the basic concepts of the gravitational field. The study of height differences in combination with the gravitational field, is the connecting link of the sciences of classical and relativistic geodesy.However, the most important part of this chapter, is the analysis of all existing and future efforts, regarding the creation of unified height reference systems. Specifically, the different techniques and methods been created to determine the coefficients used to unify systems, are analyzed. Also, the difficulties and limitations created in such experimental processes, and the current efforts to unify the height systems, both globally and nationally, are reported. The second chapter includes detailed analysis of the chronometric levelling methodology. At first the basic concepts of relativistic geodesy are mentioned and more specifically in the field of chronometric geodesy. Extensive reference is made to the measurement of physical quantities, time and frequency. Also, a distinction between the different time categories, is made. The gravitational redshift effect and its influence to frequency, is examined. The gravitational redshift effect is responsible for the applicability of the methodology and it describes the connection between orthometric heights and gravity potential.However, the most important part of this chapter is the study, recording and analysis of the parameters that affect the time-frequency accuracy, due to the characteristics of the methodology.Specifically, the constant parameter "measurement" is analyzed, which refers to the choice of time or frequency as observed quantity. Frequency observation is essentially preferred because the process of recording, transferring and comparison is simpler and more convenient.Respectively, the variable parameter "communication" is analyzed, which refers to the choice of medium that will be used to connect the measuring devices and the transmission techniques to be used for comparison. The selection of the appropriate medium and technique category depends on the purpose and specific characteristics of each different study.The third chapter refers to the detailed recording of the characteristics of atomic clocks. Initially a historical review is carried out, regarding the use and development of different time keeping systems. The retrospective is formed by the accuracy of determining the nominal value of time.The evolution of clocks, starting from mechanical clocks up to the modern atomic clocks that operate in the optical part of the spectrum, is analyzed. For the modern optical atomic clocks, the fundamental principles regarding their operation, are recorded. Also, their stability and accuracy, is examined.However, the most important part of this chapter is the study, recording and analysis of the parameters that affect the time-frequency accuracy, due to the implementation of optical atomic clocks.Specifically, the variable parameter "category and type" is analyzed, which refers to the main categorization of clocks based on the type of atom or ion to be used. Each of the different categories is also characterized by different compliance in terms of the clock accuracy. The choice is based on existing infrastructure as well as the possibility of modeling and eliminating of systematic sources of errors, which have different effect depending on the choice of the optical atomic clock.Respectively the constant parameter "transportation" is analyzed, which refers to the possibility of transporting the optical atomic clocks. The main categorization of the parameter concerns on the one hand the static or permanent and on the other hand the transportable optical atomic clocks. Each of the categories is characterized by a different complexity of use and construction of optical atomic clocks. Also, as the dimensions of the optical atomic clocks decrease and their transportation becomes easier, their dynamic data collection capabilities are highlighted. All the different categories have to perform measurements with the same accuracy therefore the final choice is determined by purpose, cost and technical development.The variable parameter "construction" is also analyzed, which refers to the additional construction features either to the internal or external structure of the optical atomic clocks. The main categorization of the parameter concerns, on the one hand the intervention in the internal structure of the optical atomic clocks, and on the other hand in their external structure. All the different categories have to contribute more or less in enhancing the stability and accuracy of optical atomic clocks, therefore the final choice is determined by the purpose and characteristics of each study.Second partThis part of the dissertation consists of two chapters (4th and 5th). The parameters’ contribution is analyzed and documented, regarding the final height difference determination accuracy by using the method of chronometric levelling, when it is performed with modern optical atomic clocks.In the fourth chapter, the stages of application of the methodology when utilized optical atomic clocks, are indicated. Then an overall study of all parameters, is performed. The aim is to obtain a classification of the parameters, based on their influence on the application of the methodology. This influence is composed and analyzed on the basis of two components. These components relate to the qualitative or quantitative influence of each parameter. Qualitative segregation concerns the general comparative classification of the parameters. The purpose of the general ranking is to analyze which criteria influence the practicality and the possibility of proper implementation of the methodology. The basic criteria are six (6), as following:•Cost•Technical infrastructure and equipment•Complexity•Commercial potential•Mathematical and statistical analysis•Cross-influence between parametersThe general classification is obtained through multi-criteria analysis of the parameters. Each parameter is given a weight factor fluctuating from 1 to 3, for each criterion. The higher the ranking the higher the contribution of the parameter to the practical application of the methodology.Respectively, the quantitative separation concerns the special comparative classification of parameters. The purpose is to use the special classification as an aid for the grading of each parameter in order to form a state of the theoretical contribution of each parameter to the final desired accuracy of the observations.Τo extend the quantitative process classification of parameters for any application, a parameter evaluation model was created. Specifically, a model was defined through a grades’ scale, which expresses the gradation of the effect of each parameter. The scale of degrees was set from 1 to 5, for each parameter. By minimum grade of scale (1), referring to the minimum contribution of the parameter to the final uncertainty. With the maximum degree of scale (5) evaluates the maximum effect of each parameter in the final accuracy of the observations. Grades are determined by the alternatives choices that can be made at the parameter study level, and correspond to the categories and sub-categories created by them. To display the results of the overall study of the parameters a linear contribution equation was created, based on the calculation of the GTotal factor. This factor is the sum of the grades’ points of each parameter.GTotal values range from 5 to 22. The optimum value of the factor is set to the lowest number of points and reflects the ideal conditions and options for the application of the methodology using optical atomic clocks.In the fifth chapter, a theoretical measurements’ simulation is performed. Specifically, different application scenarios of the methodology, are formed. These scenarios (10) cover a wide range of possible practical applications that the methodology can be used for the determination of orthometric height differences.The scenarios are structured to fulfill the range of complexity and combinatorial analysis that must be carried out for their evaluation. In simple cases of scenarios, the parameter choices are less complex and indefinite, while in the most complex cases the options are more combined and binding. Also, the scenarios are formed mainly with constraints that relate to the accuracy of determining height differences and to the distance between optical atomic clock systems. At cases of more complex scenarios, additional restrictions on their application, are applied.The formation of the scenarios is followed by their evaluation based on the created evaluation model. Each scenario is studied separately and receives either a specific GTotal value or a range of its values, in the cases presented vagueness in the effect of the parameters. The following diagram shows the change of the GTotal factor according to any scenario created.Finally, general instructions (guidelines) for the implementation of chronometric levelling with utilization of optical atomic clocks, are created. These structured instructions include the main guidelines and research questions each engineer opts to answer prior to the practical application, to have a first theoretical estimate of the final accuracy determination of height differences.Third partThe last part of the dissertation consists of one chapter (6), which presents the overall conclusions and suggestions. Eventually it turns out that the methodology of chronometric levelling can be used for measurement of height differences with an accuracy of ± 1cm, as long as modern devices, optical atomic clocks of accuracy of at least 10-18, are used.The sixth and last chapter summarizes the conclusions which have emerged and some suggestions are made for further investigation.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kanellopoulos, Nikolaos
- Κανελλόπουλος, Νικόλαος
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Χρονομετρική χωροστάθμηση
- Σχετικιστική Γεωδαισία
- Βαρυτική φασματική μετατόπιση
- Οπτικά ατομικά ρολόγια
- Chronometric Levelling
- Relativistic Geodesy
- Gravitational Redshift Effect
- Optical Atomic Clocks
- Άλλες Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογίες
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Όργανα και Συστήματα οργάνων
- Other Engineering and Technologies
- Engineering and Technology
- Instruments and Instrumentation
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/49918