University of Western Macedonia
Δημόσια ιστορία και περιοδικός τύπος "ιστορία εικονογραφημένη" (2008-2018): πρόταση εκπαιδευτικής αξιοποίησης του περιοδικού
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe Greek magazine "The Illustrated History " is a monthly public history magazine, which is published continuously from July 1968 until today. In the pre-research we identified the research gap for Greek public history magazines, while in Europe Doris Lechner (2017) research "Histories for the Many, The Victorian Family Magazine and Popular Representations of the Past. The Leisure Hour 1852-1870 ", Susanne Popp, Jutta Schumann, Miriam Hanning (2015), Commercialized History: Popular History Magazines in Europe» and Laurène Pain Prado (2010) "La question de l'histoire grand public. Étude comparée de deux magazines d’histoire: Historia et L’Histoire, 2004-2008» have already created a database about the history of public history magazines as sources and as a research object on public history.The qualitative and quantitative method was used for the research, collection, classification and analysis of the total material, which comes from the magazine, the interview, the school speech and the audience research.Our research is a case study, focusing on the semiotic triangle a) the magazine as the material, b) the transmitters (publishers, authors) and c) the receivers (indicative sample of readers). The thematic and semiotic analysis of the magazine is applied a) as a message, b) the magazine readership survey using questionnaires and c) the documentation of the magazine as a choice of public history by the publisher / transmitter.Specifically, it is recorded, classified and studied a) the visual and linguistic content of 132 covers of the period (2008-2018), period when the editorial direction has changed and issues of national public history in our country are activated, b) the content of 27 articles of the magazine, which concern the relationship of Greece with other nations, c) magazine readership survey and d) the contributors of the magazine (publisher, authors). Case study research through the database from previous studies, such as the European magazines that we identified in the pre-research, allows the understanding of complex topics. It can be considered as a powerful research method, especially when a holistic and in-depth investigation is required. Based on inductive reasoning we can develop hypotheses and find new relationships from one or more specific cases.The theoretical material that supports our questions and the collection, indexing and analysis techniques are drawn from the phenomenological and interpretive tradition of P. Ricoeur (1990), but also from the scientific objectivity in the challenge of postmodernism, as formulated by Iggers (1991).Conventionally and technographically we use the complex shape of the traditional / modern / post-modern model of historiography, in order to capture the historiographical direction of the magazine: Ranke's school promoted history as a positive science, leaders’ personalities and took for granted the clear meaning of sources, which could be reconstructed through literary analysis. On the contrary, for the new cultural history, the central institutions of the state have been shattered and the meaning of the texts/ sources is no longer transparent, but dotted with contradictions and ruptures. Then the postmodern tendency to eliminate the distinction between historical / scientific and fictional narrative has failed to invalidate the past as real, because we continue to rely complex and dialectically / interdisciplinary on a research logic.We understand that through the critique of traditional science/ historiography, we have been led to major revisions of historical thought and practice: in our study we attempt to see the history of historiography through a public history magazine as an evolving dialogue.Science presupposes a community of experts agreeing on research practices and forms of communication. Despite the differences, the boundaries between the traditional / modern / postmodern are intertwined in concentric circles, because a) the knowledge of the past remains in demand, b) the science of history retains the rationalizing role in order to ensure the collective memory, c) we accept the dialectical relationship between past and present and d) history, despite the postmodern challenge of narration, remains a science with strict methodological and analytical tools of documentation, argumentation, based on historical sources.The research methods and analytical tools that support our research come from the social sciences, such as the literature review, the interview, the semiotic-interpretive analysis, the qualitative and quantitative content analysis, the observation and the magazine readership survey. The research questions that we have to answer, in order to study a PH material in Greece, as it is expressed through media in the period (2008-2018) follow the research problem for the use of the magazine as a PH material and arise inductively from the material we collected as follows: a) what are the practices of PH, b) what are the characteristics of the public historical magazine press through the identity and the practices of the magazine "The Illustrated History", c) what kind of historical narrative is used from the magazine "The Illustrated History" on its covers, d) what kind of public discourse, e) what kind of historical illustration, f) what public discourse produces the magazine about the relation between Greece and other nations, g) what is the authors’ relationship with the science of history, h) what is the publisher’s criticism for the magazine "The Illustrated History" and i) what is the readers’ consumption of the magazine. The purpose of the research is to investigate the representations of public history selected by the first Greek popular history magazine (1968-present) as a cultural and ideological product.The novelty of the research is that it is the first comprehensive study of a Greek public history magazine and the application of interpretive, semiotic, qualitative and quantitative techniques, such as the construction of a semiotic tool for magazine’s cover analysis combining typologies of Burke (2003), Kress & Van Leeuwen (1996), Richards (1926), Morris (1971), Pleios (2001) and Iggers (1991) and the educational scenario in the context of Peace Education.The limitations of the research concern the lack of the magazine’s subscribers list, the absence of sales data of the magazine (both by ELSTAT and the "Argos" Press distribution agency) and the absence of bibliography for the History of the magazine, to which we have to contribute. We got the information about the public history magazines from the list of magazines of the National Library, from publishing houses and from the internet. In the area of these limitations, magazine readership survey captures only a small percentage of readers who have followed the magazine online the last decade.Finally, using the multimodality of the research material, images, sources, many authors, timeless themes, we propose an educational scenario as an interpretive proposal for the use of the Greek public history magazine together with a Turkish public history magazine in the educational process, which we utilized in primary education, entitled: "1453: Fall or Conquest?" and we also propose new topics for a postdoctoral analysis.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Western Macedonia
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Vasileiadis, Germanos
- Βασιλειάδης, Γερμανός
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Δημόσια ιστορία
- Εικονογραφημένα περιοδικά ιστορίας
- Ιστορική κουλτούρα
- Οπτικός/ιστορικός γραμματισμός
- Public history
- Illustrated history magazines
- Historical culture
- Visual/ historical literacy
- Ιστορία και Αρχαιολογία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Ιστορία
- History and Archaeology
- Humanities and the Arts
- History
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/51334