Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Η επίδραση της διείσδυσης των Ανανεώσιμων Πηγών Ενέργειας στην αγορά ηλεκτρικής ενέργειας στην Ελλάδα: τιμές, μεταβλητότητα, περιβάλλον

Abstract

dc:description

The present thesis includes three distinct, although intertwined essays, in which, utilizing data from the Greek electricity market, a series of research questions related to the effect of the penetration of electricity generation from renewable energy sources (RES) in electricity prices as well as in the environment, are examined.In the first essay (second chapter), using hourly data for the period from August 2012 to December 2018, I examined the merit-order effect in the wholesale electricity prices in Greece. The results of the analysis confirm the statistically significant reducing impact that electricity generation from wind and photovoltaic units has on the wholesale electricity prices. The analysis of the merit-order effect by year reveals the impact that regulations related to the rules of market operation have on the size of the merit-order effect. The impact of each RES technology on determining the average merit-order effect varies considerably during the day and in addition evidence of an increase in wholesale prices in the hours following sunset is found. The prospect of a significant increase in the installed capacity of wind and photovoltaic units in the medium term is estimated to have a significant effect on wholesale electricity prices, changing further their distribution during the day. Such changes will dramatically affect the hours of operation and especially the profitability of conventional power plants and will necessitate regulatory interventions, such as the introduction of flexible capacity assurance mechanisms and the lifting of restrictions on price caps, in order to increase the incentives for investments in new conventional power plants. Furthermore, the analysis suggests that large-scale penetration of RES, which is anticipated for the next decade in Greece, is rather difficult to be achieved without operating aid, especially for photovoltaics, due to the merit-order effect, if there are no other favorable developments in RES installation costs. It is therefore highly likely that their support will need to be further maintained, which, however, is not compatible with the functioning of competitive markets for the rest of the electricity supply that will continue to shrink. I also estimated that the overall benefit to electricity suppliers from the reduction in wholesale prices does not offset the cost of supporting the photovoltaic units. However, for wind energy the benefit to suppliers is estimated to exceed support costs. Therefore, RES technologies in power generation are not neutral in terms of the benefits and costs they bring, and this element should be integrated into the relevant policy choices. Finally, I found that the distribution of RES support costs in Greece discriminates in favor of industrial companies that are large consumers of electricity, for reasons related to the protection of their competitiveness, creating distributive effects from the RES support policy. Estimates even suggest that large electricity consumers may have benefited from the entry of RES into electricity generation. [JEL Codes: Q28, Q42, Q48, H23. Keywords: Greek wholesale electricity market, Electricity prices, merit-order effect, RES support mechanism, wind energy, photovoltaic energy, distributive impact, energy policy].In the second essay (third chapter of the thesis) I examined firstly, the impact of wind and photovoltaic energy on the daily level and volatility of wholesale electricity prices in Greece for the period from August 2012 to December 2018 and, secondly, the effect that an increase in the wholesale market price cap had on the price level and volatility. The results of the econometric estimations confirmed the existence of the merit-order effect, both for the intermittent RES as a whole and, separately, for wind and photovoltaic electricity generation, which was stronger in the case of generation from wind farms. Examining regulatory mechanisms that may affect price volatility, I found that, overall, intermittent RES have reduced price volatility – contrary to the prevailing view in the literature that price volatility is increased. This result conceals the significant differentiation of the effect on volatility, which depends on the RES technology under examination. In particular, electricity generation from wind farms is associated with increased volatility, while generation from photovoltaic plants is associated with reduced volatility of wholesale prices. The offsetting effect between wind and photovoltaic energy on the daily price volatility leads to the overall marginally negative effect. Therefore, the balanced development of RES technologies is particularly useful from the perspective of the impact they may have on price volatility and system flexibility needs, and this should be taken into account in energy policy considerations to support and integrate different RES technologies in the power system. Differentiation is also present in the impact on price volatility during the day, as I found evidence that wind energy during low demand hours tends to increase price volatility, as opposed to higher demand hours during which it decreases price volatility. In addition, generation from photovoltaics has reduced price volatility during hours of high demand, at which almost all of their output is concentrated, confirming the hypothesis that when the output of intermittent RES is positively correlated with electricity demand, at high segments of the supply curve, a smaller impact or even a reduction in price volatility is expected. Finally, I estimated that the increase in the price cap in the Greek wholesale electricity market is associated with an increase in the level and a decrease in the volatility of wholesale electricity prices. This result highlights the importance of the composition of the portfolio of power plants and the degree of vertical integration of participants in liberalized electricity markets, which determines their behavior in the market and has a potential impact on the volatility of electricity prices [JEL Codes: Q41, Q42, Q48. Keywords: Greek wholesale electricity market, Electricity prices, volatility, wind energy, photovoltaic energy, price caps, merit-order effect].In the third essay (fourth chapter) I examined the average amount of avoided CO2 emissions from wind and photovoltaic energy in the Greek interconnected electricity system during the period from August 2012 to December 2018 and I evaluated the cost-effectiveness of the policy promoting RES in Greece with regard to the aim of reducing CO2 emissions. The analysis found a statistically significant effect on the CO2 emissions avoided per MWh of wind and photovoltaic generation, which, however, varies significantly by technology and per year, due to changes in conventional electricity generation mix and the level of total load and generation from intermittent RES. Wind energy has achieved greater substitution of thermal power generation and less substitution of hydroelectric production and net imports, i.e. energy sources with zero CO2 emissions or sources of emissions originating in other electricity systems, saving more CO2 emissions than photovoltaics. I also assessed the impact on CO2 emissions of a marginal increase in wind and photovoltaic energy during hours with different levels of load and electricity generation from intermittent RES. As a general conclusion, the composition of the installed capacity and the output of conventional power plants, the load of the system, the capacity of international interconnections and the generation levels of wind and photovoltaic units significantly affect the level of marginal emissions avoided by the intermittent RES. In addition, I found that the net cost of the policy promoting RES to reduce CO2 emissions varies significantly for each RES technology. The net support cost of photovoltaics is found to be many times its potential external benefit. Wind energy has provided significant net social benefit, being a highly effective policy tool to reduce emissions, as each emission reduction unit was carried out to the benefit of consumers and society as a whole, regardless of the benefit associated with other externalities. In contrast, in the case of photovoltaics the benefit of reducing the emissions could not approach the cost of support. These findings highlight the essential role that RES policy design can play, which, under certain conditions, may prevail over alternative climate policy instruments. Overall, the policy of promoting RES in Greece in the period 2013-2018 with the aim of reducing CO2 emissions cannot be considered cost-effective, as the total cost of supporting intermittent RES significantly exceeds a wide range of estimates of social carbon cost. These results suggest that more efficiency gains can be realized by designing incentives to more accurately reflect the external benefits of individual RES technologies. Furthermore, depending on the technology, the conclusion of other studies that direct carbon pricing is the most effective policy tool for reducing CO2 emissions and other sources of pollution cannot be generalized.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2020

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Maniatis, Georgios
  • Μανιάτης, Γεώργιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 34

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/50978

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Maniatis, Georgios; Μανιάτης, Γεώργιος. Η επίδραση της διείσδυσης των Ανανεώσιμων Πηγών Ενέργειας στην αγορά ηλεκτρικής ενέργειας στην Ελλάδα: τιμές, μεταβλητότητα, περιβάλλον. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2020. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/50978