Back to search

Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)

Χάσματα προσδοκιών ελέγχου αναφορικά με τις αρμοδιότητες των ορκωτών ελεγκτών στην πρόληψη, στον εντοπισμό και την αναφορά της απάτης

Abstract

dc:description

For the last fifty years, the business community has been suffering from a kind of “moral collapse syndrome” worldwide, when corporate frauds and their enormous consequences have a dominant role (Albrecht et al., 2015). The great financial scandals of the early 21st century have paid attention to fraud prevention, detection and reporting and have brought the auditing profession to the forefront as never before, reopening the debate on the role and responsibilities of public auditor (European Commission, 2010, 2011· IAASB 2020), in a period of financial crisis and the collapse of confidence in the auditing profession (Hogan, et al., 2008· Humphrey et al., 2011· Smith, 2015· IAASB 2020). Despite the strong regulatory framework around the auditing profession, as well as the various actions over time by professional organizations and supervisors, academic and professional research worldwide shows that society's expectations for the role of audit remain broad (Humphrey et al., 2011), especially in the area of fraud (IAASB, 2020). As long as the existence of expectations gaps is not limited, society's trust in the audit profession will be undermined and the audit profession will become worthless (Porter & Gowthorpe, 1999).The present study investigated and examined the possible existence, as well as the extent of the audit expectations gap, focusing on the area of financial statement fraud, in a European country and specifically in Greece, in a period of severe economic recession, corporate failures-accounting scandals and changes in the regulatory framework and other initiatives of the European Union and professional bodies. At the same time, adopting the Porter model (1993), it sought to study the phenomenon in depth, in its components (deficiency performance, deficient standards and reasonableness gap), but also to enlighten the contributing factors of creation, proposing ways and packages of action to reduce it.For this purpose, quantitative and qualitative methods of data collection were used (questionnaire and semi-structured interviews), focusing on gathering the perceptions / opinions of groups of participants and in particular public auditors, executives/management of listed companies, bank executives and representatives of Law enforcement and judicial authorities, for a better understanding of the phenomenon.The results of this study, demonstrate that phenomenon of audit expectation gap, focused on the area of fraud, not only exists in Greece, but is also quite widespread.Deficient performance gaps were identified in the definition of fraud and its consequences, in the detection of fraud committed individually and having a significant impact on the financial statements, in the further investigation of suspected fraud and in particular in cases of management fraud with unknown implications in the accounts, in the obligations of public auditors to report: a) in their report cases of fraud with a significant impact on the accounts, b) on a case-by-case basis to management administration and/or those responsible for governance (audit committee) cases of fraud without significant impact on the accounts, but also cases of fraud that may not have a significant impact on the accounts, but appropriate measures were not taken by management, c) cases of fraud and money laundering, with a significant impact on the accounts and finally, regarding the liability of public auditors in cases of fraud that were not identified during the audit due to their own fault (unawareness, negligence, wiliness).Deficient standards gaps were found in relation to the include in their report any and each case of fraud, without significant impact on the accounts, in informing their supervisory authority (E.L.T.E.), for cases of fraud with significant or no impact on the accounts, with or without actions of the management, in informing the society (beyond their report) e.g. through special reports, newsletters, etc., for cases of fraud, with or without a significant impact on accounts-cases of fraud and general financial crimes related to money laundering and for cases of unethical business practices, within the legal framework, and finally in the situation of resignation of the audit when the fraud has not been properly dealt with by the management, and in particular for fraud with a significant or non-significant impact on the accounts, either the management or employees involved.Reasonableness gaps were identified in the detection of fraud, which was committed in collaboration with two or more persons and has significant impact on the accounts, but also cases of fraud either individually or in collaboration with two or more persons, without significant impact on the accounts, and finally on their responsibility for any fraud that was not detected during the audit.Among the identified expectation gaps, most important based on the extent and the level of participants’ consensus are considered the identification of any fraud committed individually, with a significant impact on the accounts, the reference to both their report and their supervisory authority, and to society and third parties with specific reports or other newsletters, cases of fraud without significant impact, as well as cases of unethical business practices within the legal framework, and finally the detection of fraud committed with the cooperation of two or more persons that has a significant impact on the accounts, but also with the cooperation of two or more persons or individually, without significant impact on the accounts.Examining the views of participants between them, but also individually in relation to the views of the public auditors, significant differences were found. In the vast majority of responses, the views of managers were closer to those of auditors. On the contrary, the representatives of LEAs and prosecuting / judicial authorities had very high expectations, believed much than public auditors, but also when compared to the other participants (managers and bank executives), that both the performance and the standards / legislation should be significantly improved in order to better meet the requirements / expectations of the society, but also their expectations based on their professional role. In many cases these expectations were unreasonable due to the lack of financial and accounting knowledge but also the missing knowledge of role and purpose of an audit. Finally, bank executives appeared to have higher expectations than management, but lower than LEAs and prosecuting/judicial authorities, influenced by their professional role, seeking on financial statements’ reliability, in order to better evaluate and ultimately making more reliable decision-making regarding potential corporate funding/lending.Examining the influence of specific demographics on participants' responses, themes needed further investigation where the differentiation and perception of how fraudulent situations are handled in relation to the size of audit firm (Big 4 or not), but also issues of experience and similar knowledge of the management in understanding the consequences of the fraud, but also in the better understanding audit and auditor’s role.The study identified as an important issue, the major influence of the corporate, social, but mainly the financial environment in Greece (deep economic crisis) were factors that greatly affect the audit quality and consequently the auditor’s role. The Greek corporate institutional framework and the characteristics of the corporate environment, in combination with the social and financial conditions (economic recession, accounting fraud, lack of culture of ethics and social values), but also with the state policy that is in force, including the relevant prevention mechanisms, intervention and supervision, shape and influence to a large extent the existence and the extent of the phenomenon of audit expectation gap, especially in fraud area.Investigating the most important contributing factors of occurrence and maintenance of audit expectation gap, based on importance and consensus, the study showed the following causes:1. the unreasonableness expectations of the users of the financial statements and society, due to lack of knowledge for audit purpose and auditor’s role as well as management/ those in charge of governance responsibility, 2. the economic and social conditions of the environment and the state and business culture and corporate ethical values, 3. the lack of audit independence, 4. the inadequacy of the state/supervisory authorities and the transfer of responsibilities to public auditors,5. the delays in the establishment of a regulatory framework and the lack of specialized directives, 6. the lack of technical capacity and knowledge of the auditors themselves in matters of fraud, 7. the difficulty of understanding the language of the audit report combined with the lack of financial and accounting knowledge of the users of the financial statements and 8. the audit fees.Finally, in order to reduce, if not solve it, taking into account the gaps of expectations that the research identified, but also the causes of its occurrence, the present study proposes as strategies: 1. educating / informing all users of financial statements and society about the role and responsibilities of public auditor in general, but also in particular in matters of fraud prevention, detection and reporting, in conjunction with relevant information on the role and responsibility of the management / those in charge of governance, 2. issues of remuneration and other expenses of the audit and of course the issues of providing non-audit services, 3. the establishments, firstly, state’s ethical culture and secondly corporate culture, with the activation of corporate governance related institutions and principles and the effective adoption and operation of corporate governance rules, in order to create an environment of effective oversight, transparency, and ethical culture,4. the most effective supervision of quality of audit work, including supervisory authority’s (E.L.T.E.) “upgrade”, with adequate staffing and the existence of the necessary resources (financial / technological infrastructure, etc.), but also strengthening the cooperation with other supervisory and state authorities,5. the improvement of the legal framework and on time issuing relevant regulatory decisions and directions / instructions, especially in cases of fraud, tax evasion, money laundering and the corresponding actions of further informing the competent authorities, 6. the improvement of the audit report regarding the language and the information included, such as the level of materiality or specific areas audited, etc., especially in reports where the auditor's opinion differs and/or emphasis issues identified, 7. the independent mechanism for identified the audit fees, based on specific characteristics (such as industry activity, the structure, the turnover of the company, etc.), 8. the education and professional training of public auditors in matters of fraud and other specific financial crimes,9. the education of users of financial statements and society in general, mainly in economics, financial and accounting principles, and most important for government officials, such as LEAs and prosecutors/judges, who play an essential role in the investigation of corporate fraud.The results and proposals of the present study seek to be the basis, but also the trigger for further research initiatives. Several questions and issues arose which demonstrates the need for additional research studies to be undertaken in this area.Despite the limitations of the research, its results could be very useful to the supervisory authorities (E.L.T.E., Hellenic Capital Market Commission, etc.), to other state / prosecuting / judicial authorities and the legislator, to the auditing profession, but also in its professional organizations, and finally in the scientific and academic community for further investigation of the phenomenon, in a period of intense discussions and initiatives to reduce the phenomenon (IAASB, 2020).

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB)
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Papastergiou, Konstantinos
  • Παπαστεργίου, Κωνσταντίνος

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/51647

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Papastergiou, Konstantinos; Παπαστεργίου, Κωνσταντίνος. Χάσματα προσδοκιών ελέγχου αναφορικά με τις αρμοδιότητες των ορκωτών ελεγκτών στην πρόληψη, στον εντοπισμό και την αναφορά της απάτης. Athens University Economics and Business (AUEB), 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/51647