Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Μαθηματική μοντελοποίηση για την πρόβλεψη και την οικονομοτεχνική βελτιστοποίηση της ενεργειακής κατανάλωσης και αποδοτικότητας στον κτηριακό τομέα

Abstract

dc:description

The research in the PhD thesis focused on the development and computational construction of an energy economy model for the projection of energy consumption and energy efficiency in the buildings sector. The model conception aims to build a tool suitable for analysing ambitious energy efficiency policies and measures in detail as needed in achieving ambitious energy and climate targets in the long term. For the research in the PhD thesis, the arithmetic implementation of the model covered all European Union (EU) countries individually. The model’s data include segmentation of each country's residential and services sector buildings into many categories to represent the building and consumer classes differently. The detailed segmentation of the building stock, together with the discrete choice theory applied by the model to simulate investment decisions for energy efficiency in buildings, captures the heterogeneity of consumer choices and idiosyncratic behaviours that are inherent characteristics of energy demand in buildings. The modelling approach represents consumer behaviours regarding the optimal choice of technological equipment and the undertaking of energy-saving investments by considering engineering and economic constraints while in the presence of multiple barriers that impede and distort optimality behaviours. The systematic integration of barriers affecting optimal choices builds essentially on the theory of bounded rationality: asymmetric information, uncertainties and non-market barriers lead to apparently sub-optimal choices from an engineering perspective but are perfectly consistent from the individual’s perspective. In this manner, the model builds causality between policy instruments aiming to improve energy efficiency by acting on removing barriers and driving individuals closer to engineering optimality. Furthermore, capturing the idiosyncratic behaviours through the detailed segmentation of the buildings and consumers into many classes is also important for the accurate modelling of the way targeted policy instruments may effectively drive energy efficiency improvement. Finally, the use of discrete choice theory functional forms in the model also aims at capturing the heterogeneity of investment behaviours. The combination of the representation of barriers, the mathematical formulation and the detailed segmentation are the distinctive original features of the model proposed by the PhD research. The numerous numerical applications of the model have greatly helped to fine-tune the approach and test its robustness in policy analysis and impact assessment studies.The model splits the non-market barriers into real "hidden" costs and issues related to the access to capital resources and to elements that do not have a direct payable or “true” cost. The non-market barriers can broadly be split in three groups: (a) asymmetric information, (b) uncertainty about the financial and technical performance of investment options (including the high opportunity cost of equity and debt), and (c) regulatory uncertainty. The removal of uncertainty factors as well as the institutional measures have a dynamic evolution in the model: the more energy efficiency investments are undertaken, the more consumers realize the benefits of these investments, while at the same time there is technological development as a result of economies of scale and learning factors. In the modelling, the actively incentivizing policies not only provide the necessary economic incentives to trigger energy efficiency investments, but they also constitute conditions enabling the dynamic removal of non-market barriers. In this way the approach emphasizes the role of the state as a lever of growth, which in economic theory is supposed to achieve positive externalities. A detailed portrayal of policies specific to the building sector is included in the model, comprising economic and institutional policies and measures, that remove the barriers and improve consumers’ perception regarding the benefits of energy efficiency. The model also includes the regulatory obligations prescribed in the current legislation regarding the energy performance standards for new buildings (Energy Performance of Buildings Directive) and the minimum energy efficiency standards for energy equipment (Eco-Design Directive).Mathematically, the model solves a dynamic programming problem for energy efficiency investment decisions which is integrated into a mixed complementarity problem that represents the simultaneous achievement of maximum utility for the consumer and the achievement of the policy objectives regarding energy efficiency, CO2 emissions and renewables (RES). The latter is linked to the penetration of heat pumps as well as other RES technologies resulting from investment optimization. The formulation of investment decisions in the model is hierarchical and the choice of energy equipment for space heating and cooling depends on the energy renovation of the building envelope. In turn, the choices of energy equipment for space heating affect the choices for other thermal uses. The ambitious energy and climate targets that the EU had set in the short term and, most importantly, the EU's commitment to reach climate neutrality by 2050, imply that the entire energy system needs to undergo a substantial transformation. The results of the model from its application into various policy questions that all have in common the climate neutrality goal, can give an insight to policy makers on how to ensure a cost-effective, resilient and fair transformation of energy consumption in the buildings sector. The model results confirm that the removal of barriers to energy efficiency is of utmost importance for the transformation of energy consumption in the buildings sector. Economic and regulatory policies remove the non-market barriers, in addition to providing the right incentives or disincentives to mobilize the necessary investments in energy efficiency. Beyond that, institutional measures related to consumer information and knowledge can lead to an effective policy framework. The results of the model show that the intensity of policy measures is highly dependent on the assumptions about the removal of barriers to energy efficiency, which ultimately means that barriers to energy efficiency greatly influence consumer choices. Regarding alternative strategies that can lead to the substantial transformation of energy consumption in buildings, the results of the model show that the main pillars are the deep renovation of old buildings and the electrification of heating. The electrification of heating in particular is consistent with the improvement of the thermal performance of buildings and is, at the same time, a cost-effective choice. In fact, heat pumps consume electricity very efficiently and can contribute to the RES targets. The climate-neutral fuels (i.e., hydrogen, synthetic methane, and biogas), of course, contribute to the transition towards climate neutrality, but cannot be a substitute of energy efficiency. This is, not only because high uncertainty surrounds the evolution of the technologies that produce the synthetic fuels, but also because they are highly electricity-intensive and need excessively high RES power capacities. They would imply considerable stress for the power generation system, if developed as much as needed to meet today’s energy needs of the buildings without consideration of high energy efficiency improvement. Also, the uncertainty surrounding the development of the end-user prices of the climate-neutral fuels further underlies the importance of renovation of buildings in the context of the transition to climate neutrality, as renovations reduce energy bills making consumers less exposed to the uncertain development of the prices of climate-neutral fuels. The reduction of energy bills of households, in the context of the transition to climate neutrality, is definitely an advantage of the energy efficiency strategy. However, fundraising to renovate the housing stock towards reaching a “passive” house standard in the entire stock is a challenge, in particular for the majority of households with limited access to cash flow. Therefore, the policy strategy for energy efficiency requires appropriately designed instruments to subsidize investment and facilitate fundraising up to ensuring that all households can invest in energy efficiency. It is therefore of great importance to provide subsidies, especially to consumers with limited access to capital funding resources. The results of the model confirm the importance of subsidies to incite energy efficiency investments. However, the results also show that subsidies should be differentiated by income class because there is a large asymmetry between income categories related to investment possibilities. The subsidization policy should mitigate the social differences across consumer classes (as they can be calculated by the ratio of energy bills over income) for leveraging large energy-saving investments for the entire household sector. Therefore, the energy policy design must consider socio-economic differences across consumer classes. The model was also used to evaluate the application of regulatory policy instruments consisting of raising stringent energy efficiency standards for buildings. The analysis demonstrates the need to differentiate the level of the standard by type of building using several criteria to categorize the building types appropriately. The results, however, showed that the policy based on standards fails to effectively handle the limited fundraising possibilities of the various income categories. To this respect, an instrument based on standards is inferior compared to the policy based on subsidies. Combining standards with differentiated fundraising instruments is more cost-effective. However, it is impractical to differentiate the level of standards based on social criteria; nonetheless, this policy option has also been analyzed with the model, for research purposes. The PhD thesis identifies and analyzes topics for further research. Regarding the modelling approach, enhancing the representation of bounded rationality is an important, yet unexploited, research area. The enhancement would include an endogenous feedback effect of policies and investment accumulation on the parameters that represent the non-market barriers to energy efficiency, so as to close the loop of the dynamic adjustment process. Another area of further research is the simulation of the technical and economic possibilities of self-production of energy from RES, in combination with storage, energy efficiency and demand response, particularly for blocks of houses or buildings, together with dynamic participation in the power market. The model presented in the PhD thesis and its applications has been published in international scientific journals after peer review. The research has been funded by research programs and the model has been used in several applications to support impact assessment studies and analyses for Governments and the European Commission.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Fotiou, Theofano
  • Φωτίου, Θεοφανώ

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/51457

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Fotiou, Theofano; Φωτίου, Θεοφανώ. Μαθηματική μοντελοποίηση για την πρόβλεψη και την οικονομοτεχνική βελτιστοποίηση της ενεργειακής κατανάλωσης και αποδοτικότητας στον κτηριακό τομέα. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/51457