University of Patras
Διαχείριση αστικών στερεών αποβλήτων: διερεύνηση της συσχέτισής τους με σύνθετους κοινωνικοοικονομικούς δείκτες - κατασκευή ολιστικών δεικτών μέτρησης της περιβαλλοντικής απόδοσης και της απόδοσης στην κυκλική οικονομία
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe increased production and consumption of products, a result of the economic and technological development, has led to a surge in the production of solid waste on a global level. Indeed, the "culture of rejection", combined with the "linear" character of the economy, creates huge amounts of waste, raising serious environmental, social and economic challenges. Understandably, waste prevention, reuse and recycling are high on the policy agenda aiming to reduce the demand for new resources, mitigate energy use, alleviate the environmental impact of waste and promote sustainable development. At the same time, global organizations, governments and researchers are developing complex socio-economic indicators that can be used as overall measures of sustainability, social progress, prosperity and well-being, that can enhance our knowledge and facilitate the development of appropriate policies to improve living conditions. Although the influence of various, individual socioeconomic factors on the per capita generated quantity of municipal solid waste, as well as on several of its management practices, has been extensively studied by the scientific community, to our knowledge, there has been no similar research investigating the correlation between the production of municipal solid waste and its management practices with complex socioeconomic indexes. The present thesis has tried to fill this gap. The results of the econometric study revealed that GDP presents the strongest correlation with the per capita generated amount of municipal solid waste, compared to the chosen socioeconomic indicators, namely the Human Development Index and the Social Progress Index. In addition, the results highlighted the significant correlation between the municipal solid waste management practices and all the aforementioned indicators. Moreover, contrary to the results that concern the generation of waste, the multidimensional indicators Human Development Index and Social Progress Index, show a better correlation, either negative or positive, with specific management practices, such as landfilling, incineration and recycling than the one-dimensional GDP index.Furthermore, taking into account the European Union’s waste hierarchy, the present dissertation has focused and explored, using panel data, the link between municipal solid waste generation and recycling with the social progress of European Union countries, as it is captured by the multi-dimensional Social Progress Index. The results revealed that any improvement, in almost every aspect of social life, is accompanied by an increase in the per capita generated quantity of municipal solid waste, although economic development, as it is captured by the rise of GDP, is the main driver behind these increased quantities. However, it is encouraging that both the rise of GDP, as well as the improvement of almost any dimension and thematic category of the Social Progress Index, can positively affect the shift of municipal solid waste management towards more eco-friendly methods, such as recycling. It is especially noteworthy that, among all the various thematic categories of the Social Progress Index, those related to democracy have been revealed as key drivers for the collective action of municipal solid waste recycling. This result suggests that certain characteristics of democracy, such as the level of institutional trust or the low level of corruption can be important determinants of how successfully a country can manage its municipal solid waste, by encouraging citizens’ participation towards this goal. The waste management sector is important for the European Union, not only because of the necessity to alleviate the environmental impact of waste, but also because of its key role in transforming the economy from “linear” to cyclical and thus contributes to the dual goal of economic and environmental sustainability. However, by using only single indexes, such as the Recycling rate and/or the Cyclical Material Use rate, countries' actual performance regarding these two goals, can be overestimated or underestimated. That is because the per capita generation of municipal solid waste is left unaccounted, despite the fact that low waste generation is an important environmental target, and so is the countries’ true potential, as it is reflected by their economic and social progress. In order to address these weaknesses, the present dissertation dealt with the construction of holistic efficiency measures to assess member countries’ performance in managing their municipal solid waste (Environmental Performance) and in exploiting their recycled waste (Cyclical Economy Performance).These two holistic measures of performance were constructed with the utilization of Data Envelopment Analysis. For both performance measures, the per capita generated quantity of municipal solid waste, as well as the three dimensions of the Social Progress Index (Basic Human Needs, Foundations of Wellbeing and Opportunity) were used as inputs. In addition, the recycling rate was used as an output, for constructing the Environmental Performance index, while for the Circular Economy Performance two outputs were used, namely the recycling rate and the Circular Material Use rate. These holistic measures were used for the comparative evaluation of member countries, using both the basic Data Envelopment Analysis framework (CCR), as well as a model that imposes common weights in order to achieve a complete ranking of the countries. Finally, the second model was extended in a dynamic framework, in order to assess the evolution of the environmental and circular economy performance of each Member State over time, as well as for the construction of a Malmquist Productivity Index, to monitor the countries’ productivity through time. Beside their scientific interest, the proposed evaluation frameworks, which satisfy the globally accepted criteria for the construction of complex indexes, can be used as objective tools for the identification of the countries with the best and the worst performances. As a result, they can be an especially useful tool for developing policies, since determining which are the effective and which are the non-effective countries can help, for example, to identify best practices and to encourage their adoption by the weaker performers.The results of these evaluations revealed the existence of large disparities between European countries, both with regard to their Environmental Performance and also to their Circular Economy Performance. It is interesting though that, regarding the issues under examination, the “borders” between Western and Eastern Europe have fallen. But not those between the north and the south: old EU members, such as Spain or France, perform significantly worse than newer members, such as Slovenia or Poland in both efficiency measures. This conclusion is confirmed by the results of the intertemporal analysis, since both Cyprus and Greece present, in general, the worst performance with regard to the Environmental Performance and to Cyclical Economy Performance. Moreover, the values of the Malmquist index (sometimes above, sometimes below, but always near one) for these two countries, suggest a worrisome stagnation in the solid waste management sector. Finally, Belgium has been revealed as the best performer with regard to both holistic measures of efficiency, surpassing countries with notable recycling rates, such as Germany and/or Cyclical Material Use rates, such as the Netherlands.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Giannakitsidou, Olga
- Γιαννακιτσίδου, Όλγα
Subjects
dc:subject × 42- Ευρωπαϊκή Ένωση
- Παραγωγή και διαχείριση αστικών στερεών αποβλήτων
- Ποσοστό ανακύκλωσης
- Ποσοστό κυκλική χρήσης υλικών
- Ακαθάριστο Εγχώριο Προϊόν
- Δείκτης ανθρώπινης ανάπτυξης
- Δείκτης Βιώσιμης Κοινωνίας
- Δείκτης Κοινωνικής Προόδου
- Δημοκρατία
- Περιβαλλοντική απόδοση
- Απόδοση Κυκλικής Οικονομίας
- Περιβάλλουσα ανάλυση δεδομένων
- Δείκτης Malmquist
- Ανάλυση δεδομένων πάνελ
- Εκτιμητής PCSE
- European Union
- Municipal solid waste generation and management
- Recycling rate
- Circular Material Use rate
- Gross domestic product
- Human Development Index
- Sustainable Society Index
- Social Progress Index
- Democracy
- Environmental performance
- Circular economy performance
- Data envelopment analysis
- Malmquist index
- Panel data analysis
- PCSE estimator
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Διαχείριση Τεχνολογίας και Καινοτομίας
- Περιβαλλοντική Μηχανική
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Διαχείριση και Διάθεση αποβλήτων
- Economics and Business
- Social Sciences
- Management of Technology and Innovation
- Environmental Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- Waste Management and Disposal
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/51315