Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Εκτελεστοί τίτλοι κατά του ελληνικού δημοσίου

Abstract

dc:description

The subject of this thesis is to investigate the enforceable titles which constitute the basis for execution against the Greek State, especially after the 2001 Revision of the Greek Constitution and the entry into force of the relevant provisions of the implementing law 3068/2002 as amended by Law 3301/2004 and Article 326 § 5 of Law 4072/2012 under the influence of European Convention on Human Rights, of International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights as well as the European Regulations 805/2004, 1896/2006 and 1215/2012.The primary purpose of the thesis was the evaluation of the broad regulatory framework that governs the enforceable titles that the creditor can expedite forced execution against the Greek State. The thesis takes into account all the theoretical and jurisprudential positions expressed on the issue as well as the international and European legislative data which influence the proposed solutions.The introductory part refers to the previous regulatory framework of the prohibition of execution against the Greek State - as well as public institutions and legal entities under public law - which found a justification for their exceptional position and the protection of their financial interests. The securing of the generally privileged treatment of the Greek State as a trader was pointed out and raised questions as to the necessity of introducing this particular special treatment when it was not imposed for reasons of public interest. The invocation of the need to comply with the state budget, which was borne by the relevant expenses for the execution of court decisions adjudicating monetary claims against the Greek State, is not, in our view, a sufficient justification for its long experience, according to common experience. of the winning party, until the relevant final court decision becomes irrevocable.The first part of this study focuses on de facto and then to de jure abolition of the prevailing prohibition framework of enforcement against the State under the influence of international and EU law, which had been granted preferentially by the domestic legislator: The regulatory scope of the provisions of the ECHR, as well as the most important case law of the NRA ensuring the effective exercise of the supra -legislative right to provide effective legal protection, an aspect of which is the right of enforcement.It is also pointed out that the possible adoption of rules by the common legislator, which protect the State from any enforcement procedure by invoking reasons of public interest, is not in accordance with the above constitutional provisions. For the application of the provisions of the Constitution, we should not equate the cash interest of the State with the public interest in order to place restrictions on the right of compulsory execution. Such an approach would be outside the will of the constitutional legislator who did not want to introduce any exception to the right of enforcement of the individual against the State. Thus, with the analysis of the constitutional provisions of articles 20 par. 1, 94 par. 4 and 95 par. 5, 4 par. 1 and 25 par. 1 ed . d) the constitutional framework of judicial protection against the State is deleted.Then, in the second part, the enforceable titles that can establish enforcement against the State are presented in detail. In particular, within the framework of the Greek legal order, the following categories of enforceable titles can be distinguished:I) The national enforceable titles of article 904 of the Code of Civil Procedure (especially domestic decisions and orders as well as other securities) on the basis of which the creditor is entitled to expedite the enforcement procedureΙΙ) The foreign enforceable titles that are declared enforceable by the Greek courts with the special procedure provided by the Code of Civil Procedure (procedure of article 905 § 1 Code of Civil Procedure if the relevant conditions are met)III) Intra-Community instruments enforced within the European Judicial Area pursuant to Regulations: 1215/2012, 805/2004 and 1896/2006IV ) Foreign enforcement titles that are declared enforceable by Greek courts if the conditions of international or bilateral agreements that Greece has signed and ratified by law are met. V ) Judgments of supranational courts: a) the European Court of Human Rights and b) the Court of Justice of the European Union VI ) Foreign arbitral awardsIn the chapter on conclusive judgments, the issues of enforceable titles to the detriment of the State, of temporary enforceability but also of the irrevocability of the decision as a precondition for enforcement seem to have been regulated in the right direction at first sight. The authors of Law 4072/2012 chose with a single and short wording to adopt the solutions of the jurisprudence, giving them legislative validity. If, however, the previous theoretical and jurisprudential developments of Law 4072/2012 are taken into account regarding each of these issues, then, it is obvious that the legislative intervention actually led to a setback: The dependence of the validity of enforcement on the State from the filing of a letter of guarantee without exception for all the executed securities, without any rating depending on the stage of their procedural maturity is problematic. The domestic case law does not seem to have been convinced by the justification for the introduction of this regulation on the protection of public property and with the first decisions it considered that the provision in question is contrary to the Constitution and the principle of equality of the parties. The attempted cancellation of the possibility of enforcement against the State seems to have been prevented for the time being, but the risk still lurks until the legislative repeal or modification of the restrictions.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2022

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Karkania, Maria
  • Καρκανιά, Μαρία

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/52094

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Karkania, Maria; Καρκανιά, Μαρία. Εκτελεστοί τίτλοι κατά του ελληνικού δημοσίου. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2022. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/52094