Institutes outside Greece
Regulating moral risk in reproductive technologies: a comparative study of France, the United Kingdom and Greece
Abstract
dc:descriptionReproductive technology and its regulation is a subject with an ever-growing importance, not only because it is surrounded by considerable public controversy, but also because it cuts across a major area of human activity: the creation of human life. The aim of this thesis is to prove that the theory of risk management has particular significance in the field of reproductive medicine and to suggest that, from all the risks involved in this kind of technology, one particular has played the most important role in the passing of the law: moral risk. This kind of risk is novel and under-theorized and does not appear to have been explored by other regulatory schema. Due to the special nature of reproductive technology and the existence of moral risk, I maintain that the best way to regulate this area is the method of deliberative democracy, a method that has not been adequately developed until now.In order to prove my hypothesis, I examine the status of legal regulation in the European Union, from which it emerges that four schemes of regulation exist. I use evidence from a range of jurisdictions, namely the United Kingdom, France and Greece, as exemplars for studying approaches to regulation of reproductive technology. After providing the reasons that make these countries ideal for such a comparison, I frame a consensus on the justifications of regulating this technology. I maintain that the theory of risk regulation is deeply connected with this area and I identify three basic instances of risk management. I place the focus on one novel risk, namely moral risk, which I consider to be the principal justification for regulating reproduction.Due to the importance of moral risk, I study the case law and the Parliamentary and policy debates from the three countries under examination in order to discover whether the need to manage moral risk is existent. I maintain that it is and I identify its meaning according to those who contributed to the relevant debates and the making of case law. I continue by examining what the available regulatory methods are among which a society can choose in order to regulate the risks that this technology raises. I also identify which of these regulatory mechanisms were chosen by the three countries under examination. However, I maintain that the existence of moral risk suggests that the only way for regulation to pay dividends is the use of deliberative democracy, a method that has not been mentioned by any of the countries under examination.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutes outside Greece
- Year dc:date
- 2007
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Deliopoulou, Georgia
- Δελιοπούλου, Γεωργία
Subjects
dc:subject × 21- Μέθοδοι ανθρώπινης υποβοηθούμενης αναπαραγωγής
- Ρύθμιση ρίσκου
- Εκτίμηση ρίσκου
- Διαχείριση ρίσκου
- Μοντέλα νομοθετικής ρύθμισης
- Γαλλία
- Ηνωμένο Βασίλειο
- Ελλάδα
- Methods of human reproductive technologies
- Risk regulation
- Risk assessment
- Risk management
- Models of regulation
- France
- UK (United Kingdom)
- Greece
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Δίκαιο
- Law
- Social Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/50317