University of Thessaly (UTH)
Έλληνες Εβραίοι: μνήμες και Ταυτότητες μετά τον Β’ Παγκόσμιο Πόλεμο
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe present study offers an original contribution to the history of the Jews of Greece. It concentrates on the enormous changes wrought by the Occupation and the annihilation of the overwhelming majority of Greek Jewry. In this study the relations of the Greek Jews with the state and the international community are examined. In addition, both the social and cultural changes within the communities are examined at the level of community reconstruction and leadership, at the level of the ideological currents that permeated these communities, as well as at the level of individual and collective choices and trajectories. Recent historiography focuses on the issue of the “return” of Jews in the aftermath of the Shoah; in the Introduction an overview of the relevant Greek historiography is presented, in the context of the corresponding international developments.Drawing on different sources held in the archives of the Central Council of Jewish Communities of Greece (KISE), the communities of Athens and Thessaloniki, the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee (Joint), the Jewish Museum of Greece (EME), the Service for the Management of Jewish Property (YDIP), Yad Vashem, the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, as well as on memoirs, literary texts, and publications in the Greek and Greek-Jewish press of the time, I track step by step the multifaceted process of the construction of both the multiple identities of Greek Jews in the aftermath of the Shoah and the latter event’s memory. My main concern was to highlight the subjective, and historiographically “neglected”, dimension of the history of Greek Jews after the war within a chronological framework extending from the first days of liberation (October 1944) to the mid 1950s – the era in which the reconstruction of the communities of Greece was been largely completed.The dissertation is divided into two parts, each part consisting of two chapters. In the first chapter of the first part, entitled “Return and Reconstruction”, I examine the initial collective actions by Greek Jews following the withdrawal of the German Army and specifically the features of the public discourse of the leading communal representative Asher Moissis. At the same time I follow what stance Greek Jews, principally those of Athens and Thessaloniki, took as individuals and as collective bodies, in regard to the pressing problems that needed to be faced such as the housing of survivors whose homes were occupied by refugees or German collaborators, the provision of food and medical care for those who were unemployed or weakened by the hardships of the camps or participation in the Resistance, for the orphaned children and “unprotected” girls. I also focus on the ideological confrontations that erupted between the survivors of Athens and Thessaloniki and how they were reflected in the discourse of the Joint.The second chapter of the first part, entitled “Early Testimonies: the First Phase in the Construction of Memory”, is dedicated to the development of Greek-Jewish autobiographical discourse and examines the texts of Marcel Nadjari, Isaac Matarasso, Albert Menasche and Marco Nahon. The extensive analysis presented in this chapter offers a representative picture of the prevailing issues that emerge from these texts, the rhetorical methods used in order to compose a first standard narrative, but also the mediation of this discourse by journalists in accordance to the political orientation of their newspapers. Furthermore, I analyse the works of Michael Molho and Joseph Nehama, as well as two literary works that have been somewhat neglected by the pertinent Greek philological and historiographical scholarship namely, the novels of Maurice Politi and Isaac Ben-Rubi.The second part of the dissertation is devoted to the Jewish ideological identities that emerged or evolved in the post-war era. It consists of two chapters. In the first chapter entitled “Greek Jews and Zionists: Ideological Positions and Personalities”, I trace post-war Zionist discourse in both the Jewish press and in the texts of Asher Moissis. I also look at the ways in which the Zionist movement expressed itself in practice – mainly through the “Hachsharot” agricultural training farms – and the experience of the “pioneers” (“chalutzim”). Photographic material complements the archival research. I also discuss the then dominant version of Zionism, that of socialist Zionism, as the latter was articulated by two Greek Jews, Isaac Ben-Rubi and Abraham Benaroya.In the second chapter of the second part, entitled “Greek Jews and Leftists: Ideological Positions and Personalities”, I explore the post-war choices of those Jews, who during the Occupation and Civil War were integrated into the political forces of the Left. I examine what position these Jews took in regard to the dilemmas in the aftermath of the events of December 1944 and in regard to their relations with former comrades. I also examine the relations of former resistance fighters (who were persecuted during the Civil War) with the official leadership of Greek Jewry and with the welfare services of the individual communities and the KIS, and finally their emigration to Israel. The perseverance of antisemitism emerges even after the “earthquake” of the Shoah. The tensions between the communities of Athens and Thessaloniki are highlighted as well as the tense relations between the latter community and the Joint. I also ascertain that despite the sharp ideological divisions within Greek Jewry, such as the conflicts between the Leftists and the Zionists, and contrary to what has been argued by other scholars, there were points of convergence between these opposing groups. The diverse voices articulated Greek Jews after the war, the different positions adopted by these subjects in regard to the question of emigration/“Aliyah” and the clashes between different groups often indicate different rescue experiences (e.g. former resistance fighters - former deportees). In short, the complexity of the Jewish experience after the war is documented and highlighted, primarily as it was experienced and constructed in memory by Greek Jews themselves. In this sense, the present study contributes to a better understanding of the post-war society of Greece.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Beze, Eleni
- Μπεζέ, Ελένη
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/49964