National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Ενότητα και πολλαπλότητα κατά τους ύστερους διαλόγους και την άγραφη διδασκαλία του Πλάτωνος
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe purpose of the dissertation is to investigate the nature of the two ultimate Principles of Platonic metaphysics and the productive system based on the Principles through a co-examination of the written and unwritten philosophy of Plato. In the first part I examine the unwritten theory of the Principles, while in the second part I try to demonstrate that this theory is fully compatible with the content of the late Platonic Dialogues. The two Principles of Being, the One (Ἓν) and the Indefinite Dyad of the Great-and-Small (Ἀόριστος Δυὰς ή Μέγα καὶ Μικρὸν), are not placed in the Platonic works in the form they appear in the unwritten doctrines, but they are the canvas on which both the unwritten and the written dialectic are woven. The unwritten theory of Principles, although provided to us in fragmentary form through the scattered references of Aristotle and other ancient writers, can be reconstructed and serve as a guiding thread for a deeper understanding of Platonic thought as a whole. The purpose of the dissertation is, therefore, to explore the deeper core of Plato’s metaphysics and to demonstrate the presence of Principles in his written work. The fact that the Platonic Dialogues never reach a definitive conclusion, but the philosophical issues remain open each time, confirms Plato’s belief that the meaning of the Unspoken, although it is the ultimate foundation of each individual issue, does not become explicit within the context of written speech. The Platonic dialectic, however, is organized around this transcendental meaning. The element of concealed metaphysical truth points to a theory that goes beyond Dialogues. This unknown aspect of Platonic metaphysics, which we derive from the work of Aristotle, can, therefore, allow a more complete reading of Plato under appropriate conditions. The first entities to emerge from the two Principles are the Ideal Numbers, because they contain the One and the Multiple in their purest version, and therefore infiltrate the structure of every being, even of Ideas. The Unity of the One is not a rigid Unity but a dynamic Unity, capable of developing dialectical relations. It should, therefore, be understood not only as an absolute Unity but also as having an inherent dynamism, an infinite capacity for self-differentiation and production of forms. On the other hand, although hierarchically superior to the Indefinite Dyad, the One cannot be a productive Principle without the Dyad. This element underlines a kind of interdependence between the Principles, which leads us to a metaphysical monism. The pure and absolute Unity, completely separated from the Multiplicity, is impossible and inconceivable. The One and the Many exist or are removed together. The existence of the One constitutes a conditio sine qua non for the Many, and vice versa. The existence of the One alone means the acceptance of a Twin: the One and the Being. The One is related to the Idea of Being, and from this relation emerges the Number 2 and, therefore, the order of the Numbers. The implicit and transcendental One (Ἓν) of the first Parmenides’s hypothesis appears in the second hypothesis as capable of developing ontological relationships. That is, from the Being of the One, the ontological multiplicity emerges, starting with the multiplicity of Numbers. Without the Οne, the Multiple retains no trace of its Being, even as something inherently indefinite. Deprived of Unity, the Many disappear, because they become incoherent and chaotic. Multiplicity exists only if it has a purely numerical meaning, that is, if it is a Unity. Thus, Parmenides’s system of eight hypotheses confirms the complete dependence of the Multiple on the One and, finally, the monistic character of the Metaphysics of the Principles. Philebus confirms the correspondence of the Limit (Πέρας) and the Unlimited (Ἄπειρον) with the One and the Indefinite Dyad. The Limit is the Principle of every symmetric relation, while the Unlimited is the Principle of every asymmetry. The One is conceived as a Measure (Μέτρον), when it ceases to be considered completely transcendent and is treated in the light of the dialectic it develops with Being. The Measure constitutes the Principle of all symmetrical relations contained in the Being, and, therefore, is identified with One - Good (Ἓν - Ἀγαθὸν). Thus, the late Platonic Dialogues lead to the confirmation of the main position of Plato’s unwritten teaching, that the One is the Principle of Numbers and is the supreme Measure (Μέτρον).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Birou, Vasiliki
- Μπίρου, Βασιλική
Subjects
dc:subject × 56- Άγραφα δόγματα
- Περὶ τἀγαθοῦ
- Έν
- Πολλά
- Ενότητα
- Πολλαπλότητα
- στοιχεῖα ή πρῶται ἀρχαί
- Αγαθόν
- Μέτρον
- Ἀόριστος Δυὰς
- Μέγα καὶ Μικρόν
- Yλική αρχή
- Πέρας
- Ἄπειρον
- Ίσον
- Ἄνισον
- Εἰδητικοὶ ἀριθμοί
- ἰδεώδη μεγέθη
- Σημείο
- Γραμμή
- Επίπεδο
- Στερεό
- Δυιστική μεταφυσική
- έσχατος μονισμός
- Σχολή της Τυβίγγης
- Unwritten doctrines
- One
- Many
- Unity
- Multiplicity
- Elements
- First principles
- Good
- Measure
- Indefinite Dyad
- Great and Small
- Material principle
- Limit
- Unlimited
- Equal
- Unequal
- Ideal numbers
- Ideal magnitudes
- Point
- Line
- Plane
- Solid
- Dualistic metaphysics
- Final monism
- Tübingen School
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Φιλοσοφία
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
- Humanities and the Arts
- Philosophy
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/51286