Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Η έννομη προστασία της πνευματικής ιδιοκτησίας στο πεδίο του ιδιωτικού δικαίου

Abstract

dc:description

The object of the study is the legal protection of intellectual property in the field of private law.It is clear that a key pillar of the concept of intellectual property is its protection because without it the development of intellectual activity is not possible, as the existence of a capable framework for direct and effective assertion lays the foundation for the substantial realization of rights. The thesis consists of five Chapters and the Conclusions/Final Remarks . In the First Chapter entitled "Introduction to the protection of intellectual property" the purpose and peculiarities of intellectual property are analyzed, the difficulty of protection due to the nature of the work is emphasized, a general approach is made to protection at the international level especially with the TRIPS Agreement and in the EU level primarily with Directive 2004/48 which, together with regulation 44/2001, constituted the first pieces of legislation at the European level which sought to regulate in a unified manner the issues affecting the procedural law area in which until now there had been no interventions at the level of the European Union . The importance of certain provisions of Directive 2004/48 and in particular the provisions on temporary and conservative measures is highlighted, as well as the evidence with parallel reference to the provisions of Law 2121/1993 and of the Civil Code. It is worth noting that for the first time we have the reduction of injunctive measures to an autonomous system of protection with a derogation from the principle of the urgency of the procedure (688 Civil Code).In the Second Chapter entitled "Infringement of copyright" the concept of the work, the infringement, the defense, the rules for the distribution of the burden of proof, the conditions for the removal of the infringement and its omission, as well as specific issues of procedural law are analyzed . In the analysis of the concept of insult, the relevant definition is given, civil protection refers to the exclusive and absolute rights which are defined by the provisions of Law 2121/1993 (property and moral) and which, precisely because of their nature, are directed at all. In the section on the subject of the offense it is pointed out that the offended party is usually the creator or the right holder, while the offending party can be any third party who interferes with their powers without permission or relevant right. In order for the author's action to provide protection consisting in the removal of the infringement and the omission to be certain, it is sufficient for the plaintiff to invoke the actual event of the creation of the work, the possible identity or similarity between the two works, when the infringement consists of copying or modification of his work and the offending action/behaviour of the defendant. For the existence of a legal interest to initiate a declaratory action, it is emphasized that the right must be challenged by the person against whom it is directed. In the event that the plaintiff has a legal interest, to raise a negative recognition action, with which he requests to recognize that the defendant has no rights to the work, the burden of proof is reversed and the defendant will be obliged to prove that he is the creator or beneficiary. The distribution of the burden of proof is analyzed based on the fair compensation/reasonable remuneration provided for in article 5 par. 2 item b of Directive 2001/29, as well as in article 18 par. 3 of Law 2121/1993. The analysis for the presumptions of Article 7 of Law 4481/2017 is detailed and it is argued that collective management or protection organizations are entitled to request judicial protection, either as entitled parties, when property rights were transferred to them, or as non-entitled parties, when it was provided to them power of attorney. In the section on procedural law issues, Brussels Regulation Ia 1215/2012 on international jurisdiction, recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters, which applies to cross-border intellectual property cases of a civil and commercial nature, is examined.In the Third Chapter entitled "The protection of intellectual property rights in the domestic legal order" an analysis is made of the protection of intellectual property rights at the national level with reference to articles 63 A , 64 and 65 of Law 2121/1993, as well as the provisions of the Civil Code to which the above articles often refer, which followed the structure of the TRIPS Agreement and Directive 2004/48. Regarding provision 63 A par. 1 of Law 2121/1993 and in particular with regard to the claim to present evidence controlled by the opposing party, the opinion is expressed that this is an important innovation in the context of the procedural treatment of infringements of intellectual property. With the possibility of issuing an order against the defendant for the production of evidence that is in his possession by resorting to procedures shorter than those provided for in the Code of Civil Procedure, the aim is to prevent risks of thwarting the protection of the beneficiaries of intellectual property rights, due to the evidence inequality or asymmetry. The claim derives from the individual procedural right to evidence based on article 20 paragraph 1 of the Constitution and article 6 paragraph 1 of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights. In contrast to the EU acquis which does not regulate the consequences of the opposing party's reluctance to comply, article 63A par. 5 of Law 2121/1993 provides that, if the party is summoned and unreasonably fails to provide the evidence, the corresponding allegations to be proved of the party are considered confessed. Article 64 of Law 2121/1993 is examined in the injunctive measures and protective evidence section and the opinion is expressed that this regulation is not unconstitutional. The regulation of paragraph 1 of article 64 of Law 2121/1993 aims to secure and preserve the evidence of the violation of rights through the conservative confiscation or the detailed inventory and photography of the objects in question, in order to prevent the possibility of their disappearance and not to secure of the creator's claim against the infringer . The provisions of article 64 par. 3 and 4 are then analyzed which provide for the granting of regulatory injunctions, the preventive seizure or judicial bailment of the goods as well as the imposition in cases of offenses on a commercial scale of preventive seizure at the expense of the defendant 's assets . The provision of paragraph 2 of article 64 of Law 2121/1993 which allows the non-specification of projects that are threatened with infringement or are being insulted. Similar is the regulation of article 7 par. 2 of 4481/2017 according to which for the judicial pursuit of the protection of works and creators protected by the organization of collective management or protection. In the section on the compulsory satisfaction of intellectual property rights, reference is made to essential issues, in particular the removal of the infringement, the request to confiscate illegal copies, the amount of the fine, the conditions for imposing compulsory confiscation according to article 1022 of the Civil Code and the conservative confiscation of special assets.In the Fourth Chapter entitled "Infringement of intellectual property rights in the digital environment" the infringement in the digital environment is analyzed. The new digital environment has created new risks for the interests of creators and related beneficiaries. modern technical developments make it possible to extend the system of "reasonable remuneration" in cases where the realization of intellectual property as an absolute right is in doubt. In the section on the law applicable to intellectual property issues on the internet, article 8 par. 1 of the Rome II Regulation is analyzed , the difficulties in highlighting the applicable law on the internet, the possibility to provide the judge with a proportional application of the provisions of article 4 of Rome II Regulation to limit the applicable law by examining certain criteria, the proposal to apply the law of the country in the market affected by the infringement (" market impact "), as well as the current proposals regarding the law applicable to infringements of intellectual property on the Internet which converge towards the law of the country in which there is the closest connection with the infringement. In the section on the delimitation of digital rights/powers, the two basic property rights are analyzed, i.e. the right of reproduction in the digital environment and the right of digital distribution as a special manifestation of the right to present works to the public, and the relevant terminology regarding the concept of digitization is described. uploading , downloading , routing , caching , browsing, on demand calling and streaming. For the moral right it is pointed out that digital technology makes it easy to change, modify, fragment and distort the works, to spread the result of digital processing through networks and to remove any indication of authorship. The section on common Internet offenses analyzes issues such as the "limit" of private reproduction in the field of offense, sharing/sharing files over networks, placing/providing hyperlinks as an act of presentation to the public, user content generated content and the You example Tube . It is pointed out that the role of internet service providers (Internet Service Providers-ISPs ) are among the most controversial issues that have arisen regarding the internet and copyright infringement . The relevant solutions and proposals to solve the problems are examined (French system, reasonable remuneration) and it is found that the peers that peer networks are very useful, but their use must be carried out in moderation, that is, not only with the provision of penalties, but also with appropriate measures to protect intellectual works, such as filtering. The development of problems related to the operation of hyperlinks is also detailed . The problems for the content of online users are examined at this point based on Directive 2000/31 and the terms of use of You are analyzed Tube .The Fifth Chapter entitled "The protection of rights in the digital environment" deals with the protection of intellectual property rights in the digital world. EU member states have taken various legislative initiatives to combat online piracy, with the aim of harmonizing Directives 2001/29 and 2004/48. Many of them, however, did not produce the expected results for the reason that even today , there is no social awareness that the online availability and exchange of works, without the permission of the beneficiary, constitutes an illegal and criminally hellish act, while at the same time the identification of online users / of attackers conflicts, except in certain special cases, with the current European legislation on the protection of personal data and the privacy of communications, which also covers the location and movement data of these users. In the section on taking injunctive measures against mediators (article 64 A Law 2121/1993) it is argued that this is an innovative regulation of Directive 2001/29, because it gives the right to the beneficiaries to turn, not only against the persons who directly offend intellectual property rights, but also to those who mediate or facilitate the infringement. Intermediaries only provide services on the internet, they do not infringe copyright law themselves. In addition to the relevant provisions of Law 2121/1993, the application of article 64 is being considered A Law 2121/1993 on online insults based on the jurisprudence of the Greek courts. A separate section concerns article 66 E L. 2121/1993 and in the administrative procedure for strengthening the protection established by L. 4481/2017 in the model of foreign legislation. It is argued that provided the competent Commission respects the principle of proportionality and respects the fundamental rights of all parties involved (beneficiaries, users, providers ), the introduced procedure will ultimately be judged by its application in practice. Creative licenses are discussed in detail in the online troubleshooting section Commons , Free Software, and Alternative Dispute Resolution Procedures. Further it is argued that Blockchain is one of the cutting-edge technologies associated with the concept of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, which significantly affects the way businesses operate while revolutionizing many innovation ecosystems. For Directive 2019/790 it is pointed out that it is an important piece of legislation aimed at adapting protection to the digital single market. Specific provisions are foreseen for exceptions/limitations, arrangements to improve licensing practices , as well as to achieve the smooth functioning of the market for intellectual property rights. The regulation of Article 17 of the Directive establishes a new complex system of liability for providers of online content exchange services. Directive 2019/790 does not make any reference to the concept of the public and the other criteria for delimiting the right of presentation to the public, a fact from which it can be concluded that the provision of article 3 of the 2001 Directive is still taken into account for the interpretation of these concepts /29 in the context of the standing jurisprudence of the CJEU. An analysis is made of all the opinions that have been expressed as to whether or not Article 17 introduces a new right and it is pointed out that, with this provision, a new complex liability system is introduced for the providers of online content exchange services with increased due diligence obligations, which are accompanied and from an administrative cost. Regarding paragraph 7 of Article 17, which stipulates that cooperation between providers of online content exchange services and licensees should not lead to the prevention of the availability of such content, it is argued that the regulation is more like wishful thinking, since it does not appear at all that the filtering technology of content has gone so far as to distinguish cases that fall within the scope of legislative limitation of intellectual property. In particular, apart from the older CJEU jurisprudence, twelve CJEU decisions are critically analyzed, this jurisprudence is evaluated and then the jurisprudence of the national courts is examined. The decisions analyzed are timely and of particular importance. This is the case law Promusicae , Scarlet , Footbal Dataco , Svensson , Pickney , Pez Hejduk , C More Entertainment , Bestwater , Public Relations Consultants Association, Tom Kabinet , You Tube /Google, as well as the Poland Case. The importance of the decision 4658/2012 of the Single-Member Court of First Instance of Athens is highlighted, which is the first to apply article 64A of Law. 2121/1993, a provision which incorporates a regulation of the EU acquis for the possibility of taking injunctive measures against intermediaries whose services are used by a third party to infringe the right of the creator or a related right, as well as the contrary decision 13478/2014 Law of which rejected the applications judging, among other things, that with the application of the requested measure ( blocking ) , access to websites or services, which may contain or distribute pirated content, but not only such, is excluded, applying the principle of proportionality. The decision C-401/2019 of the ECJ Poland v. European Parliament and Council is analyzed for the annulment of the provision either only of Article 17 paragraph 4 items b) and c) or of Article 17 in its entirety due to its incompatibility with freedom of expression as guaranteed by the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (Article 11 of the Charter). The Court mostly followed the positions of the Attorney General. He held that Article 17 can only be assessed as a whole, which means that Article 17(4)(b) and (c) should not be assessed separately. The Court confirmed that Article 17 requires online content sharing service providers to carry out prior screening of uploaded content in cases where rights holders have provided "relevant and necessary information". Finally, the transposition of Article 17 of Directive 2019/790 into German law and the method chosen for its integration are analyzed.In the Conclusions/Final Remarks it is argued that the protective framework is sufficient in terms of dealing with infringements of intellectual property, while the fact that the legislation is constantly being enriched, especially with the recent Directive 2019/790, demonstrates the attempt to adapt the law to technological developments but and their utilization by the legislator. The intellectual creator is inherently unable to precisely control the circulation of his work in the online environment, due to the structure and organization of the internet, the emergence of internet service providers and the easy access of countless users to protected content. The law seems to be moving in tandem with the continuous developments in the world of the internet and technology in finding the "golden ratio" between the interests of the intellectual creator and those who have access to his works. Legislation is constantly evolving, especially with Directives 2019/789 and 2019/790, in an effort to adapt the law to technological developments. The willingness of the legislator to evolve the law of intellectual property, so that it keeps pace with the developments that are constantly taking place in the digital world, is hopeful.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Papadopoulos, Sotirios
  • Παπαδόπουλος, Σωτήριος

Subjects

dc:subject × 7

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/52066

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Papadopoulos, Sotirios; Παπαδόπουλος, Σωτήριος. Η έννομη προστασία της πνευματικής ιδιοκτησίας στο πεδίο του ιδιωτικού δικαίου. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/52066