Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Χωρική διασπορά της φωσφίνης σε πρότυπους χώρους, σε σχέση με την αποτελεσματικότητά της για έντομα αποθηκευμένων γεωργικών προϊόντων και τροφίμων

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation examines the distribution of phosphine gas in different types of facilities and structures. The evaluation of phosphine distribution was conducted by using a series of tests at the Laboratory of Entomology and Agricultural Zoology (LEAZ), at the University of Thessaly. In the first experimental part, we determined phosphine resistance in insect populations that had been collected from a range of storages across Greece, using different diagnostic protocols. Apart from the traditional Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) protocol, a field rapid diagnostic (known as the Phosphine Tolerance Test, PTT), a Dose Response protocol (insect exposure at various concentrations) and the Cooperation Centre for Scientific Research Relative to Tobacco (CORESTA) protocol (exposure at fixed concentrations for fixed exposure intervals) were utilized, for the determination of the resistance status of field collected insects. In total, 53 populations belonging to Rhyzopertha dominica, Sitophilus oryzae, Sitophilus granarius, Cryptolestes ferrugineus, Tribolium confusum, Tribolium castaneum and Oryzaephilus surinamensis were tested. For the majority of the species and populations tested, PTT and FAO provided similar results, for the susceptibility to phosphine and thus, the quick test could be used with success for an initial same day screening of phosphine resistance. Among the tested species, the populations recorded with the most frequent survival at the FAO and Dose Response protocols were those of R. dominica. In contrast, in the CORESTA protocol all populations were considered as susceptible. The dissimilar evaluation and characterization of resistance to phosphine between diagnostic protocols is particularly important, as it poses risks in the overestimation or underestimation of the resistance status of a given population. Our data indicate that the PTT could be used to determine resistance to phosphine in the field, before the initiation of fumigations to disinfest stored commodities. In the second experimental part, we evaluated wireless phosphine sensors to quantify and depict spatio-temporal dynamics and distribution of this gas within different types of facilities and commodities. The use of wireless sensors has certain advantages over the traditional monitoring techniques (e.g. glass tubes etc.), as any measurements with these traditional techniques correspond to the specific time and location of monitoring and are not transferable to additional intervals and locations, which leads fumigators to either overestimate or underestimate the concentrations and outcomes of a given fumigation. In fact, in light of our findings, the distribution of phosphine in large warehouses was not usually adequate for a satisfactory level of insect control, and gas concentrations varied remarkably through time and space. In contrast, commercial treatments at containers were sufficient to control the insects tested, even on stored-product insects which were found to be resistant to phosphine. Furthermore, in the case of silos and ship holds, our work indicated that the use of forced recirculation systems for phosphine is essential to increase concentration and, as a result, insect mortality. Overall, our tests clearly suggested that the sensors were very effective in measuring phosphine and are generally expected to play an important role in the near future in IPM-based programs at the post-harvest stages of agricultural commodities. At the same time, real-time monitoring can be used with success for the prediction of insect mortality in the treated facilities. In the third experimental part, the distribution of phosphine gas in six metal silos with wheat was modelled and compared with available distribution data from phosphine sensors. During the fumigation, a recirculation system was used to improve the diffusion of phosphine. Three different Scenarios of the recirculation system were used: (a) Scenario 1: the recirculation system was used for only 24 h in the beginning of the fumigation, (b) Scenario 2: the recirculation system was used for four consecutive days from the beginning of the fumigation and (c) Scenario 3: the recirculation system was used from the beginning of the fumigation for approximately 50 hours, where the concentration reached over 300 ppm and gas equilibrium was achieved. In each silo, sensors were placed to monitor the concentration of phosphine, along with vials with phosphine-susceptible and -resistant insect populations of R. dominica and O. surinamensis. A Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) method was used for precision fumigation by using phosphine sensors with the OpenFoam software. Gas transport and sorption effects of phosphine into the grain was accounted through the CFD model. Simulation results were obtained for insect mortality as a function of their exposure to phosphine gas. CFD-based modelling was accurate in simulating and forecasting fumigation results and provided good predictions on each location inside the fumigated areas. Moreover, the fumigation applications resulted in complete control in all populations tested. The recirculation system improved the distribution of phosphine in the fumigated area. The most appropriate Scenario was Scenario 3, showing the least uneven distribution in the treated silo in contrast with the other two Scenarios. These results indicated that CFD correlates well phosphine concentration with insect mortality and thus, a methodology for precision fumigation can be further established. In the fourth experimental part, the distribution of phosphine gas in metal shipping containers was modeled and compared with available data from phosphine sensors. Two different sizes of containers, 20 and 40 ft, were used in the experiments with different doses for each treatment/ each time. In each container, sensors were placed to monitor the distribution of phosphine, along with vials with phosphine –susceptible and –resistant insect populations of R. dominica and O. surinamensis. A CFD model was developed with the OpenFoam software and combined with phosphine sensor data for precision fumigation. Gas transport and sorption effects of phosphine into empty and filled containers were accounted through the CFD model. In the light of our findings, in an empty container, the phosphine concentration was quite similar for all locations, while in the filled container there were noticeable variations inside in the fumigated area. Moreover, there was a time delay for phosphine to reach the sensors that were placed inside the commodity, at the rear side of the filled containers. Regarding the simulations, the predictions of the computational model were in accordance with phosphine distribution as given by the sensor data. Concerning insect mortality data, in most of the cases, for both species, complete control was noted, regardless of the resistance level of the population tested. These results indicated that CFD correlates well with the phosphine concentration and insect mortality and thus, a methodology for precision fumigation in containers can be further established. In the initial section of the fifth experimental part, we evaluated the efficacy of heat treatment on phosphine resistant and susceptible populations of stored product insects at 29 different commercial facilities in Greece. Heat treatments were carried out by using a special equipment, such as Therminate, TempAir and ThermoNox, applied alone or in combination. The overall temperature range was between 33 and 55 °C and the duration of the heat treatments was between 20 and 39 h. Adults of different populations of R. dominica and O. surinamensis were used in the experiments. These populations were collected from different storage facilities in Greece and were characterized for their resistance to phosphine by using the PTT. Insect mortality was measured at the termination of each trial. Then, the vials were kept in incubator chambers set at 25 °C and 65% relative humidity and 65 d later the progeny production was measured in the treated substrate. Based on our results, in the vast majority of the cases, 100% mortality was observed for both resistant and susceptible populations at all facilities. In general, in the few cases where survival and progeny production was recorded, there was no specific trend towards specific species or population. Overall, based on the current results, heat treatment can be used by the industry as an alternative method for the control of phosphine-resistant adults of R. dominica and O. surinamensis. In the final section of the fifth experimental part, the effectiveness of modified atmosphere was evaluated, as an alternative to phosphine. Phosphine-sensitive and phosphine-resistant populations were used in nine commercial nitrogen chambers in Greece. The following combinations were used: 31 oC for 2 days, 40 oC for 2.5 days, 28 oC for 3 days, 28 oC for 6 days and 28 oC for 9 days of exposure, using different populations of R. dominica and O. surinamensis. Mortality and progeny production were recorded as noted above. In all cases, complete parental mortality was observed, with the exception of R. dominica at 31 oC for 2 days of exposure. There was no progeny production, with some exceptions for some of the combinations tested. Our results showed that low oxygen, through the increase of nitrogen, is effective for all populations tested, regardless of their resistance to phosphine. This method can be adopted as an alternative method to control stored product beetles. In general, this is the first assessment of the distribution of phosphine gas in different types of facilities and commodities, in combination with the expected insect mortality. It is shown that fumigation failures can be regarded mostly as a result of poor fumigation practices, rather that insect resistance. At the same time, heat treatment and nitrogen are proposed as alternatives to phosphine gas, as they are based on similar principles, i.e. the treatment of the air around the commodity.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Agrafioti, Paraskevi
  • Αγραφιώτη, Παρασκευή

Subjects

dc:subject × 26

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/50927

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Agrafioti, Paraskevi; Αγραφιώτη, Παρασκευή. Χωρική διασπορά της φωσφίνης σε πρότυπους χώρους, σε σχέση με την αποτελεσματικότητά της για έντομα αποθηκευμένων γεωργικών προϊόντων και τροφίμων. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2021. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/50927