Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
Evaluation of effectiveness and harms reporting in overviews of systematic reviews of interventions by developing new assessment tools
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn biomedical literature, overviews of systematic reviews (OoSRs) have recently become a popular approach of evidence synthesis where the unit of synthesis is the systematic review (SR). The outcome data from SRs included in an OoSRs can be presented exactly as they are reported in the SRs (qualitative synthesis) or they can be re-analyzed using meta-analysis (quantitative synthesis). OoSRs can provide valuable information to support decision-making by healthcare professionals and to guide integration of research evidence in policy-making within a short timeframe. Using a sample of 1558 OoSRs published between 2000 and 2020, the bibliometric analysis revealed research trends and areas of interest about these studies. Particularly, we found that the publications have been increasing yearly and their nomenclature was not uniform (the most frequent label in the title was “overview of systematic reviews”). The largest number of papers and the most cited ones were published by corresponding authors from the United Kingdom. The publications were distributed across 737 scholarly journals and many of them were published in the field of complementary/alternative medicine, psychiatry/psychology, nutrition/dietetics, and pediatrics. The co-authorship analysis revealed collaborations among authors from different countries. The most common clinical conditions were depression, diabetes, cancer, dementia, pain, cardiovascular disease, stroke, obesity, and schizophrenia. Furthermore, this dissertation presents assessment tools for evaluating the effectiveness and harms reporting completeness in OoSRs of healthcare interventions. We developed the PRIO-harms tool (56 sub-items) to promote a more transparent and balanced reporting of benefits and harms of interventions examined in healthcare OoSRs, and PRIO for abstracts tool (20 sub-items) to help authors in writing complete, transparent and informative abstracts for OoSRs. These instruments can be adopted by journal editors and publishers that publish OoSRs as well. Additionally, in this doctoral thesis we introduced new static tabular and graphical techniques for visually presenting overlapping SRs included in OoSRs. The proposed sophisticated graphical methods (e.g., upset plots, heatmaps, node-link graphs) may assist methodologists and authors in exploring and depicting the degree of overlap of primary studies across SRs, which in turn may improve validity and transparency in OoSRs. However, more research is needed to understand which graphical technique would be most useful and easiest to understand. These novel tools and graphical techniques might benefit from critical review and further validation from experts and research teams that produce guidelines for OoSRs.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Aristotle University Of Thessaloniki (AUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Bougioukas, Konstantinos
- Μπουγιούκας, Κωνσταντίνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Ανασκόπηση συστηματικών ανασκοπήσεων
- Kατευθυντήριες oδηγίες πληρότητας καταγραφής
- Εργαλείο αξιολόγησης PRIO-harms
- Εργαλείο αξιολόγησης PRIO για περιλήψεις
- Οverview of systematic reviews
- Reporting completeness guidelines
- PRIO-harms checklist
- PRIO for abstracts checklist
- Άλλες Ιατρικές Επιστήμες
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Ιατρική, άλλοι τομείς
- Other Medical Sciences
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Medicine, miscellaneous
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/50515