Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Ο αθέατος χαρακτήρας της ειδικής μαθησιακής αναπηρίας: διερεύνηση των προκλήσεων και προοπτικών φοίτησης σε ένα παιδαγωγικό τμήμα πανεπιστημιακής εκπαίδευσης

Abstract

dc:description

Certain disabilitiy types have a hidden character, thus they negotiate the liminal in-between space between ‘disabled’ and ‘nondisabled’. This fact leads to constrained perception of the challenges occuring in hidden or −else− invisible disabilities. Specific learning disability (SLD) is characterized by the above mentioned attributes. In order to shed light on the non-apparent characteristics of specific learning disability (SLD), the present study has illustrated the views, opinions and experiences of people with SLD, as well as those of their academic surrounding. Moreover, the choice of a Tertiary Pedagogical Education Department (PED) in Greece, as a case study, illuminates possible challenges and future percpectives for students with SLD.During the investigation of SLD in the present study, the ‘voice’ of adult people with SLD has been heard, as they have been generous in sharing their past and present experiences concerning SLD, the challenges in their academic student years and the future perspectives as graduates of an Education Department. At the same time, the opinions of university classmates, academic and administration staff, have been outlined, thus illustrating the conceptualization of SLD in the specific PED and practices applied around it.Via mixed methods (qualitative and quantitative methods), data have been collected from the following groups of people in the Pedagogical Department: students with SLD and without SLD, academic staff and administration staff, all of which offer the opportunity for triangulation of the findings. Qualitative methods include ten (10) interviews with students with SLD, fifteen (15) interviews with academic staff and sixty (60) hours of observation of the students with SLD. Quantitative methods include one hundrend sixty-five (165) questionnaires completed by third and fourth-year students and five (5) questionnaires completed by the administration staff. Content analyses of the interviews’ data along with descriptive and inferential statistics on the questionnaires’ data have been applied for the processing of the results.The results of the present study verify the worldwide challenge in defining SLD, which has elicited the use of various names (i.e. dyslexia, learning difficulty, dysorthographia, intellectual disability) by the participants in this study. The plethora of terms used by the participants bears testament to the dearth of a universally adopted term concerning specific learning challenges and confirm the need for a social approach of SLD. At the same time, the present study reflects differentiated opinions as far as a social approach on SLD is concerned. More specifically, students with SLD reject a social approach of SLD, disagreeing with the use of the term ‘disability’, as they feel that it should be used in more ‘severe’ cases. Meanwhile, the majority of the participants (87% of the 165 students, two administration staff members, nine students with SLD, three members of the academic staff) realize a medically centered conceptualization of SLD, leaving aside the educational impact of the issue and the fact that SLD falls under the special educational needs ‘umbrella’ according to the Greek Law (3699/2008). Thus, SLD lies in a ‘special matters’ sphere, after having been clearly influenced by the stereotypical ‘prevention and treatment’ approach. However, students with SLD themselves, aspire to define SLD as a positive trait by using terms such as the ‘gift of SLD’. In whole, their approaches wander between treatment, acceptance and invisiblity of SLD. As far as the label of SLD is concerned, there is remarkable confusion in the present study; on the one hand, the diagnosis of SLD is disputed, whereas, on the other hand, the same diagnosis results to be useful. The disputable diagnostic criteria or the high-grade chasing while obtaining a SLD diagnosis has been highlighted in the study by mouth of the academic staff and the students with SLD. At the same time, the latter seem to abide by the usefulness of such a diagnosis since it provides an explanation of their challenges, as well as a ‘ticket’ to oral examination. As far as the SLD diagnosis is concerned, in the present study, in the opinion of the academic staff diagnostic mechanisms leave the responsibility to experts, who always do their best to justify their professionalism in deciding for a type of diagnosis; simultaneously, diagmoses give the chance to educators to work with ‘homogenous’ student crowds, since students with diagnoses would have been excluded; this point of view is profound in the academic staff group, while the student groups seem to have a difficulty adopting this socially centered approach (in spite of the social approach of their studies’ subjects), probably due to stereotypical views on the role of a diagnosis. The diagnosis effects become known in the present study by mouth of students with SLD themselves since they have the experience of living with a SLD label. That said, remarkable is the fact that diagnosis and labelling have taken place during school years. Moreover, the academic staff appears to be sceptical, not only about the diagnostic criteria, but also about the mere fenomenon of SLD, especially since they observe learning challenges to all university students irrespectively of them having a SLD diagnosis or not. Academic staff sets the topic on a social basis, in terms of removing barriers and abandoning stereotypes concerning SLD. The present study also discusses the institutional policy of the PED. The PE Department has proved the PED to be a friendly department for students with SLD. As far as the educational policy of the department is concerned, students with SLD refer extensively to evaluation methods applied to the entirety of students in the Department, such as the application of differentiated assessment methods (i.e.multiple choice questions, right/wrong questions, oral examination) and objective grading regardless of spelling mistakes. Other study challenges that students with SLD refer to (taking notes, curriculum issues, the use of examples in lectures), endorse an administering approach of SLD by part of students with SLD; however, they wish that this would not discriminate them frorm other students. In any case, the academic staff from its part, highlights that no discriminations take place in the PED, as differentiated assessment is applied to all students; at the same time, they notice a generalization of learning challenges in all students irrespectively of them having a diagnosis or not, thus providing evidence for the difficulty in telling who has SLD and who doesn’t. The academic staff appears to be the main group in the study who critically considers SLD diagnosis and the increasing numbers of it. As far as academic provision is concerned, students with SLD receive support by the academic and administration staff, whenever needed. The main occasion for SLD disclosure seems to be semester examinations, a fact which suggests that support is strongly associated with evaluation, a familiar and quite dominating condition during the students’ school years. As academic staff mentions, SLD remains invisible in the PED, with exception examination circumstances when students may ask for oral examination or mark-grading irrespectively of their spelling mistakes.The PED students / future educators with SLD have personal experience of learning challenges and believe that this is a crucial educational practice which when applied could be beneficial for all their students. Accordning to their opinion, this kind of empathy is very possible as a direct result of their learning effort and psychological state they have been in, during their school years. Considering SLD as a special trait, students with SLD claim that their personal experience and empathy appear to be unique weapons in their hands –in comparison with other educators− when it comes to teaching students in the future. Neverhteless, this approach gives exclusively positive attributes to SLD, diverging from a social perspective of specific learning challenges.In general, the noticeable confusion around SLD terminology, the –at own will− acceptance of the SLD label, the existence and at the same time absence of academic challenges for students with SLD along with the rest of the PED students, the disputable barrier or booster of SLD in the future educational role of students – future professors with SLD, all manifest the hidden character of SLD in a Tertiary Pedagogical Educational Department.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Mousoura, Tatiani
  • Μούσουρα, Τατιανή

Subjects

dc:subject × 26

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/51589

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Mousoura, Tatiani; Μούσουρα, Τατιανή. Ο αθέατος χαρακτήρας της ειδικής μαθησιακής αναπηρίας: διερεύνηση των προκλήσεων και προοπτικών φοίτησης σε ένα παιδαγωγικό τμήμα πανεπιστημιακής εκπαίδευσης. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/51589