Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
Η νοσηλευτική πράξη στη μονάδα εντατικής θεραπείας: λήψη κλινικών αποφάσεων και σχέσεις εξουσίας
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn this doctoral dissertation I examine the world of the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) in a general hospital of Athens, and I specifically explore the type of “nursing praxis” produced by Greek ICU nurses in this "transitional" and "liminal” - technologically advanced - clinical environment. The study focuses on clinical decision-making and especially on the "rituals" or other practices by which ICU nurses intervene, sometimes successfully and sometimes less successfully, in order to participate, albeit mostly informally in the “margin” of this ICU, in clinical decision-making that nevertheless seems to still be mostly considered the responsibility of physicians.More specifically, I critically discuss not only the power relations in which the participants of the study are constructed as subjects, but also the sorts of meanings, representations and identities that arise and unfold in the cultural ethos of Intensive Care. This study falls within the realm of critical medical anthropology and phenomenology. Data were collected (produced) via long-term participant observation in a large public ICU and via semi-structured in-depth interviews with twenty (20) informants. The interviews were mostly conducted with experienced nurses. Interviews were transcribed, coded and analysed according to the thematic approach of Braun and Clarke."Routine", the strict scheduling of work and care in the ICU, emerges as a technology of discipline and a mechanism of (self-) control and (self-) supervision of the nursing staff in the ethnographic example. However, the "distinct" scientific and cultural ethos of Intensive Care activates to the maximum a discourse of care and knowledge on the part of the experienced ICU nurses, which in turn produces nursing praxis that is scientifically and culturally suitable for the severely ill patients. As an outstanding example of that routine, I examine the highly choreographed morning practice of “patient bedmaking” (the indigenous term in Greek is “στρώσιμο των αρρώστων”), which could be described as meticulous morning care and assessment of the patient in ICU. I argue that this “underrated” practice of patient care encompasses a lot more than simply “washing/bathing bodies” and “doing beds”. It has three characteristics: nurses are in total synch with patient care needs and clinical status whilst they get closer and enter the “polychronic” time dimension of the patient; it creates a safe "zone" of privacy where participants share experiences and feelings with each other and with their patients in safe conditions. It is a ritual which re-confirms the dominance of medical science through the technique of “disinfection" and “dirt removal”.The in-depth interviews look at the ICU nurses’ phenomenological experience of “caring”. Participants’ narratives demonstrate that ICU nurses develop a multi-sensorial somatic relationship with their patients, which in turn is characterized by "proximity" to their patient, a high sense of responsibility for their patient, empathy for their pain and trauma, and a unique ability to put in motion all available care and treatment modalities. In addition, fieldwork reveals that nurses are subjectified as embodiments of Intensive Therapy and Care, as the "ears" and "eyes" of doctors and patients at the bedside, as mediators between the patient and ICU technology, which renders the patients “transparent”, as “the experienced" ones in the heterotopia of the intershift verbal handover, as visible negotiators of care and treatment in the event of emergency and patient deterioration. However, they are also subjectified as the invisible or visible absent during routine medical rounds, where clinical decisions are reached by medical staff.In conclusion, the ICU nurses in this study, in their own bodily/embodied way, were found to settle power relations and strengthen – more or less successfully - their negotiating power towards the doctors by applying their specialist knowledge in practice. Nevertheless, they themselves continue to subjectify as “invisible” and informal clinical decision-makers, although they are rendering themselves even more "visible" via the somatic relation they establish with their patients. Therefore, they continue to be absent from the formal discourse and practices of clinical decision-making concerning the management of their cases. This particular finding constitutes a significant differentiation from similar studies at ICUs abroad.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Parissopoulos, Stylianos
- Παρισσόπουλος, Στυλιανός
Subjects
dc:subject × 44- Εντατική
- νοσηλευτική πράξη
- Κλινικές αποφάσεις
- Σχέσεις εξουσίας
- Νοσηλευτική
- Εθνογραφία
- Βιωμένη εμπειρία
- ρουτίνα
- Αναγνώριση ταυτότητας προσώπου
- Σώμα
- Ετεροτοπία
- αορατότητα
- εμπειρογνωμοσύνη
- Φροντίδα
- Νοσηλευτής
- Φαινομενολογία
- Ανθρωπολογία της υγείας
- Φουκώ, Μισέλ Πωλ
- Intensive care
- nursing praxis
- Nursing
- Critical care nurses
- Clinical decisions
- Power relations
- Expertise
- Lived experience of caring
- routine
- Discipline
- invisibility
- Identity
- Body
- Medical anthropology
- Phenomenology
- Embodiment
- Heterotopia
- Foucault, Michel Paul
- Άλλες Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Κοινωνικές επιστήμες, άλλοι τομείς
- Κοινωνικές επιστήμες, διεπιστημονική προσέγγιση
- Other Social Sciences
- Social Sciences
- Social sciences, miscellaneous
- Social sciences, interdisciplinary
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/51609