Back to search

University of Ioannina

Evolution and persistence of paedomorphosis in newts (Amphibia, Urodela)

Abstract

dc:description

Many salamandrid species exhibit paedomorphosis, a polyphenism in which sexually mature individuals retain larval external morphology, such as gill slits and external gills. Facultative paedomorphosis is an environmentally induced polyphenism and its manifestation can be predicted by fitness differences, where one morphotype might have greater fitness advantage over the other in the prevailing environmental conditions. The aim of this dissertation is to explore the underlying mechanisms on the expression and persistence of facultative paedomorphosis in newts. The study focuses on a natural population of the Greek smooth newt (Lissotriton graecus) exhibiting facultative paedomorphosis, and implements behavioral and ecological experiments, along with genetic tools (Chapters 2, 3 & 4). In addition, aim of this dissertation is to provide an estimate of the viability of the studied population on the long-term, along with the possible effects of different environmental stressors in the persistence of facultative paedomorphosis in newts (Chapters 5 & 6).Chapter 2 explores the proximate mechanisms of facultative paedomorphosis, by using body condition and reproductive components as fitness proxies. Fitness is a key concept in evolutionary biology where each given genotype or phenotype contributes differently to the gene pool of the next generation. More specifically, courtship behaviors and mating preferences were observed, along with egg production, larval development, and offspring viability of female newts, to explore potential fitness differences between the two phenotypes. The experiments showed that body size has a significant positive effect in fecundity. At the same time, paedomorphic female newts exhibited higher body condition than metamorphic females and produced more surviving larvae and had a better outcome in reproduction. Male newts did not show differences in body condition but showed preferences in courtship behavior towards paedomorphic female newts probable due to differences in fitness and higher abundances in the studied population.Despite the significance of phenotypic plasticity in the evolution and ecology of natural populations and the ongoing development of new genomic tools, the underlying genetic basis remains unresolved. Chapter 3 explores levels of genetic divergence between the two morphotypes by obtaining thousands of genetic markers through dd-RAD sequencing and provides insights into the underlying genetic mechanisms of facultative paedomorphosis. Based on the obtained SNP data, low genetic divergence between the two alternative morphotypes and similar levels of gene diversity on neutral markers were observed. Despite the observed high gene flow, an Fst approach for outliers detected candidate loci putatively associated with the alternative morphs that mapped to four genes. These identified genes have functional roles in metabolic processes, energy production and stress response. Utilizing the results of Chapter 2, where body size was found to be positively correlated with fecundity and the thousands of marker loci obtained through dd-RAD sequencing in Chapter 3, the aim of Chapter 4 was to explore the genetic basis of the quantitative phenotypic trait of body size and detect any heterozygosity-fitness correlations (HFCs) that may arise in the population. The results of the genome-wide association study identified loci highly associated with body size and revealed candidate genes putatively associated with epithelial cell proliferation. Cell proliferation, the increase in the number of cells, is an important factor from embryogenesis to tissue repair and growth and is regulated by complex mechanisms. Regarding levels of heterozygosity, I did not observe any correlation of fitness-related traits with genome-wide heterozygosity, however genotypic differences between the two morphotypes were observed in the identified genes that are correlated with body size.Paedomorphic population depend on both aquatic and terrestrial habitat and are prone to alterations of the environmental conditions. Chapter 5 aims to predict the extinction risk of the studied paedomorphic population, and to investigate the sensitivity of the paedomorphic phenotype to pond desiccation and fish introductions, that are considered as the most environmental stressful factors for newt populations. According to the population viability analysis, both these environmental factors lead to the extinction of the paedomorphic phenotype within the next 25 years, while sex-specific differences in the persistence of the paedomorphic morphotype were evident, with male newts metamorphosing earlier than females in stressful environmental conditions, probable due to differences in life history traits.In Epirus prefecture, NW Greece, several cases of facultative paedomorphosis occurrence have been recorded, while several lakes and ponds in the region have been stocked with fish for recreational fishing, rising concerns for the negative impacts to the paedomorphic populations. To this end, Chapter 6 aims to investigate and quantify the impact of the most invasive fish species, the eastern mosquitofish (Gambusia holbrooki), on paedomorphic newts as a result of direct physical disturbance and/or indirect modification of their behavior, and the effects on metamorphosis rate as well. Mosquitofish had a negative impact on paedomorphic newts by inducing both behavioral and phenotypic changes. Paedomorphic newts exhibited avoidance behavior and higher metamorphosis rates in the presence of fish. Both female and male newts responded by decreasing mobility and foraging activity, and females stopped investing in egg-laying. Such effects could have long-term detrimental consequences on reproductive success and contribute to the decline of focal populations.The combined results of the present study conform that facultative paedomorphosis remains as a polymorphism in the studied population and converge to the “paedomorphosis advantage hypothesis”, since paedomorphic female newts exhibit higher body condition and fecundity. Male newts are becoming choosier, and according to the courtship behavior experiment, it seems they choose female paedomorphs rather than metamorphs probably due to the fitness advantages and higher abundance in the population. Although, the lack of genetic differentiation conforms sexual compatibility between the alternative morphotypes, it strengthens the hypothesis that facultative paedomorphosis remains as a polyphenism to reduce intra-population competition.Additionally, the study offers valuable insights into the genetic basis of paedomorphosis, since the identified genes putatively associated with each morphotype have a significant role in energy production and stress response, important metabolic processes in phenotypic changes. At the same time, body size is an important fitness proxy and substantial differences were found between the two morphotypes. The identified genes and genetic variants associated with the quantitative trait of body size offer the possibility for further examination of genetic polymorphisms at the specific loci and their association with the different sizes observed in the Greek smooth newt.Lastly, the persistence of facultative paedomorphosis is prone to environmental changes, while introduction of alien fish species, specifically, has detrimental effects on paedomorphic newt populations leading to the extirpation of the alternative phenotype. Especially, in the region of Epirus, where several cases of paedomorphosis have been reported and is an important area for the conservation of alternative ontogenetic trajectories like paedomorphosis, it is necessary to plan effective management actions for the protection and the persistence of paedomorphic newt populations and their habitats.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Ioannina
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Toli, Elisavet -Aspasia
  • Τόλη, Ελισάβετ-Ασπασία

Subjects

dc:subject × 17

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/51635

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Toli, Elisavet -Aspasia; Τόλη, Ελισάβετ-Ασπασία. Evolution and persistence of paedomorphosis in newts (Amphibia, Urodela). University of Ioannina, 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/51635