University of Patras
Συγκριτική μελέτη της οστεοτομίας Weil με τριπλή οστεοτομία Weil για την αντιμετώπιση της μεταταρσαλγίας: εμβιομηχανική και κλινική μελέτη
Abstract
dc:descriptionIntroduction Surgical treatment of metatarsalgia has been controversial for decades and more than 25 different techniques have been described until today. Initially, the lack of clear distinction between the different types of metatarsalgia led to the use of the same procedure for all cases. Consequently, in many cases the unpredictable shortening or elevation of the entire ray or even the non-union led to poor results, either due to the fact that these techniques were applied incorrectly or due to their endogenous instability. During the 1990s, the definition of different types of metatarsalgia according to the rocker concept during gait cycle and a better understanding of the forefoot’s biomechanics, helped to improve the enforcement of indications for the use of different procedures depending on the type of metatarsalgia.The Weil osteotomy first described by L.S. Weil in Chicago in 1985, and originally applied in Europe by the French orthopaedic surgeon S. Barouk, due to the simple surgical technique, in combination with the high rates of union and the predicted results which brings, it quickly became popular in the orthopaedic community and became the most frequently used procedure in the treatment of third-rocker or propulsive metatarsalgia. However, Weil osteotomy does not deprive of complications, with the floating toe being the most important complication. In 1998, E. Maceira described the triple Weil osteotomy, based on the observation that the plantar displacement of the metatarsal head, as a result of the Weil osteotomy, is the primary cause of the floating toe. With this modified technique, the Spanish orthopaedic surgeon attempted to achieve a controlled and coaxial with the shaft shortening of the metatarsal with simultaneous elevation of the head, with final goal to discharge the affected ray in patients with third-rocker metatarsalgia and in some selected cases of second-rocker metatarsalgia. Metatarsophalangeal dislocations of propulsive origin (not neurological origin) can be addressed by this technique, avoiding the need for additional soft-tissue or tendon transfers. The technique requires longer surgical times in comparison with the osteotomy Weil and has a higher risk of delayed union or non-union. Because of its oblique character and smaller contact surface, the triple Weil osteotomy is less stable than the original technique. The fixation is compromised by the more vertical-oriented osteotomy line, and it is not possible to run the screw perpendicular to the cut.Purpose The present doctoral thesis consists of two parts: an experimental one and a clinical one. During the cadaveric study, three experiments were performed. The ultimate goal was to determine the potential advantage of the triple Weil osteotomy over the Weil osteotomy, in terms of avoiding the floating toe. Taking into account the etiology of this complication, the change of the metatarsophalangeal joint’s center of rotation will have as a result the change of the position of the tendons of the interosseous muscles, which will lose their normal act, and they will turn to extensors from flexors of the metatarsophalangeal joint. Thus, the aim of the three comparative study on cadavers was to determine the change of the metatarsophalangeal joints’ center of rotation after both the Weil and the triple Weil osteotomies and to investigate the role of the change of the interosseous muscles’ position, as well as the role of the relaxation of the plantar plate in the pathogenesis of floating toe.The purpose of the clinical comparative retrospective study was to evaluate the functional results and determine the complications of the two types of osteotomies, through a series of patients who underwent surgery due to third rocker biomechanical metatarsalgia.Material and MethodsA total of 21 fresh-frozen cadaveric feet were utilized in experimental study. All feet had been amputated from patients who were hospitalized at the University General Hospital of Patras and at the General Hospital of Ilia, N.U. of Pyrgos, because of a circulatory disorder. Subsequently, a Weil osteotomy was performed at half of the feet, and a triple Weil osteotomy at the rest ones.At the first experiment a geometrical analysis was used in order to determine the center of rotation of the MTP joint. Thus, before and after performing each of the two osteotomies, the initial and final center of rotation of the metatarsophalangeal joint and, therefore, the change of position of the metatarsal head in relation to the diaphyseal longitudinal axis were also determined, through selected coordinated points in views taken with the use of C-arm. The position of the tendons of the interosseous muscles was also controlled.At the second experiment a part of the plantar plate equal to 3 mm was removed and the central and peripheral stumps were then sutured with non-absorbable sutures 2.0. The feet were mounted in self-made constructed loading frame, which allowed the application of vertical upward forces on the second MTP joint, through the pneumatic valve actuator. Three load cycles were applied to each ray. In each loading cycle it was possible to calculate the upward movement of the metatarsophalangeal joint, equal to 8 mm (distance corresponding to the point of subluxation of the MTP joint, which would be clinically relevant yet non-destructive).At the third experiment the hallux was disarticulated at the level of the first metatarsophalangeal joint and the feet were divided into two groups. In the first group A the Weil osteotomy was performed at the second ray, while in the second group B the triple Weil osteotomy was performed at the second ray, respectively. The feet were mounted in a self-made constructed frame, which allowed the application of an axial load to the distal tibia, through a metal rod connected to a central electric linear actuator. The arrangement of the feet on the support platform of the frame allowed the free plantar flexion of the second metatarsophalangeal joint. In conditions which simulate normal load, a series of measurements with whole the tendons of the dorsal interosseous muscles, was realized. Then, the tendons of these muscles at the level of the metatarsal neck, were excised and the measurements were repeated. Using a portable radiography machine lateral x-rays were realized. In all views, the extension angle of the second MTP joint was evaluated.A total of 71 patients were initially included in the clinical study. After the separation of the patients according to the type of metatarsalgia, only those patients with biomechanical metatarsalgia were finally studied (a total of 44). The remaining patients were excluded from the study. The presence of previous surgery was a further exclusion criterion. The average age at the time of surgery was 58 years (range between 23 and 72). After the failure of conservative treatment for six months, all patients suffered from biomechanical metatarsalgia, who clinically presented a large and diffuse area of hyperkeratosis which spans several heads, underwent surgery by the same surgical team. Therefore, a total 62 (26 right and 33 left) feet were studied. A total of 90 osteotomies were performed. When, according to the preoperative planning, a shortening smaller than or equal to 3 mm was required, a simple Weil osteotomy was performed. About shortening bigger than 3 mm, however, a triple Weil osteotomy was performed. Therefore, two groups of patients were formed: the Weil osteotomy group (group A) and the triple Weil osteotomy group (group B). The mean follow-up was 24 months (range between 5 and 48). The AOFAS score was used for the assessment of the functional result, while the pain was assessed using the VAS scale.ResultsUsing the fluoroscopy and taking into account the geometrical analysis of both the Weil and triple Weil osteotomies we noticed that the metatarsophalangeal joint’s center of rotation after the Weil osteotomy is displaced proximally and plantarly by an average of 3.5±1.64 mm compared to the center of rotation in the control group, and by an average of 3.7±1.52 mm compared to the center of rotation in the triple Weil osteotomy group. In both cases, the numerical values indicate a statistically significant difference (p<0.05). Furthermore, the center of rotation in the triple Weil osteotomy group was proximally and plantarly displaced, equal to 0.817±0.12 mm on average, relative to the center of rotation in the control group. However, this difference was not statistically significant. Using a Kirschner wire as a guide for the position of the tendons of the interosseous, before and after the Weil osteotomy, and comparing the two positions with fluoroscopy, we noticed that after the Weil osteotomy the guide wire was above the metatarsal longitudinal axis. Repeating the same procedure in the case of triple Weil osteotomy, the position’s change of the guide wire does not present a statistically significant difference with respect to the position of the guide wire in control group.The analysis of the data of the second experiment showed that in the group A (Weil osteotomy + shortening of the plantar plate) the average the required vertical force for upward displacement of the 2nd metatarsophalangeal joint equal to 8 mm from the balance position was equal to 37±0.12 Newtons, while in group B (triple Weil osteotomy + shortening of the plantar plate) the average of the force was equal to 46±1.5 Newtons. During the three loading cycles in each studied ray, the comparison of the percentage changes of the vertical force applied at the second MPT joint, showed a statistically significant difference equal to with 27±11% (p <0.05) between the control group and the group A. This is the case after the same observation done from the comparison of the values between the groups A and B, where the difference was equal to 25±13% (p <0.05). On the contrary, this is not the case after the comparison of the forces between the control group and the group B.The data’s statistical analysis of the third experimental showed that in the control group, the mean average of the extension angle of the second metatarsophalangeal joint was 27.83o±1.39o under normal load simulation conditions. After the Weil osteotomy which shortened the second ray by 5 mm (group A), passive plantar flexion ceased to be observed, as the mean average of the extension angle in the measurements under axial loading increased to 44.33o±1.79o. In the group B, the mean average of the extension angle after the respective measurements was equal to 31.66o±1.41o, approaching closer to the average of the extension angle in the control group. After the excision of the tendons of the interosseous in the second ray undergoing Weil osteotomy the passive plantarflexion of the second metatarsophalangeal joint is observed to increase slightly. On the other hand, the passive plantarflexion of the metatarsophalangeal joint in which a triple Weil osteotomy was performed with concomitant excision of the interosseous is reduced statistically, both in relation to the passive flexion of the same joint before the resection of the tendons of the interosseous and compared with the passive flexion in the control group.Regarding the results of the clinical retrospective study, in the group A, preoperatively, the average AOFAS score was 51/100. In the same group, postoperatively, the average AOFAS score was 89/100. In the group B, the corresponding values were 50/100, preoperatively, and postoperatively 93/100. In the group A, the mean preoperative VAS score was 7.8/10, while the mean postoperative VAS score was 1.3/10. The corresponding values in the group B were 8.2/10 and 1.7/10, respectively. In the group A, 78% of patients had an excellent or good result, 17% had a moderate result and 5% an unsatisfactory one. In the group B, 76% of patients presented an excellent or good result, 21% presented a moderate result and 3% an unsatisfactory one. Concerning the complications in the group A was notified: moderate or severe dorsal stiffness (60.9%), floating toe (28.3%) and recurrence of metatarsalgia (7.3%). Ηowever, it is worth noting that, in the group A, half of the patients who developed a floating toe, in the last follow-up had an AOFAS score > 80. In the group B the complications were: superficial infection (25.6%), delayed union (15.9%), floating toe (6.8%), recurrence of metatarsalgia (2.5%) and a case of Sudeck syndrome.ConclusionsFrom the cadaveric experiments studies it is concluded that it is impossible to complete the Weil osteotomy plantarly with an orientation of the blade less than 25o with respect to the metatarsal diaphysis. As the average value of inclination of the second metatarsal is 15o, it would be impossible to perform the Weil osteotomy parallel to the weigh bearing surface and in the second metatarsal the final inclination of the osteotomy would be 10o at minimum. This inclination predicts a plantarflexion effect of the osteotomy which would increase with bigger proximal displacement. Thus, the proximal displacement of the metatarsal head after a Weil osteotomy, lead to the change in location of the interosseous muscles in relation to the metatarsal longitudinal axis. The dorsal displacement of the tendons of the interosseous muscles relative to the center of rotation of the metatarsophalangeal joint results in weakness or elimination of their normal plantarflexory action.The pathogenesis of floating toe, however, seems more complex. Several authors agree that the occurrence of these complication after a distal metatarsal shortening osteotomy, in addition to the dorsal deviation of the tendons of the interosseous relative to the center of rotation of the metatarsophalangeal joint, is also due to a significant extent to the relaxation of the plantar soft tissues. During the third rocker of gait, this relaxation lead to a deficit of the inverted windlass mechanism and, therefore, to the incapacity of the toe to make contact with the ground. We conclude that shortening of the metatarsals by means of a distal lesser metatarsal osteotomy causes an indirect soft tissues relaxation which leads to deficit of the action of the plantar plate over the metatarsophalangeal joint. The deficit of the inverted windlass mechanism increases the risk of floating toe. This risk is further increased in the case of Weil osteotomy due to the dorsal displacement of the interosseous muscles in relation to the metatarsophalangeal joint’s axis. This is not the case, for the triple Weil osteotomy, since the preservation of the normal action of the interossei on the metatarsophalangeal joint achieves significantly to balance the reduced flexion torque on behalf of the plantar plate.In conclusion, that both Weil osteotomy and triple Weil osteotomy are effective procedures in the surgical treatment of patients suffered by third rocker metatarsalgia. The risk of floating toe is higher with the Weil osteotomy, and especially increases when a shortening bigger than 3 mm is required in order to restore the harmonic type of the distal metatarsal parabola. Therefore, to avoid this complication, the triple Weil osteotomy is preferred in these cases. In both osteotomies, the correct preoperative planning, which must be done on weight-bearing x-rays, is of paramount importance for the outcome. Furthermore, in the appearance of the dorsal stiffness of the metatarsophalangeal joint, the healing of the surgical wound and also of the soft tissues have an important role.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Bougiouklis, Dimitrios
- Μπουγιουκλής, Δημήτριος
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- μεταταρσαλγία
- οστεοτομία Weil
- τριπλή οστεοτoμία
- αιωρούμενος δάκτυλος
- Εμβιομηχανική
- μεσόστεοι μύες
- metatarsalgia
- Weil osteotomy
- triple osteotomy
- floating toe
- Biomechanics
- interosseous muscles
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Ορθοπεδική και Αθλιατρική
- Ιατρική Βιοτεχνολογία
- Clinical Medicine
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Orthopedics and Sports Medicine
- Medical Biotechnology
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/51653