Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Spatial planning and architectural design for the integration of civil infrastructure into landscapes: inferences from renewable energy works and dams

Abstract

dc:description

The case of renewable energy (RE) has demonstrated that the integration of civil infrastructure into landscapes can be a major challenge. Negligence over impacts to natural and cultural characteristics of landscapes and marginalization of communities affected by those impacts, can lead to a vicious cycle of public unrest and developmental disorder. In this work, we initially investigate how civil infrastructure transforms landscapes, both quantitatively-spatially and qualitatively-perceptually. Then, utilizing the results of this investigation we proceeded with proposing upgrades to spatial planning and architectural design of infrastructure, aiming for its improved integration into landscapes. The study goes into more detail in the study of wind, solar, hydroelectric energy works and dams but the inferences drawn refer to all major infrastructure works. The analysis is structured in three hierarchical levels of analysis in gradually decreasing spatial scales: (A) Global scale – Comparative assessment of the generic landscape impacts of different types of infrastructure works: Stakeholders in the development of infrastructure are often uncertain about whether landscape impacts are a genuine and objective issue or whether they should be attributed to biased NIMBY (not in my back yard) dispositions by the public. This uncertainty eventually conflicts with the development of optimal design methods for the mitigation of impacts. For this reason, our analysis initiates with an investigation of whether the extents and the severity of landscape impacts of different types of infrastructure can be generically and objectively quantified and compared. RE works were analysed in detail in this regard, utilizing literature and data from realized projects, from global sources. Three established metrics of landscape impacts were elected as insightful indicators of landscape impacts: land use, visibility and public perception. Through the investigation of these metrics, it was demonstrated that wind energy works have been, on average, the most impactful to landscapes, per unit energy generation, followed by solar photovoltaic projects and hydroelectric dams, respectively. More broadly, it was concluded that different types of infrastructure indeed have different generic landscape impacts and therefore different mitigation approaches are suitable in each case. These approaches are highly dependent on: (i) whether the examined infrastructure-type is perceived negatively by the public, within landscapes, (ii) the spatial extents of its visual impacts and land-use requirements and (iii) its receptivity or not of architectural treatment. (B) National-regional scale - Improving spatial planning for landscape integration: In this scale, emphasis is given on the treatment of types of infrastructure works that receive strong criticism over their visual impacts. So far, visibility analysis has been established as the primary tool that informs the siting of projects, in order to reduce their visibility from within scenic landscapes. However, conventional visibility analyses have limited utility as a planning tool as they can only be applied in late planning stages when project's locations have already been finalized. This is due to the fact that they require those locations as input. Therefore, we propose reversing visibility analyses by using the locations of protected landscape elements as the input of visibility analyses. This methodological shift allows for the generation of fixed landscape-protection maps surrounding important landscape elements which enjoy the advantages of: (i) proactiveness, as they can be used to anticipate landscape impacts from earlier planning stages, before projects' locations have been finalized, (ii) time-saving, as they only need to be calculated once within a region or country, discarding the requirement for individual visibility analysis for each new project and (iii) better compatibility with participatory planning processes. The implementation of reverse visibility analysis was investigated in practice, in the region of Thessaly, Greece, where Reverse – Zone of Theoretical Visibility (R-ZTV) maps were formed and then used to project visual impacts from planned wind energy projects to the protected landscape elements of the region.(C) Project's site scale – The utility and potential of architectural and landscape design: In this scale, we investigated the utility of architectural treatment of infrastructure, in the context of mitigating their landscape impacts. To this aim, we formulated a typology of global practices of architectural and landscape design in dams and investigated them from a cost-benefit perspective. The investigation demonstrated that the implementation of architectural and landscape design (i) can measurably improve the public perception of infrastructure and (ii) that there are no insurmountable technical or cost-associated limitations to its wider implementation. It is thus overall argued that architectural and landscape design studies could and should be implemented more widely in the infrastructure projects that are capable of such treatment.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Ioannidis, Romanos
  • Ιωαννίδης, Ρωμανός

Subjects

dc:subject × 57

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/52025

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Ioannidis, Romanos; Ιωαννίδης, Ρωμανός. Spatial planning and architectural design for the integration of civil infrastructure into landscapes: inferences from renewable energy works and dams. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/52025